Clustering time-course microarray data using functional Bayesian infinite mixture model

This paper presents a new Bayesian, infinite mixture model based, clustering approach, specifically designed for time-course microarray data. The problem is to group together genes which have “similar” expression profiles, given the set of noisy measurements of their expression levels over a specific time interval. In order to capture temporal variations of each curve, a non-parametric regression approach is used. Each expression profile is expanded over a set of basis functions and the sets of coefficients of each curve are subsequently modeled through a Bayesian infinite mixture of Gaussian distributions. Therefore, the task of finding clusters of genes with similar expression profiles is then reduced to the problem of grouping together genes whose coefficients are sampled from the same distribution in the mixture. Dirichlet processes prior is naturally employed in such kinds of models, since it allows one to deal automatically with the uncertainty about the number of clusters. The posterior inference is carried out by a split and merge MCMC sampling scheme which integrates out parameters of the component distributions and updates only the latent vector of the cluster membership. The final configuration is obtained via the maximum a posteriori estimator. The performance of the method is studied using synthetic and real microarray data and is compared with the performances of competitive techniques.     

Empirical null distribution-based modeling of multi-class differential gene expression detection

In this paper, we study the multi-class differential gene expression detection for microarray data. We propose a likelihood-based approach to estimating an empirical null distribution to incorporate gene interactions and provide a more accurate false-positive control than the commonly used permutation or theoretical null distribution-based approach. We propose to rank important genes by p-values or local false discovery rate based on the estimated empirical null distribution. Through simulations and application to lung transplant microarray data, we illustrate the competitive performance of the proposed method.     

Randomization tests for small samples: an application for genetic expression data

Summary. An advantage of randomization tests for small samples is that an exact P -value can be computed under an additive model. A disadvantage with very small sample sizes is that the resulting discrete distribution for P -values can make it mathematically impossible for a P -value to attain a particular degree of significance. We investigate a distribution of P -values that arises when several thousand randomization tests are conducted simultaneously using small samples, a situation that arises with microarray gene expression data. We show that the distribution yields valuable information regarding groups of genes that are differentially expressed between two groups: a treatment group and a control group. This distribution helps to categorize genes with varying degrees of overlap of genetic expression values between the two groups, and it helps to quantify the degree of overlap by using the P -value from a randomization test. Moreover, a statistical test is available that compares the actual distribution of P -values with an expected distribution if there are no genes that are differentially expressed. We demonstrate the method and illustrate the results by using a microarray data set involving a cell line for rheumatoid arthritis. A small simulation study evaluates the effect that correlated gene expression levels could have on results from the analysis.     

A new approach: Interrelated two-way clustering of gene expression data

The paper presents a new approach to interrelated two-way clustering of gene expression data. Clustering of genes has been effected using entropy and a correlation measure, whereas the samples have been clustered using the fuzzy C-means. The efficiency of this approach has been tested on two well known data sets: the colon cancer data set and the leukemia data set. Using this approach, we were able to identify the important co-regulated genes and group the samples efficiently at the same time.     

Hadamard matrix methods in identifying differentially expressed genes from microarray experiments

