Collapsibility of contingency tables based on conditional models

Strict collapsibility and model collapsibility are two important concepts associated with the dimension reduction of a multidimensional contingency table, without losing the relevant information. In this paper, we obtain some necessary and sufficient conditions for the strict collapsibility of the full model, with respect to an interaction factor or a set of interaction factors, based on the interaction parameters of the conditional/layer log-linear models. For hierarchical log-linear models, we present also necessary and sufficient conditions for the full model to be model collapsible, based on the conditional interaction parameters. We discuss both the cases where one variable or a set of variables is conditioned. The connections between the strict collapsibility and the model collapsibility are also pointed out. Our results are illustrated through suitable examples, including a real life application.     

Average Collapsibility of Distribution Dependence and Quantile Regression Coefficients

Abstract. The Yule–Simpson paradox notes that an association between random variables can be reversed when averaged over a background variable. Cox and Wermuth introduced the concept of distribution dependence between two random variables X and Y, and gave two dependence conditions, each of which guarantees that reversal of qualitatively similar conditional dependences cannot occur after marginalizing over the background variable. Ma, Xie and Geng studied the uniform collapsibility of distribution dependence over a background variable W, under stronger homogeneity condition. Collapsibility ensures that associations are the same for conditional and marginal models. In this article, we use the notion of average collapsibility, which requires only the conditional effects average over the background variable to the corresponding marginal effect and investigate its conditions for distribution dependence and for quantile regression coefficients.     

Detecting multiple confounders

This paper proposes an approach for detecting multiple confounders which combines the advantages of two causal models, the potential outcome model and the causal diagram. The approach need not use a complete causal diagram as long as it is known that a known covariate set Z$Z$ contains the parent set of the exposure E  . On the other hand, whether a covariate is or not a confounder may depend on its categorization. We introduce uniform non-confounding which implies non-confounding in any subpopulation defined by the interval of a covariate (or any pooled level for a discrete covariate). We show that the conditions in Miettinen and Cook's criteria for non-confounding also imply uniform non-confounding. Further we present an algorithm for deleting non-confounders from the potential confounder set Z$Z$, which extends Greenland et al.'s [1999a. Causal diagrams for epidemiologic research. Epidemiology 10, 37–48] approach by splitting Z$Z$ into a series of potential confounder subsets. We also discuss conditions for non-confounding bias in the subpopulations in which we are interested, where the subpopulations may be defined by non-confounders.     

Collapsibility of Conditional Graphical Models

Abstract. In this paper, we consider two kinds of collapsibility, that is, the model‐collapsibility and the estimate‐collapsibility, of conditional graphical models for multidimensional contingency tables. We show that these two definitions are equivalent, and propose a sufficient and necessary condition for them in terms of the interaction graph, which allows the collapsibility to be characterized and judged intuitively and conveniently.     

Collapsibility for Directed Acyclic Graphs

Abstract.  Collapsibility means that the same statistical result of interest can be obtained before and after marginalization over some variables. In this paper, we discuss three kinds of collapsibility for directed acyclic graphs (DAGs): estimate collapsibility, conditional independence collapsibility and model collapsibility. Related to collapsibility, we discuss removability of variables from a DAG. We present conditions for these three different kinds of collapsibility and relationships among them. We give algorithms to find a minimum variable set containing a variable subset of interest onto which a statistical result is collapsible.     

Whittemore's notion of collapsibility in multidimensional contingency tables

We develop simple necessary and sufficient conditions for a hierarchical log linear model to be strictly collapsible in the sense defined by Whittemore (1978). We then show that collapsibility as defined by Asmussen & Edwards (1983) can be viewed as equivalent to collapsibility as defined by Whittemore (1978) and illustrate why Bishop, Fienberg, & Holland's (1975, p.47) conditions for collapsibility are sufficient but not necessary. Finally, we discuss how collapsibility facilitates interpretation of certain hierarchical log linear models and formulation of hypotheses concerning marginal distributions associated with multidimensional contingency tables.     

A Note on Collapsibility in DAG Models of Contingency Tables

Abstract.  Necessary and sufficient conditions for collapsibility of a directed acyclic graph (DAG) model for a contingency table are derived. By applying the conditions, we can easily check collapsibility over any variable in a given model either by using the joint probability distribution or by using the graph of the model structure. It is shown that collapsibility over a set of variables can be checked in a sequential manner. Furthermore, a DAG is compared with its moral graph in the context of collapsibility.     

