Forecasting Performance of an Open Economy DSGE Model

This paper analyzes the forecasting performance of an open economy dynamic stochastic general equilibrium (DSGE) model, estimated with Bayesian methods, for the Euro area during 1994Q1–2002Q4. We compare the DSGE model and a few variants of this model to various reduced-form forecasting models such as vector autoregressions (VARs) and vector error correction models (VECM), estimated both by maximum likelihood and two different Bayesian approaches, and traditional benchmark models, e.g., the random walk. The accuracy of point forecasts, interval forecasts and the predictive distribution as a whole are assessed in an out-of-sample rolling event evaluation using several univariate and multivariate measures. The results show that the open economy DSGE model compares well with more empirical models and thus that the tension between rigor and fit in older generations of DSGE models is no longer present. We also critically examine the role of Bayesian model probabilities and other frequently used low-dimensional summaries, e.g., the log determinant statistic, as measures of overall forecasting performance.     

Forecasting Performance of an Open Economy DSGE Model

This paper analyzes the forecasting performance of an open economy dynamic stochastic general equilibrium (DSGE) model, estimated with Bayesian methods, for the Euro area during 1994Q1-2002Q4. We compare the DSGE model and a few variants of this model to various reduced-form forecasting models such as vector autoregressions (VARs) and vector error correction models (VECM), estimated both by maximum likelihood and two different Bayesian approaches, and traditional benchmark models, e.g., the random walk. The accuracy of point forecasts, interval forecasts and the predictive distribution as a whole are assessed in an out-of-sample rolling event evaluation using several univariate and multivariate measures. The results show that the open economy DSGE model compares well with more empirical models and thus that the tension between rigor and fit in older generations of DSGE models is no longer present. We also critically examine the role of Bayesian model probabilities and other frequently used low-dimensional summaries, e.g., the log determinant statistic, as measures of overall forecasting performance.     

Bayesian Analysis of DSGE Models

This paper reviews Bayesian methods that have been developed in recent years to estimate and evaluate dynamic stochastic general equilibrium (DSGE) models. We consider the estimation of linearized DSGE models, the evaluation of models based on Bayesian model checking, posterior odds comparisons, and comparisons to vector autoregressions, as well as the non-linear estimation based on a second-order accurate model solution. These methods are applied to data generated from correctly specified and misspecified linearized DSGE models and a DSGE model that was solved with a second-order perturbation method.     

基于多重尝试Metropolis算法的非线性DSGE模型贝叶斯推断

本文提出一种改进的多重尝试Metropolis算法,用于非线性动态随机一般均衡模型的贝叶斯参数估计和模型选择。多重尝试策略通过每次迭代抽取多个尝试点的方法来提高算法的混合速率,新方法中提出使用近似的方法提高计算速度,并通过接收概率调整偏差。数值实验表明新方法在相同的计算时间内具有更高的估计效率。最后,本文比较了具有不同货币政策设定的模型对中国经济数据的拟合效果,发现中国数据更加支持具有时变通胀目标的模型。     

Comment on An and Schorfheide's Bayesian Analysis of DSGE Models

An and Schorfheide's article provides an excellent review of Bayesian estimation of DSGE models. Rather than recapitulating the points already made in this article, my comment focuses on three aspects. It proposes a convergence measure to take account of serial correlation of MCMC draws, explains why the DSGE-VAR framework for policy analysis can be improved by avoiding the ad hoc identification assumption, and discusses an alternative structural approach to model misspecification.     

A Bayesian analysis of exogeneity in models pooling time-series and cross-sectional data

The analysis of exogeneity in econometric time-series models as formalized in the seminal paper by Engle et al. [Econometrica 51 (1983), 277–304] is extended to cover a more general class of models, including error-components models. The Bayesian framework adopted here allows us to take full advantage of a number of statistical tools, related to the reduction of Bayesian experiments, and motivates a careful consideration of prediction issues, leading to a concept of predictive exogeneity. We also adapt the formal definitions of weak and strong exogeneity introduced in Engle et al. (1983), and provide a naturally nested set of definitions for exogeneity. An example highlights the main implications of our analysis for econometric modelling.     

