论中国婚姻法在法律体系中地位研究之误区——兼与婚姻法私法论商榷

国内有关婚姻法在法律体系中地位的主要论述,主要散见于各种教科书和婚姻法修改论争中。主流观点可称为婚姻法私法论,其主张婚姻法属于私法应“回归民法”,并适用私法自治原则,在婚姻法中建立全面的权利体系。然而,有关论述普遍存在论证过程简单、论证逻辑错误、缺乏论证、研究视角单一等问题,而难以具有说服力。有关婚姻法在法律体系中的地位问题,应改变从理论到理论的研究思路,应扎根于社会生活本身,从实际出发,从有利于解决中国婚姻家庭的实际问题出发作扎实的研究。

A Comment on the Justification of the Status of Marriage Law

The paper sorts out and analyses the main opinions on the status of marriage law in our country's legal system, especially those believing marriage law is private law and self-determination principle of private law could be applied. The author believes that many issues, such as reasoning logics, knowledge basis and methodology, should be paid more consideration. It is pointed out that the justification is not persuasive enough to come to the conclusion, and deeper and further research is needed.