宋初“九僧”诗人群体形成辨

王传龙《“九僧”生卒年限及群体形成考》一文以为，九僧群体形成于京师，形成于馆阁，《九僧诗》是类似《西昆酬唱集》一样的馆阁吟唱结晶，其清邃淡泊的诗风并非真实山林景色的映现。实际上，从《九僧诗》之结集与诗歌内容考辨可知，九僧诗人群体的形成于九僧四处云游期间，且其周围有一个庞大的诗人群体。九僧所结交之名卿也非达官显贵，而多为文士词臣，彼此是基于文学互动的交游。

An Inquiry into the Formation of Nine Monk Poet Group in Early Song Dynasty

Wang Chuanlong believed that nine monks group was formed in the Imperial Academy in the capital of China and "Nine Monk Poems", similar to “Xi Kun Chou Chang” was not a true reflection of the real landscape of land and forest. This paper puts forward the view that Nine Monk Poets are formed in their roaming from place to place, and a large group of poets are gathered around them. The friends nine monks made are not famous officials, but are literary figures