担保权的性质另有看法

把担保权作为物权是一种有逻辑缺陷的思维,是学者抄袭德国、台湾地区物权理论而并未对物权本质做深入思考而做出的错误理解。通过对物权本质特别是物权必须对物进行直接支配的性质的透彻分析可以得出担保权不是物权的论断,通过对形成权及担保权特征的对比,可以认为担保权是一种积极的形成权。

A Different View on the Essence of the Security Right

It is an idea with logical defect to regard the security right as a real right,ist is also a mistaken comprehension that scholars have achieved based on copying the real right theory from Germany,Taiwan instead of looking into the essence of the real right.Through the analysis on the essence of the real right,especially the quality of the real right having the direct control over the substance,it is concluded that the security right is not the real right.By the comparison of the security right and the right...