首页 | 本学科首页   官方微博 | 高级检索  
     检索      

报告文学的批判"退位"了吗--与范培松先生商榷
引用本文:章罗生,杨建华.报告文学的批判"退位"了吗--与范培松先生商榷[J].湖南大学学报(社会科学版),2004,18(2):98-103.
作者姓名:章罗生  杨建华
作者单位:湖南大学,文学院,湖南,长沙,410082
摘    要:文章针对<论九十年代报告文学的批判退位>提出完全相反的看法,认为90年代报告文学不但未"批判退位",而且走向了深化、成熟与自觉第一,问题报告文学不但未成为"明日黄花",而且已向纵深发展为重要品类;作家们不但未"自动放弃批判",而且坚持了精神操守;第二,90年代报告文学并非"趋向甜蜜化",而是适当调整和正确处理了歌颂与批判等关系;即使是没有"深刻批判内涵"的"颂歌",也与"战歌"相互补充;第三,"泛批判"报告文学不但未导致批判"钝化",而且促进了批判"深化";"特指"批判与"泛指"批判相互融合、共同发展.最后,产生"退位"说的原因是未全面、深入从整体上把握80年代与90年代文学的创作实际.

关 键 词:报告文学  批判  退位  商榷
文章编号:1008-1763(2004)02-0098-06
修稿时间:2003年6月18日

Has the Reportage's Critique Abdicated
ZHANG Luo-sheng,YANG Jian-hua.Has the Reportage''s Critique Abdicated[J].Journal of Hunan University(Social Sciences),2004,18(2):98-103.
Authors:ZHANG Luo-sheng  YANG Jian-hua
Abstract:The thesis put forward contrary viewpoints to the paper declaring the critique's Abdicate of 1990's reportage. The 1990's reportage critique did not abdicate but headed for depth, maturity and consciousness: First, problem reportage did not fade out but developed an important variety; the writers did not abandoned critique automatically but adhered to the sentiment in spirit; Second, 1990's reportage not tend to sweeten but readjust appropriately, and correctly deal with the relation between eulogizes and critiques; even if it was ode of lacking deep critique intension, it also replenished with battle song each other; Third, general-critique reportage not only has not resulted in critique's passivity but also advanced deepening of critique; the special critique and general critique mixed each other and developed side by side. At last, the cause of believing abdication is the lack of overall understanding to the creative practice of literature in 1980's and 1990's.
Keywords:reportage  critique  abdicate  discuss
本文献已被 CNKI 万方数据 等数据库收录!
点击此处可从《湖南大学学报(社会科学版)》浏览原始摘要信息
点击此处可从《湖南大学学报(社会科学版)》下载免费的PDF全文
设为首页 | 免责声明 | 关于勤云 | 加入收藏

Copyright©北京勤云科技发展有限公司  京ICP备09084417号