A note on the facility location problem with stochastic demands

In this research note that the single source capacitated facility location problem with general stochastic identically distributed demands is studied. The demands considered are independent and identically distributed random variables with arbitrary distribution. The unified a priori solution for the locations of facilities and for the allocation of customers to the operating facilities is found. This solution minimizes the objective function which is the sum of the fixed costs and the value of one of two different recourse functions. For each case the recourse function is given in closed form and a deterministic equivalent formulation of the model is presented. Some numerical examples are also given.     

Two-stage stochastic mixed-integer linear programming: The conditional scenario approach

In this paper we consider the two-stage stochastic mixed-integer linear programming problem with recourse, which we call the RP problem. A common way to approximate the RP problem, which is usually formulated in terms of scenarios, is to formulate the so-called Expected Value (EV) problem, which only considers the expectation of the random parameters of the RP problem. In this paper we introduce the Conditional Scenario (CS) problem which represents a midpoint between the RP and the EV problems regarding computational tractability and ability to deal with uncertainty. In the theoretical section we have analyzed some useful bounds related to the RP, EV and CS problems. In the numerical example here presented, the CS problem has outperformed both the EV problem in terms of solution quality, and the RP problem with the same number of scenarios as in the CS problem, in terms of solution time.     

A general space-time model for combinatorial optimization problems (and not only)

We consider the problem of defining a strategy consisting of a set of facilities taking into account also the location where they have to be assigned and the time in which they have to be activated. The facilities are evaluated with respect to a set of criteria. The plan has to be devised respecting some constraints related to different aspects of the problem such as precedence restrictions due to the nature of the facilities. Among the constraints, there are some related to the available budget. We consider also the uncertainty related to the performances of the facilities with respect to considered criteria and plurality of stakeholders participating to the decision. The considered problem can be seen as the combination of some prototypical operations research problems: knapsack problem, location problem and project scheduling. Indeed, the basic brick of our model is a variable x_ilt which takes value 1 if facility i is activated in location l at time t, and 0 otherwise. Due to the conjoint consideration of a location and a time in the decision variables, what we propose can be seen as a general space-time model for operations research problems. We discuss how such a model permits to handle complex problems using several methodologies including multiple attribute value theory and multiobjective optimization. With respect to the latter point, without any loss of the generality, we consider the compromise programming and an interactive methodology based on the Dominance-based Rough Set Approach. We illustrate the application of our model with a simple didactic example.     

Approximating soft-capacitated facility location problem with uncertainty

In this paper we devise the stochastic and robust approaches to study the soft-capacitated facility location problem with uncertainty. We first present a new stochastic soft-capacitated model called The 2-Stage Soft Capacitated Facility Location Problem and solve it via an approximation algorithm by reducing it to linear-cost version of 2-stage facility location problem and dynamic facility location problem. We then present a novel robust model of soft-capacitated facility location, The Robust Soft Capacitated Facility Location Problem. To solve it, we improve the approximation algorithm proposed by Byrka et al. (LP-rounding algorithms for facility-location problems. CoRR, 2010a) for RFTFL and then treat it similarly as in the stochastic case. The improvement results in an approximation factor of \(\alpha + 4\) for the robust fault-tolerant facility location problem, which is best so far.     

Fixed or variable demand? Does it matter when locating a facility?

In most competitive location models available in the literature, it is assumed that the demand is fixed independently of market conditions. However, demand may vary depending on prices, distances to the facilities, etc., especially when the goods are not essential. Taking variable demand into consideration increases the complexity of the problem and, therefore, the computational effort needed to solve it, but it may make the model more realistic. In this paper, a new planar competitive location and design problem with variable demand is presented. By using it, it is shown numerically for the first time in the literature that the assumption of fixed demand influences the location decision very much, and therefore the selection of the type of demand (fixed or variable) must be made with care when modeling location problems. Finally, two methods are presented to cope with the new model, an exact interval branch-and-bound method and an evolutionary algorithm called UEGO (Universal Evolutionary Global Optimizer).     