Comment

The article provides detailed and accurate illustrations of Bayesian analysis of DSGE models that are likely to be used increasingly in support of central bank policy making. These comments identify a dozen aspects of these methods, discussing how their application and improvement can contribute to effective support of policy.     

情绪冲击、资产泡沫与经济波动:基于贝叶斯DSGE的分析

本文在Smets和Wouters(2003)、Christiano等(2005)模型基础上,引入驱动股价泡沫的情绪冲击,构建了情绪冲击通过资产价格渠道影响经济波动的动态随机一般均衡模型,并采用我国2000-2016年的季度数据对模型进行贝叶斯估计。研究表明,由于企业面临融资约束,正向情绪冲击带来股价泡沫的上升起到了放松信贷约束的作用,因而企业投资增加,进而触发一系列经济变量的顺周期波动。情绪冲击能够解释我国股票价格波动的552%以及顺周期性;劳动供给冲击、技术冲击、投资专有冲击、金融冲击都是我国经济波动的来源,尽管其对产出、消费、投资、劳动时间和股票价格波动的贡献存在异质性。     

Some Observations,a Suggestion,and Some Comments on the Conway-Roberts Article

This article provides new tools for the evaluation of dynamic stochastic general equilibrium (DSGE) models and applies them to a large-scale new Keynesian model. We approximate the DSGE model by a vector autoregression, and then systematically relax the implied cross-equation restrictions and document how the model fit changes. We also compare the DSGE model's impulse responses to structural shocks with those obtained after relaxing its restrictions. We find that the degree of misspecification in this large-scale DSGE model is no longer so large as to prevent its use in day-to-day policy analysis, yet is not small enough to be ignored.     

财政政策DSGE模型中国化构建及其应用

事前模拟经济对财政政策变化的反应是检验政策效果的重要手段。本文通过国外经典模型中国化改进,并引入系统财政规则,构建财政政策DSGE模型。在有效税率估算校准与参数贝叶斯估计基础上,给出政策模拟检验应用示例。发现税率冲击效应模拟是税制改革实验的有效方法,资本税率可作为经济结构调整的政策工具,以及当前增加政府支出拉动增长作用微弱等结论。该研究也可为我国DSGE模型研究提供参考。     

中国经济波动来自趋势还是周期——基于多种UC模型的比较分析

传统趋势周期分解方法存在理论基础不符实际、缺少数据生成过程等问题,相较而言,UC模型具有一定优势。论文采用贝叶斯方法和中国宏观季度数据,估计了多个UC模型以分解产出的趋势和周期。研究发现：(1) 断点期在2008Q1的无约束UC模型为最优模型;(2) 趋势新息波动大于周期新息波动,两者高度负相关;(3) 趋势增长率发生了结构性下降;(4) 经济下行源于趋势下行而非周期下行。论文的基本结论在双变量模型、其它数据、其它经典单变量方法下依然成立。论文为宏观调控和“供给侧”改革提供实证依据。     

Robust Tests Against Smooth Transition Autoregressive Models

In this paper, we consider testing for linearity against a well-known class of regime switching models known as the smooth transition autoregressive (STAR) models. Apart from the model selection issues, one reason for interest in testing for linearity in time-series models is that non-linear models such as the STAR are considerably more difficult to use. This testing problem is non-standard because a nuisance parameter becomes unidentified under the null hypothesis. In this paper, we further explore the class of tests proposed by Luukkonen, Saikonnen and Terasvirta (1988). Luukkonen et al . (1988) proposed LM tests for linearity against STAR models. A potential difficulty here is that the linear approximation introduces high leverage points, and hence outliers are likely to be quite influential. To overcome this difficulty, we use the same approximating linear model of Luukkonen et al . (1988), but we apply Wald and F -tests based on l 1 - and bounded influence estimates. The efficiency gains of this procedure cannot be easily deduced from the existing theoretical results because the test is based on a misspecified model under H 1 . Therefore, we carried out a simulation study, in which we observed that the robust tests have desirable properties compared to the test of Luukkonen et al . (1988) for a range of error distributions in the STAR model, in particular the robust tests have power advantages over the LM test.     