Identifying differentially expressed genes is a basic objective in microarray experiments. Many statistical methods for detecting differentially expressed genes in multiple-slide experiments have been proposed. However, sometimes with limited experimental resources, only a single cDNA array or two Oligonuleotide arrays could be made or only insufficient replicated arrays could be conducted. Many current statistical models cannot be used because of the non-availability of replicated data. Simply using fold changes is also unreliable and inefficient [Chen et al. 1997. Ratio-based decisions and the quantitative analysis of cDNA microarray images. J. Biomed. Optics 2, 364–374; Newton et al. 2001. On differential variability of expression ratios: improving statistical inference about gene expression changes from microarray data. J. Comput. Biol. 8, 37–52; Pan et al. 2002. How many replicates of arrays are required to detect gene expression changes in microarray experiments? a mixture model approach. Genome Biol. 3, research0022.1-0022.10]. We propose a new method. If the log-transformed ratios for the expressed genes as well as unexpressed genes have equal variance, we use a Hadamard matrix to construct a t-test from a single array data. Basically, we test whether each doubtful gene has significantly differential expression compared to the unexpressed genes. We form some new random variables corresponding to the rows of a Hadamard matrix using the algebraic sum of gene expressions. A one-sample t-test is constructed and the p-value is calculated for each doubtful gene based on these random variables. By using any method for multiple testing, adjusted p-values could be obtained from original p-values and significance of doubtful genes can be determined. When the variance of expressed genes differs from the variance of unexpressed genes, we construct a z-statistic based on the result from application of Hadamard matrix and find the confidence interval to retain the null hypothesis. Using the interval, we determine differentially expressed genes. This method is also useful for multiple microarrays, especially when sufficient replicated data are not available for a traditional t-test. We apply our methodology to ApoAI data. The results appear to be promising. They not only confirm the early known differentially expressed genes, but also indicate more genes to be differentially expressed.     

Bayesian curve fitting and clustering with Dirichlet process mixture models for microarray data

In the field of molecular biology, it is often of interest to analyze microarray data for clustering genes based on similar profiles of gene expression to identify genes that are differentially expressed under multiple biological conditions. One of the notable characteristics of a gene expression profile is that it shows a cyclic curve over a course of time. To group sequences of similar molecular functions, we propose a Bayesian Dirichlet process mixture of linear regression models with a Fourier series for the regression coefficients, for each of which a spike and slab prior is assumed. A full Gibbs-sampling algorithm is developed for an efficient Markov chain Monte Carlo (MCMC) posterior computation. Due to the so-called “label-switching” problem and different numbers of clusters during the MCMC computation, a post-process approach of Fritsch and Ickstadt (2009) is additionally applied to MCMC samples for an optimal single clustering estimate by maximizing the posterior expected adjusted Rand index with the posterior probabilities of two observations being clustered together. The proposed method is illustrated with two simulated data and one real data of the physiological response of fibroblasts to serum of Iyer et al. (1999).     

Selection bias in working with the top genes in supervised classification of tissue samples

Currently there is much interest in using microarray gene-expression data to form prediction rules for the diagnosis of patient outcomes. A process of gene selection is usually carried out first to find those genes that are most useful according to some criterion for distinguishing between the given classes of tissue samples. However, there is a bias (selection bias) introduced in the estimate of the final version of a prediction rule that has been formed from a smaller subset of the genes that have been selected according to some optimality criterion. In this paper, we focus on the bias that arises when a full data set is not available in the first instance and the prediction rule is formed subsequently by working with the top-ranked genes from the full set. We demonstrate how large the subset of top genes must be before this selection bias is not of practical consequence.     

Bayesian mixture model averaging for identifying the different gene expressions of chickpea (Cicer arietinum) plant tissue

Identification of different gene expressions of chickpea (Cicer arietinum) plant tissue is needed in order to develop new varieties of chickpea plant which is resistant to disease through the insertion of genes. This plant is the third legume plant of the Leguminosae (Fabaceae) family and is much needed in the world due to its high-protein seeds and roots that contain symbiotic nitrogen-fixing bacteria. This paper has succeeded to demonstrate the work of Bayesian mixture model averaging (BMMA) approach to identify the different gene expressions of chickpea plant tissue in Indonesia. The results show that the best BMMA normal models contain from 727 (73%) up to 939 (94%) models from 1,000 generated mixture normal models. The fitted BMMA models to gene expression differences data on average is 0.2878511 for Kolmogorov–Smirnov (KS) and 0.1278080 for continuous rank probability score (CRPS). Based on these BMMA models, there are three groups of gene IDs: downregulated, regulated, and upregulated. The results of this grouping can be useful to find new varieties of chickpea plants that are more resistant to disease. The BMMA normal models coupled with Occam's window as a data-driven modeling have succeed to demonstrate the work of building the gene expression differences microarray experiments data.     