A visual interactive approach to classical and mixed vehicle routing problems with backhauls

In this paper a new visual interactive approach for the classical vehicle routing problem with backhauls (VRPB) and its extensions is presented. The classical VRPB is the problem of designing minimum cost routes from a single depot to two type customers that are known as Backhaul (pickup) and Linehaul (delivery) customers where deliveries after pickups are not allowed. The mixed VRPB is an extension of the classical VRPB where deliveries after pickups are allowed.     

A multi-stage stochastic supply network design problem with financial decisions and risk management

In this paper, a multi-period supply chain network design problem is addressed. Several aspects of practical relevance are considered such as those related with the financial decisions that must be accounted for by a company managing a supply chain. The decisions to be made comprise the location of the facilities, the flow of commodities and the investments to make in alternative activities to those directly related with the supply chain design. Uncertainty is assumed for demand and interest rates, which is described by a set of scenarios. Therefore, for the entire planning horizon, a tree of scenarios is built. A target is set for the return on investment and the risk of falling below it is measured and accounted for. The service level is also measured and included in the objective function. The problem is formulated as a multi-stage stochastic mixed-integer linear programming problem. The goal is to maximize the total financial benefit. An alternative formulation which is based upon the paths in the scenario tree is also proposed. A methodology for measuring the value of the stochastic solution in this problem is discussed. Computational tests using randomly generated data are presented showing that the stochastic approach is worth considering in these types of problems.     

The min-p robust optimization approach for facility location problem under uncertainty

Improper value of the parameter p in robust constraints will result in no feasible solutions while applying stochastic p-robustness optimization approach (p-SRO) to solving facility location problems under uncertainty. Aiming at finding the lowest critical p-value of parameter p and corresponding robust optimal solution, we developed a novel robust optimization approach named as min-p robust optimization approach (min-pRO) for P-median problem (PMP) and fixed cost P-median problem (FPMP). Combined with the nearest allocation strategy, the vertex substitution heuristic algorithm is improved and the influencing factors of the lowest critical p-value are analyzed. The effectiveness and performance of the proposed approach are verified by numerical examples. The results show that the fluctuation range of data is positively correlated with the lowest critical p-value with given number of new facilities. However, the number of new facilities has a different impact on lowest critical p-value with the given fluctuation range of data. As the number of new facilities increases, the lowest critical p-value for PMP and FPMP increases and decreases, respectively.

     

An approximation algorithm for k-center problem on a convex polygon

This paper studies the constrained version of the k-center location problem. Given a convex polygonal region, every point in the region originates a service demand. Our objective is to place k facilities lying on the region’s boundary, such that every point in that region receives service from its closest facility and the maximum service distance is minimized. This problem is equivalent to covering the polygon by k circles with centers on its boundary which have the smallest possible radius. We present an 1.8841-approximation polynomial time algorithm for this problem.     

Minimizing the maximum travel time in a combined model of facility location and network design

This paper presents a combined Facility Location/Network Design Problem which simultaneously considers the location of facilities and the design of its underlying network so as to minimize the maximum customer-facility travel time. The model generalizes the classical p-center problem and has various applications in regional planning, distribution, telecommunications, emergency systems, and other areas. Two mixed integer programming formulations are presented and compared. Several valid inequalities are derived for the most promising of these formulations to strengthen its LP relaxation bound and to reduce the enumeration tree. Numerical results of a series of computational experiments for instances with up to 100 nodes and 500 candidate links are reported.     

STOCHASTIC LINEAR PROGRAMMING WITH RECOURSE: A TUTORIAL*

Presented here is an introduction to stochastic linear programs with recourse. The paper is by no means a comprehensive survey of the field; that would be an encyclopedic task at best. This paper discusses formulation, interpretation, and computational aspects of stochastic linear programs with simple and fixed recourse. The paper is pedagogical in nature and is aimed to whet the interest of the decision scientist that has little or no background in stochastic programming. Moreover, the papers in this field have appeared in diverse journals not always readily available to the typical management scientist or practitioner and quite often at a very sophisticated mathematical level. For the practitioner, Wets's algorithm for solving stochastic linear programs with simple recourse may be particularly interesting since Wets shows in that paper how the problem can be reduced to an equivalent deterministic linear program of the same dimensionality.     

