大陆儒教派的学术理路评析

大陆"儒教是教"说的提出引发了关于儒学是否为宗教问题的长期争论,有必要对其观点和学理进行宏观的审视和客观的评价。大陆儒教派一是受西方学者研究儒教的影响,以西方近代科学主义的理路判释儒教,以西方宗教来比附儒教;二是在马克思主义教条化及其长期的浸润下,以二元对抗思维指导学术研究,使儒教研究步入误区;三是在西方实体主义的影响下,以儒教为中国文化的本质存在,并把儒教对象化、断裂化、抽象化、绝对化。

On the Academic line of Reasoning of Confucian Religion School in the Mainland of China

The theory of scholars in the mainland of China that "Confucianism is religion" led to the long-lasting controversies over whether or not confucianism is religion.A macroexamination and objective evaluation of the theory and line of reasoning become necessary.Firstly,Confucianists of mainland are influenced by Western scholars in studying confucianism and compare Confucianism to Western religions.Secondly,greatly and dogmatically influenced by Marxism,Confucianists of the mainland do acdemic researches under the guidance of dual antagonistic thinking which misleads researches on Confucianism;Thirdly,influenced by Western substantism,mainland scholars study confucianism unilaterally,abstractly and absolutely.