Hierarchical Bayesian meta-analysis models for cross-platform microarray studies

The development of new technologies to measure gene expression has been calling for statistical methods to integrate findings across multiple-platform studies. A common goal of microarray analysis is to identify genes with differential expression between two conditions, such as treatment versus control. Here, we introduce a hierarchical Bayesian meta-analysis model to pool gene expression studies from different microarray platforms: spotted DNA arrays and short oligonucleotide arrays. The studies have different array design layouts, each with multiple sources of data replication, including repeated experiments, slides and probes. Our model produces the gene-specific posterior probability of differential expression, which is the basis for inference. In simulations combining two and five independent studies, our meta-analysis model outperformed separate analyses for three commonly used comparison measures; it also showed improved receiver operating characteristic curves. When combining spotted DNA and CombiMatrix short oligonucleotide array studies of Geobacter sulfurreducens, our meta-analysis model discovered more genes for fixed thresholds of posterior probability of differential expression and Bayesian false discovery than individual study analyses. We also examine an alternative model and compare models using the deviance information criterion.     

High dimensional extension of the growth curve model and its application in genetics

Recent advances in technology have allowed researchers to collect large scale complex biological data, simultaneously, often in matrix format. In genomic studies, for instance, measurements from tens to hundreds of thousands of genes are taken from individuals across several experimental groups. In time course microarray experiments, gene expression is measured at several time points for each individual across the whole genome resulting in a high-dimensional matrix for each gene. In such experiments, researchers are faced with high-dimensional longitudinal data. Unfortunately, traditional methods for longitudinal data are not appropriate for high-dimensional situations. In this paper, we use the growth curve model and introduce test useful for high-dimensional longitudinal data and evaluate its performance using simulations. We also show how our approach can be used to filter genes in time course genomic experiments. We illustrate this using publicly available genomic data, involving experiments comparing normal human lung tissue with vanadium pentoxide treated human lung tissue, designed with the aim of understanding the susceptibility of individuals working in petro-chemical factories to airway re-modelling. Using our method, we were able to filter out 1053 (about 5 %) genes as non-noise genes from a pool of  22,277. Although our focus is on hypothesis testing, we also provided modified maximum likelihood estimator for the mean parameter of the growth curve model and assessed its performance through bias and mean squared error.     

Bayesian Analysis on a Noncentral Fisher–Student’s Hypersphere

Fisher succeeded early on in redefining Student’s t-distribution in geometrical terms on a central hypersphere. Intriguingly, a noncentral analytical extension for this fundamental Fisher–Student’s central hypersphere h-distribution does not exist. We therefore set to derive the noncentral h-distribution and use it to graphically illustrate the limitations of the Neyman–Pearson null hypothesis significance testing framework and the strengths of the Bayesian statistical hypothesis analysis framework on the hypersphere polar axis, a compact nontrivial one-dimensional parameter space. Using a geometrically meaningful maximal entropy prior, we requalify the apparent failure of an important psychological science reproducibility project. We proceed to show that the Bayes factor appropriately models the two-sample t-test p-value density of a gene expression profile produced by the high-throughput genomic-scale microarray technology, and provides a simple expression for a local false discovery rate addressing the multiple hypothesis testing problem brought about by such a technology.     

