我国行政裁量权的司法审查制度分析

根据我国<行政诉讼法>的规定,人民法院对行政行为进行司法审查时,只能进行合法性审查,而行政裁量权的行使不仅仅涉及合法性的问题,还涉及到合理性的问题.因此,在我国的现行法律框架下,能否对行政裁量权进行司法审查还存在着争议.本文对行政裁量权能够纳入现行司法审查的范围进行了论证,并对司法审查的标准提出了设想.

Analysis of judicial review system of administrative discretionary right of China

According to Administrative Litigation Law, people's courts can only make legal examination when they make judicial review on administrative behavior but administrative discretionary right surpasses the legal issue. Thus, under China current laws, there is disputing about judicial review on administrative discretionary right. This paper discusses the category of judicial review on administrative discretionary right and gives suggestions for the standard of judicial review.