Uniform robustness against nonnormality of the t and f tests

The size of the two-sample t test is generally thought to be robust against nonnormal distributions if the sample sizes are large. This belief is based on central limit theory, and asymptotic expansions of the moments of the t statistic suggest that robustness may be improved for moderate sample sizes if the variance, skewness, and kurtosis of the distributions are matched, particularly if the sample sizes are also equal.

It is shown that asymptotic arguments such as these can be misleading and that, in fact, the size of the t test can be as large as unity if the distributions are allowed to be completely arbitrary. Restricting the distributions to be identical or symmetric (but otherwise arbitrary) does not guarantee that the size can be controlled either, but controlling the tail-heaviness of the distributions does. The last result is proved more generally for the k-sample F test.