Collapsibility of Graphical CG-Regression Models

Abstract.  CG-regressions are multivariate regression models for mixed continuous and discrete responses that result from conditioning in the class of conditional Gaussian (CG) models. Their conditional independence structure can be read off a marked graph. The property of collapsibility, in this context, means that the multivariate CG-regression can be decomposed into lower dimensional regressions that are still CG and are consistent with the corresponding subgraphs. We derive conditions for this property that can easily be checked on the graph, and indicate computational advantages of this kind of collapsibility. Further, a simple graphical condition is given for checking whether a decomposition into univariate regressions is possible.     

Uniform Inference on Quantile Effects under Sharp Regression Discontinuity Designs

ABSTRACT

This study develops methods for conducting uniform inference on quantile treatment effects for sharp regression discontinuity designs. We develop a score test for the treatment significance hypothesis and Wald-type tests for the hypotheses related to treatment significance, homogeneity, and unambiguity. The bias from the nonparametric estimation is studied in detail. In particular, we show that under some conditions, the asymptotic distribution of the score test is unaffected by the bias, without under-smoothing. For situations where the conditions can be restrictive, we incorporate a bias correction into the Wald tests and account for the estimation uncertainty. We also provide a procedure for constructing uniform confidence bands for quantile treatment effects. As an empirical application, we use the proposed methods to study the effect of cash-on-hand on unemployment duration. The results reveal pronounced treatment heterogeneity and also emphasize the importance of considering the long-term unemployed.     

Testing for Granger-causality in quantiles

This paper proposes a consistent parametric test of Granger-causality in quantiles. Although the concept of Granger-causality is defined in terms of the conditional distribution, most articles have tested Granger-causality using conditional mean regression models in which the causal relations are linear. Rather than focusing on a single part of the conditional distribution, we develop a test that evaluates nonlinear causalities and possible causal relations in all conditional quantiles, which provides a sufficient condition for Granger-causality when all quantiles are considered. The proposed test statistic has correct asymptotic size, is consistent against fixed alternatives, and has power against Pitman deviations from the null hypothesis. As the proposed test statistic is asymptotically nonpivotal, we tabulate critical values via a subsampling approach. We present Monte Carlo evidence and an application considering the causal relation between the gold price, the USD/GBP exchange rate, and the oil price.     

Dimension reduction summaries for balanced contrasts

We discuss the covariate dimension reduction properties of conditional density ratios in the estimation of balanced contrasts of expectations. Conditional density ratios, as well as related sufficient summaries, can be used to replace the covariates with a smaller number of variables. For example, for comparisons among k   populations the covariates can be replaced with k-1$k-1$ conditional density ratios. The dimension reduction properties of conditional density ratios are directly connected with sufficiency, the dimension reduction concepts considered in regression theory, and propensity theory. The theory presented here extends the ideas in propensity theory to situations in which propensities do not exist and develops an approach to dimension reduction outside of the potential outcomes or counterfactual framework. Under general conditions, we show that a principal components transformation of the estimated conditional density ratios can be used to investigate whether a sufficient summary of dimension lower than k-1$k-1$ exists and to identify such a lower dimensional summary.     

Identification and Identification Failure for Treatment Effects Using Structural Systems

We provide necessary and sufficient conditions for effect identification, thereby characterizing the limits to identification. Our results link the nonstructural potential outcome framework for identifying and estimating treatment effects to structural approaches in economics. This permits economic theory to be built into treatment effect methods. We elucidate the sources and consequences of identification failure by examining the biases arising when the necessary conditions fail, and we clarify the relations between unconfoundedness, conditional exogeneity, and the necessary and sufficient identification conditions. A new quantity, the exogeneity score, plays a central role in this analysis, permitting an omitted variable representation for effect biases. This analysis also provides practical guidance for selecting covariates and insight into the price paid for making various identifying assumptions and the benefits gained.     

Functional data: local linear estimation of the conditional density and its application

In this paper, we introduce a new nonparametric estimation procedure of the conditional density of a scalar response variable given a random variable taking values in a semi-metric space. Under some general conditions, we establish both the pointwise and the uniform almost-complete consistencies with convergence rates of the conditional density estimator related to this estimation procedure. Moreover, we give some particular cases of our results which can also be considered as novel in the finite-dimensional setting. Notice also that the results of this paper are used to derive some asymptotic properties of the local linear estimator of the conditional mode.     