Clustering transformed compositional data using K-means,with applications in gene expression and bicycle sharing system data

Although there is no shortage of clustering algorithms proposed in the literature, the question of the most relevant strategy for clustering compositional data (i.e. data whose rows belong to the simplex) remains largely unexplored in cases where the observed value is equal or close to zero for one or more samples. This work is motivated by the analysis of two applications, both focused on the categorization of compositional profiles: (1) identifying groups of co-expressed genes from high-throughput RNA sequencing data, in which a given gene may be completely silent in one or more experimental conditions; and (2) finding patterns in the usage of stations over the course of one week in the Velib' bicycle sharing system in Paris, France. For both of these applications, we make use of appropriately chosen data transformations, including the Centered Log Ratio and a novel extension called the Log Centered Log Ratio, in conjunction with the K-means algorithm. We use a non-asymptotic penalized criterion, whose penalty is calibrated with the slope heuristics, to select the number of clusters. Finally, we illustrate the performance of this clustering strategy, which is implemented in the Bioconductor package coseq, on both the gene expression and bicycle sharing system data.     

On simultaneous confidence intervals based on rank-estimates with application to analysis of gene expression data

Abstract

Inferential methods based on ranks present robust and powerful alternative methodology for testing and estimation. In this article, two objectives are followed. First, develop a general method of simultaneous confidence intervals based on the rank estimates of the parameters of a general linear model and derive the asymptotic distribution of the pivotal quantity. Second, extend the method to high dimensional data such as gene expression data for which the usual large sample approximation does not apply. It is common in practice to use the asymptotic distribution to make inference for small samples. The empirical investigation in this article shows that for methods based on the rank-estimates, this approach does not produce a viable inference and should be avoided. A method based on the bootstrap is outlined and it is shown to provide a reliable and accurate method of constructing simultaneous confidence intervals based on rank estimates. In particular it is shown that commonly applied methods of normal or t-approximation are not satisfactory, particularly for large-scale inferences. Methods based on ranks are uniquely suitable for analysis of microarray gene expression data since they often involve large scale inferences based on small samples containing a large number of outliers and violate the assumption of normality. A real microarray data is analyzed using the rank-estimate simultaneous confidence intervals. Viability of the proposed method is assessed through a Monte Carlo simulation study under varied assumptions.     

Simultaneous rank tests for detecting differentially expressed genes

Rank tests are known to be robust to outliers and violation of distributional assumptions. Two major issues besetting microarray data are violation of the normality assumption and contamination by outliers. In this article, we formulate the normal theory simultaneous tests and their aligned rank transformation (ART) analog for detecting differentially expressed genes. These tests are based on the least-squares estimates of the effects when data follow a linear model. Application of the two methods are then demonstrated on a real data set. To evaluate the performance of the aligned rank transform method with the corresponding normal theory method, data were simulated according to the characteristics of a real gene expression data. These simulated data are then used to compare the two methods with respect to their sensitivity to the distributional assumption and to outliers for controlling the family-wise Type I error rate, power, and false discovery rate. It is demonstrated that the ART generally possesses the robustness of validity property even for microarray data with small number of replications. Although these methods can be applied to more general designs, in this article the simulation study is carried out for a dye-swap design since this design is broadly used in cDNA microarray experiments.     

Mixture model on the variance for the differential analysis of gene expression data

Summary.  In microarray experiments, accurate estimation of the gene variance is a key step in the identification of differentially expressed genes. Variance models go from the too stringent homoscedastic assumption to the overparameterized model assuming a specific variance for each gene. Between these two extremes there is some room for intermediate models. We propose a method that identifies clusters of genes with equal variance. We use a mixture model on the gene variance distribution. A test statistic for ranking and detecting differentially expressed genes is proposed. The method is illustrated with publicly available complementary deoxyribonucleic acid microarray experiments, an unpublished data set and further simulation studies.     

A modified two-sample t-test based on permutation method for large-scale data

In large-scale data, for example, analyzing microarray data, which includes hypothesis testing for equality of means in order to discover differentially expressed genes, often deals with a large number of features versus a few number of replicates. Furthermore, some genes are differentially expressed and some others not. Thus, a usual permutation method, which is applied facing these situations, estimates the p-value poorly. This is because two types of genes are mixed. To overcome this obstacle, the null permutation samples are suggested in the literatures. We propose a modified uniformly most powerful unbiased test for testing the null hypothesis.