也谈诸葛亮忠于蜀汉说——兼与朱子彦先生商榷

上海大学的朱子彦先生在其《诸葛亮忠于蜀汉说再认识》一文中指出:诸葛亮秉政时,不仅大权独揽,且以“太上皇”自居,其竭尽全力北伐,其目的不是为了“兴复汉室”,而是冀图通过北伐来树立绝对权威,一旦条件成熟,“诸葛亮本人,抑或其子孙极有可能易代更祚,登上帝位。”本文认为朱文的这一观点建立在感性化的认识与判断上,缺乏事实依据,很有商榷之必要,故对朱文的基本观点提出质疑。

The Opinion on Zhu Geliang's Cleaving to Shuhan

Professor Zhu Ziyan in Shanghai University points out in his paper Recognition of Zhu Geliang's Cleaving to Shuhan(that) when Zhu Geliang was in power he arrogated to the political power and set himself up as overlord.It also says that the purpose of his exertion to Northern expedition was not to restorate Han Dynasty but to build up his absolute authority.And only the conditions reached,Zhu Geliang himself or his offspring would usurp the throng.The thesis points the paper of Professor Zhu bases on perceptual opinion and lacks basis in fact.The author contests professor Zhu's opinion.