Robustness of MML estimators based on censored samples and robust test statistics

We investigate the efficiences of Tiku's (1967) modified maximum likelihood estimators μ_c and σ_c (based on symmetrically censored normal samples) for estimating the location and scale parameters μ and σ of symmetric non-normal distributions. We show that μ_c and σ_c are jointly more efficient than x? and s for long-tailed distributions (kurtosis $\text{β}{}_2{}^1\text{=}\text{μ}{}_4\text{μ}{}_2{}^2\text{>4.2, β}{}_2{}^1\text{= 4.2}$ for the Logistic), and always more efficient than the trimmed mean μT and the matching sample estimate σ_T of σ. We also show that μ_c and σ_c are jointly at least as efficient as some of the more prominent “robust” estimators (Gross, 1976). We show that the statistic $\text{t}{}_{\mathrm{c}}\text{= μ}{}_{\mathrm{c}}\text{m}\text{σ}{}_{\mathrm{c}}\text{, m = n ?2r + 2rβ}$ (r is the number of observations censored on each side of the sample and β is a constant), is robust and powerful for testing an assumed value of μ. We define a statistic T_c (based on μ_c andσ_c) for testing that two symmetric distributions are identical and show that T_c is robust and generally more poweerful than the well-known nonparametric statistics (Wilcoxon, normal-score, Kolmogorov-Smirnov), against the important location-shift alternatives. We generalize the statistic T_c to test that k symmetric distibutions are identical. The asymptotic distributions of t_c and T_c are normal, under some very general regularity conditions. For small samples, the upper (lower) percentage points of t_c and T_c are shown to be closely approximated by Student's t-distributions. Besides, the statistics μ_c and σ_c (and hence t_c and T_c) are explicit and simple functions of sample observations and are easy to compute.