Making robust the cross-validatory choice of smoothing parameter in spline smoothing regression

Cross-validation as a means of choosing the smoothing parameter in spline regression has achieved a wide popularity. Its appeal comprises of an automatic method based on an attractive criterion and along with many other methods it has been shown to minimize predictive mean square error asymptotically. However, in practice there may be a substantial proportion of applications where a cross-validation style choice may lead to drastic undersmoothing often as far as interpolation. Furthermore, because the criterion is so appealing the user may be misled by an inappropriate, automatically-chosen value. In this paper we investigate the nature of cross-validatory methods in spline smoothing regression and suggest variants which provide small sample protection against undersmoothing.