On the location of new facilities for chain expansion under delivered pricing

We study the problem of locating new facilities for one expanding chain which competes for demand in spatially separated markets where all competing chains use delivered pricing. A new network location model is formulated for profit maximization of the expanding chain assuming that equilibrium prices are set in each market. The cannibalization effect caused by the entrance of the new facilities is integrated in the objective function as a cost to be paid by the expanding chain to the cannibalized facilities. It is shown that the profit of the chain is maximized by locating the new facilities in a set of points which are nodes or iso-marginal delivered cost points (points on the network from which the marginal delivered cost equals the minimum marginal delivered cost from the existing facilities owned by the expanding chain). Then the location problem is reduced to a discrete optimization problem which is formulated as a mixed integer linear program. A sensitivity analysis respect to both the number of new facilities and the cannibalization cost is shown by using an illustrative example with data of the region of Murcia (Spain). Some conclusions are presented.     

An approximation algorithm for <Emphasis Type="Italic">k</Emphasis>-facility location problem with linear penalties using local search scheme

In this paper, we consider an extension of the classical facility location problem, namely k-facility location problem with linear penalties. In contrast to the classical facility location problem, this problem opens no more than k facilities and pays a penalty cost for any non-served client. We present a local search algorithm for this problem with a similar but more technical analysis due to the extra penalty cost, compared to that in Zhang (Theoretical Computer Science 384:126–135, 2007). We show that the approximation ratio of the local search algorithm is \(2 + 1/p + \sqrt{3+ 2/p+ 1/p^2} + \epsilon \), where \(p \in {\mathbb {Z}}_+\) is a parameter of the algorithm and \(\epsilon >0\) is a positive number.     

On multi-criteria chance-constrained capacitated single-source discrete facility location problems

This work aims at investigating multi-criteria modeling frameworks for discrete stochastic facility location problems with single sourcing. We assume that demand is stochastic and also that a service level is imposed. This situation is modeled using a set of probabilistic constraints. We also consider a minimum throughput at the facilities to justify opening them. We investigate two paradigms in terms of multi-criteria optimization: vectorial optimization and goal programming. Additionally, we discuss the joint use of objective functions that are relevant in the context of some humanitarian logistics problems. We apply the general modeling frameworks proposed to the so-called stochastic shelter site location problem. This is a problem emerging in the context of preventive disaster management. We test the models proposed using two real benchmark data sets. The results show that considering uncertainty and multiple objectives in the type of facility location problems investigated leads to solutions that may better support decision making.     

Approximation algorithms for <Emphasis Type="Italic">k</Emphasis>-level stochastic facility location problems

In the k-level facility location problem (FLP), we are given a set of facilities, each associated with one of k levels, and a set of clients. We have to connect each client to a chain of opened facilities spanning all levels, minimizing the sum of opening and connection costs. This paper considers the k-level stochastic FLP, with two stages, when the set of clients is only known in the second stage. There is a set of scenarios, each occurring with a given probability. A facility may be opened in any stage, however, the cost of opening a facility in the second stage depends on the realized scenario. The objective is to minimize the expected total cost. For the stage-constrained variant, when clients must be served by facilities opened in the same stage, we present a \((4-o(1))\)-approximation, improving on the 4-approximation by Wang et al. (Oper Res Lett 39(2):160–161, 2011) for each k. In the case with \(k=2,\,3\), the algorithm achieves factors 2.56 and 2.78, resp., which improves the \((3+\epsilon )\)-approximation for \(k=2\) by Wu et al. (Theor Comput Sci 562:213–226, 2015). For the non-stage-constrained version, we give the first approximation for the problem, achieving a factor of 3.495 for the case with \(k = 2\), and \(2k-1+o(1)\) in general.     