ASSOCIATIONS BETWEEN AIR POLLUTION AND HOSPITAL VISITS FOR CARDIOVASCULAR DISEASES IN THE ELDERLY IN SYDNEY USING BAYESIAN STATISTICAL METHODS

Using generalized linear models (GLMs), Jalaludin  et al. (2006;  J. Exposure Analysis and Epidemiology   16 , 225–237) studied the association between the daily number of visits to emergency departments for cardiovascular disease by the elderly (65+) and five measures of ambient air pollution. Bayesian methods provide an alternative approach to classical time series modelling and are starting to be more widely used. This paper considers Bayesian methods using the dataset used by Jalaludin  et al.  (2006) , and compares the results from Bayesian methods with those obtained by Jalaludin  et al.  (2006) using GLM methods.     

Computational challenges and temporal dependence in Bayesian nonparametric models

Müller et al. (Stat Methods Appl, 2017) provide an excellent review of several classes of Bayesian nonparametric models which have found widespread application in a variety of contexts, successfully highlighting their flexibility in comparison with parametric families. Particular attention in the paper is dedicated to modelling spatial dependence. Here we contribute by concisely discussing general computational challenges which arise with posterior inference with Bayesian nonparametric models and certain aspects of modelling temporal dependence.     

Latent cure rate model under repair system and threshold effect

In this paper, we formulate a simple latent cure rate model with repair mechanism for a cell exposed to radiation. This latent approach is a flexible alternative to the models proposed by Klebanov et al. [A stochastic model of radiation carcinogenesis: latent time distributions and their properties. Math Biosci. 1993;18:51–75], Kim et al. [A new threshold regression model for survival data with a cure fraction. Lifetime Data Anal. 2011;17:101–122], and is along the lines of the destructive cure rate model formulated recently by Rodrigues et al. [Destructive weighted Poisson cure rate model. Lifetime Data Anal. 2011b;17:333–346]. A new version of the modified Gompertz model and the promotion cure rate model that takes into account the first passage time of reaching the critical point are discussed, and the estimation of tumor size at detection is then addressed from the Bayesian viewpoint. In addition, a simulation study and an application to real data set illustrate the usefulness of the proposed cure rate model.     

资产配置模型的选择:回报、风险抑或二者兼具

近年来以风险平价为代表的基于风险的配置模型广为流行。这些模型的一大特点是放弃回报信息。而以均值方差模型代表的基于回报的配置模型则认为回报很重要而且默认对回报的预测是准确的。这两种做法都有问题。考虑到回报的可预测性得到了大量经验研究的支持,那么对于基于风险的配置模型而言,完全放弃回报则意味着有关回报的有用信息得不到充分利用。对于基于回报的配置模型而言,不考虑参数估计误差而且对输入参数敏感的缺点也大大抵消了它们利用回报信息带来的好处。那么,回报是否重要以及应该如何使用回报成了资产配置研究所面临的一个重大问题。为此,本文提出以风险平价为配置基准,以贝叶斯VAR回报预测为主观观点的Black-Litterman(贝叶斯BL)模型回答这一命题。利用1952-2016年的美国股票和债券季度数据,本文将贝叶斯BL模型与现有配置模型进行比较研究。实证结果表明,相比基于回报的配置模型,贝叶斯BL模型降低了组合风险;相比基于风险的配置模型,贝叶斯BL模型增强了组合回报。这些特性来自于它既能利用回报可预测性带来的有用信息,又能够发挥基于风险的配置模型在控制风险方面的优势。因此该模型表现出增强回报和控制风险兼具的特点,是一条具有潜力的资产配置新方案。     

Estimating Heston's and Bates’ models parameters using Markov chain Monte Carlo simulation

