A simulation study of the nearest neighbour analysis method of papadakis

The relative performances of randomised block, balanced lattice squares and Papadakis nearest neighbour analyses were compared on two simulated fields whose soil heterogeneity profiles were generated, one with a few evenly spaced contours and the other with many unevenly spaced contours. Four levels of random error were generated to simulate different proportions of random error and soil heterogeneity. Dummy treatments, corresponding to 7 x 7 and 11 x 11 balanced lattice squares were applied to the fields. The results from simulated experiments showed an interaction of error mean square (EMS) between size of experiment (7 x 7, 11 x 11) and levels of soil heterogeneity in the lattice analyses, but no such interaction in the Papadakis analyses. The Papadakis EMS decreased as random error decreased but at a rate depending on the map andthe ratio of soil heterogeneity to random error.