Optimal location and capability of oil-spill response facilities for the south coast of Newfoundland

The south coast of Newfoundland (Canada) includes both open sea and semi-enclosed waterways which collectively account for over 20,000 vessel movements annually. Every such movement poses the risk of an oil spill which can endanger the fragile marine life and tourism locales in the region, and is a source of concern to the communities. In an effort to analyze the problem, we present a two-stage stochastic programming approach which tackles both the location and stockpile of equipment at the emergency response facilities. The proposed optimization program was tested on realistic data collected from publicly available reports and through personal communications with emergency response personnel. These data were then varied to solve a number of scenarios which account for the stochastic nature of the problem parameters. Although only two response facilities seem to be appropriate for almost all scenarios, the size of equipment stockpile is a function of both the societal disutility factor and the trade-off between environmental cost and facility and equipment acquisition cost.     

A local search approximation algorithm for the uniform capacitated <Emphasis Type="Italic">k</Emphasis>-facility location problem

In the uniform capacitated k-facility location problem (UC-k-FLP), we are given a set of facilities and a set of clients. Every client has a demand. Every facility have an opening cost and an uniform capacity. For each client–facility pair, there is an unit service cost to serve the client with unit demand by the facility. The total demands served by a facility cannot exceed the uniform capacity. We want to open at most k facilities to serve all the demands of the clients without violating the capacity constraint such that the total opening and serving cost is minimized. The main contribution of this work is to present the first combinatorial bi-criteria approximation algorithm for the UC-k-FLP by violating the cardinality constraint.     

Asymptotically optimal policy for stochastic job shop scheduling problem to minimize makespan

This paper studies the large-scale stochastic job shop scheduling problem with general number of similar jobs, where the processing times of the same step are independently drawn from a known probability distribution, and the objective is to minimize the makespan. For the stochastic problem, we introduce the fluid relaxation of its deterministic counterpart, and define a fluid schedule for the fluid relaxation. By tracking the fluid schedule, a policy is proposed for the stochastic job shop scheduling problem. The expected value of the gap between the solution produced by the policy and the optimal solution is proved to be O(1), which indicates the policy is asymptotically optimal in expectation.     

Stochastic Optimization for Natural Disaster Asset Prepositioning

A key strategic issue in pre‐disaster planning for humanitarian logistics is the pre‐establishment of adequate capacity and resources that enable efficient relief operations. This paper develops a two‐stage stochastic optimization model to guide the allocation of budget to acquire and position relief assets, decisions that typically need to be made well in advance before a disaster strikes. The optimization focuses on minimizing the expected number of casualties, so our model includes first‐stage decisions to represent the expansion of resources such as warehouses, medical facilities with personnel, ramp spaces, and shelters. Second‐stage decisions concern the logistics of the problem, where allocated resources and contracted transportation assets are deployed to rescue critical population (in need of emergency evacuation), deliver required commodities to stay‐back population, and transport the transfer population displaced by the disaster. Because of the uncertainty of the event's location and severity, these and other parameters are represented as scenarios. Computational results on notional test cases provide guidance on budget allocation and prove the potential benefit of using stochastic optimization.     

An ant colony algorithm for solving budget constrained and unconstrained dynamic facility layout problems

The main characteristic of today's manufacturing environments is volatility. Under a volatile environment, demand is not stable. It changes from one production period to another. To operate efficiently under such environments, the facilities must be adaptive to changing production requirements. From a layout point of view, this situation requires the solution of the dynamic layout problem (DLP). DLP is a computationally complex combinatorial optimization problem for which optimal solutions can only be found for small size problems. It is known that classical optimization procedures are not adequate for this problem. Therefore, several heuristics including taboo search, simulated annealing and genetic algorithm are applied to this problem to find a good solution. This work makes use of the ant colony optimization (ACO) algorithm to solve the DLP by considering the budget constraints. The paper makes the first attempt to show how the ACO can be applied to DLP with the budget constraints. In the paper, example applications are presented and computational experiments are performed to present suitability of the ACO to solve the DLP problems. Promising results are obtained from the solution of several test problems.