Identification of Local Causal Effects with Missing Outcome Values and an Instrument for Non Response

Even in randomized experiments the identification of causal effects is often threatened by the presence of missing outcome values, with missingness possibly being non ignorable. We provide sufficient conditions under which the availability of a binary instrument for non response allows us to non parametrically point identify average causal effects in some latent subgroups of units, named Principal Strata, defined by their non response behavior in all possible combinations of treatment and instrument. Examples are provided as possible scenarios where our assumptions may be plausible.     

Conditions for D A -Maximin Marginal Designs for Generalized Linear Mixed Models to be Uniform

Optimal design theory deals with the assessment of the optimal joint distribution of all independent variables prior to data collection. In many practical situations, however, covariates are involved for which the distribution is not previously determined. The optimal design problem may then be reformulated in terms of finding the optimal marginal distribution for a specific set of variables. In general, the optimal solution may depend on the unknown (conditional) distribution of the covariates. This article discusses the D _A -maximin procedure to account for the uncertain distribution of the covariates. Sufficient conditions will be given under which the uniform design of a subset of independent discrete variables is D _A -maximin. The sufficient conditions are formulated for Generalized Linear Mixed Models with an arbitrary number of quantitative and qualitative independent variables and random effects.     

A general definition of influence between stochastic processes

We extend the study of weak local conditional independence (WCLI) based on a measurability condition made by (Commenges and Gégout-Petit J R Stat Soc B 71:1–18) to a larger class of processes that we call D￠{\bf {\mathcal{D}'}}. We also give a definition related to the same concept based on certain likelihood processes, using the Girsanov theorem. Under certain conditions, the two definitions coincide on D￠{\bf {\mathcal{D}'}}. These results may be used in causal models in that we define what may be the largest class of processes in which influences of one component of a stochastic process on another can be described without ambiguity. From WCLI we can construct a concept of strong local conditional independence (SCLI). When WCLI does not hold, there is a direct influence while when SCLI does not hold there is direct or indirect influence. We investigate whether WCLI and SCLI can be defined via conventional independence conditions and find that this is the case for the latter but not for the former. Finally we recall that causal interpretation does not follow from mere mathematical definitions, but requires working with a good system and with the true probability.     

Exact conditional inference for two uniform populations

We discuss the nature of ancillary information in the context of the continuous uniform distribution. In the one-sample problem, the existence of sufficient statistics mitigates conditioning on the ancillary configuration. In the two-sample problem, additional ancillary information becomes available when the ratio of scale parameters is known. We give exact results for conditional inferences about the common scale parameter and for the difference in location parameters of two uniform distributions. The ancillary information affects the precision of the latter through a comparison of the sample value of the ratio of scale parameters with the known population value. A limited conditional simulation compares the Type I errors and power of these exact results with approximate results using the robust pooled t-statistic.     

Collapsibility of regression coefficients and its extensions

Collapsibility with respect to a measure of association implies that the measure of association can be obtained from the marginal model. We first discuss model collapsibility and collapsibility with respect to regression coefficients for linear regression models. For parallel regression models, we give simple and different proofs of some of the known results and obtain also certain new results. For random coefficient regression models, we define (average) A$A$-collapsibility and obtain conditions under which it holds. We consider Poisson regression and logistic regression models also, and derive conditions for collapsibility and A$A$-collapsibility, respectively. These results generalize some of the results available in the literature. Some suitable examples are also discussed.     

Robust nonparametrics in mixed-MANOCOVA models

In robust and nonparametric MANOVA models, the basic assumptions of independence, homoscedasticity and multinormality of the error components have been relaxed to a certain extent. In mixed-effects MANOVA models, the random effects components (due to concomitant variates) rest on the linearity of the regression function and some other distributional homogeneity conditions that may not hold universally, and avoidance of such regularity conditions generally introduce complications. Some of these difficulties are eliminated here through a conditional functional estimation approach, and in this setup, improved estimation of the fixed effects parameters is presented in a unified manner. Robustness and efficacy of these nonparametric procedures are appraised, and the picture is compared with their parametric as well as semiparametric counterparts.     

Conditioning on Auxiliary Variable Means in Finite Population Inference

This paper reviews conditional properties of the mean and total estimators of a finite population when auxiliary information is available. An exact design-based conditional analysis for complex sampling designs is intractable, but an asymptotic conditional framework can be developed. Within such a framework the paper establishes sufficient conditions for conditional unbiasedness and explores conditional properties of various types of regression estimators. A sample statistic capable of indicating the presence of substantial conditional biases is proposed, and illustrated by a simulation study.