Heston's model and Bates’ model are very important in option pricing. It is mentioned in Mendoza's paper [Bayesian estimation and option mispricing (job market paper). Cambridge, MA: Massachusetts Institute of Technology; 2011] that Mexican Stock Exchange introduced options over its main index (the Índice de Precios y Cotizaciones) in 2004 which used Heston's model to price options on days when there was no trading. The estimation of the parameters in both models is not easy. One of the methods is Markov chain Monte Carlo algorithm (MCMC for short). In this paper, we adopt Li, Wells and Yu's MCMC algorithm [A Bayesian analysis of return dynamics with levy jumps. Rev Financ Stud. 2008;21(5):2345–2377]. We provide the necessary derivation utilizing prior distributions since they are otherwise unavailable in the literature. As Li et al. used their model to analyse S&P 500 data from 2 January 1980 to 29 December 2000, we likewise recreate their analysis, this time using data from 1987 to 2012. We would like to involve the financial crisis and analyse how stable the method is while applying to the financial crisis. Unlike Li et al., we find that the estimation is very sensitive to the prior distribution assumption. In addition, we have R-code available by request. We hope to offer tools for people doing empirical research in financial mathematics or quantitative finance.     

货币政策转型背景下汇率调整对宏观经济的影响——基于开放经济DSGE模型的研究

在货币政策转型背景下研究人民币汇率调整对宏观经济波动的影响,通过构建一个符合中国实际情况的开放经济DSGE模型,对比分析数量型和价格型的货币政策规则对烫平人民币汇率调整导致的宏观经济波动的效果。研究结果表明:当人民币汇率冲击导致经济波动时,数量型规则比价格型规则对烫平经济波动的作用更有效,且能够更好地减小社会福利损失。因此,在货币政策逐渐从数量型向价格型转变的过程中,仍然不能放弃数量型工具的使用,综合运用数量和价格两种调控手段对于转型中的中国而言是比较合适的选择。     

A new multivariate imputation method based on Bayesian networks

Dealing with incomplete data is a pervasive problem in statistical surveys. Bayesian networks have been recently used in missing data imputation. In this research, we propose a new methodology for the multivariate imputation of missing data using discrete Bayesian networks and conditional Gaussian Bayesian networks. Results from imputing missing values in coronary artery disease data set and milk composition data set as well as a simulation study from cancer-neapolitan network are presented to demonstrate and compare the performance of three Bayesian network-based imputation methods with those of multivariate imputation by chained equations (MICE) and the classical hot-deck imputation method. To assess the effect of the structure learning algorithm on the performance of the Bayesian network-based methods, two methods called Peter-Clark algorithm and greedy search-and-score have been applied. Bayesian network-based methods are: first, the method introduced by Di Zio et al. [Bayesian networks for imputation, J. R. Stat. Soc. Ser. A 167 (2004), 309–322] in which, each missing item of a variable is imputed using the information given in the parents of that variable; second, the method of Di Zio et al. [Multivariate techniques for imputation based on Bayesian networks, Neural Netw. World 15 (2005), 303–310] which uses the information in the Markov blanket set of the variable to be imputed and finally, our new proposed method which applies the whole available knowledge of all variables of interest, consisting the Markov blanket and so the parent set, to impute a missing item. Results indicate the high quality of our new proposed method especially in the presence of high missingness percentages and more connected networks. Also the new method have shown to be more efficient than the MICE method for small sample sizes with high missing rates.     

Identification of Multivariate Responders/Non-Responders Using Bayesian Growth Curve Latent Class Models

In this paper, we propose a multivariate growth curve mixture model that groups subjects based on multiple symptoms measured repeatedly over time. Our model synthesizes features of two models. First, we follow Roy and Lin (2000) in relating the multiple symptoms at each time point to a single latent variable. Second, we use the growth mixture model of Muthén and Shedden (1999) to group subjects based on distinctive longitudinal profiles of this latent variable. The mean growth curve for the latent variable in each class defines that class's features. For example, a class of "responders" would have a decline in the latent symptom summary variable over time. A Bayesian approach to estimation is employed where the methods of Elliott et al (2005) are extended to simultaneously estimate the posterior distributions of the parameters from the latent variable and growth curve mixture portions of the model. We apply our model to data from a randomized clinical trial evaluating the efficacy of Bacillus Calmette-Guerin (BCG) in treating symptoms of Interstitial Cystitis. In contrast to conventional approaches using a single subjective Global Response Assessment, we use the multivariate symptom data to identify a class of subjects where treatment demonstrates effectiveness. Simulations are used to confirm identifiability results and evaluate the performance of our algorithm. The definitive version of this paper is available at onlinelibrary.wiley.com.