Discussion on the paper by Peter Müller,Fernando A. Quintana,and Garritt L. Page

The article by Müller, Quintana, and Page reviews a variety of Bayesian nonparametric models and demonstrates them in a few applications. They emphasize applications in spatial data on which our discussion focuses as well. In particular, we consider two types of mixture models based on species sampling models (SSM) for spatial clustering and apply them to the Chilean mathematics testing score data analyzed by the authors. We conclude that only the mixture model of SSM with spatial locations as part of observations renders spatially non-overlapping clusters.     

Constrained Maximization of the Shapiro–Wilk W Statistic to Estimate Parameters of the Johnson S B Distribution

This article presents a constrained maximization of the Shapiro Wilk W statistic for estimating parameters of the Johnson S _B distribution. The gradient of the W statistic with respect to the minimum and range parameters is used within a quasi-Newton framework to achieve a fit for all four parameters. The method is evaluated with measures of bias and precision using pseudo-random samples from three different S _B populations. The population means were estimated with an average relative bias of less than 0.1% and the population standard deviations with less than 4.0% relative bias. The methodology appears promising as a tool for fitting this sometimes difficult distribution.     

Percentage points of the joint distribution of the extreme roots of the random matrix S1(S1+S2)−1

The numerical treatment of nonlinear model fitting problems often can be simplified by manipulating the model equations. Algebraic manipulations including nonlinear transformations of model parameters, do not change the numerical result of the adjustment and can be a powerful method to improve the performance of solution algorithms. Nonlinear transformations of the observations, on the other hand, do change the numerical results unless the normal equations are transformed accordingly. The latter transformation has been neglected by previous authors and this article provides a complete set of formulas that are needed to implement transformations of observations. The transformations are in general less useful than parameter transformations for the improvement of algorithms but may have other applications in particular situations.     

Discussion of “On simulation and properties of the stable law” by L. Devroye and L. James

We contribute to the discussion of the paper by Devroye and James, by reviewing some of the most meaningful results that relate the unilateral stable distribution with the asymptotic behavior of the so-called Ewens-Pitman sampling model. Our focus is then on how these results have been exploited in the context of Bayesian nonparametric inference for species sampling problems.     

Discussion of “Simple Estimators for Invertible Index Models” by H. Ahn,H. Ichimura,J. Powell,and P. Ruud

This is an interesting article that considers the question of inference on unknown linear index coefficients in a general class of models where reduced form parameters are invertible function of one or more linear index. Interpretable sufficient conditions such as monotonicity and or smoothness for the invertibility condition are provided. The results generalize some work in the previous literature by allowing the number of reduced form parameters to exceed the number of indices. The identification and estimation expand on the approach taken in previous work by the authors. Examples include Ahn, Powell, and Ichimura (2004 Ahn, H., Powell, J., and Ichimura, H. (2004), “Simple Estimators for Monotone Index Models,” UC Berkeley Working Paper. [Google Scholar]) for monotone single-index regression models to a multi-index setting and extended by Blundell and Powell (2004 Blundell, R. W., and Powell, J. L. (2004), “Endogeneity in Semiparametric Binary Response Models,” The Review of Economic Studies, 71, 655–679.[Crossref], [Web of Science ®] , [Google Scholar]) and Powell and Ruud (2008 Powell, J., and Ruud, P. (2008), “Simple Estimators for Semiparametric Multinomial Choice Models,” UC Berkeley Working Paper. [Google Scholar]) to models with endogenous regressors and multinomial response, respectively. A key property of the inference approach taken is that the estimator of the unknown index coefficients (up to scale) is computationally simple to obtain (relative to other estimators in the literature) in that it is closed form. Specifically, unifying an approach for all models considered in this article, the authors propose an estimator, which is the eigenvector of a matrix (defined in terms of a preliminary estimator of the reduced form parameters) corresponding to its smallest eigenvalue. Under suitable conditions, the proposed estimator is shown to be root-n-consistent and asymptotically normal.     

A comment on “An analysis of global warming in the Alpine Region based on nonlinear nonstationary time series models” by F. Battaglia and M. K. Protopapas

We discuss the paper by Battaglia and Protopapas concerning the analysis of global warming phenomenon in the Alpine Region. The Authors consider a nonlinear model which takes into account regimes in time and levels. In this contribution some of the statistical results presented in the paper are commented and a different approach to the problem is proposed. It is based on a temporal aggregation analysis and it can help to highlight some features in the data.     

Comment “On the role of data,statistics and decisions in a pandemic” by Jahn et al.

AStA Advances in Statistical Analysis - We comment the paper by Jahn et al. (On the role of data, statistics and decisions in a pandemic, 2022).     

Discussion of “The power of monitoring: how to make the most of a contaminated multivariate sample” by Andrea Cerioli,Marco Riani,Anthony C. Atkinson and Aldo Corbellini

This paper discusses the contribution of Cerioli et al. (Stat Methods Appl, 2018), where robust monitoring based on high breakdown point estimators is proposed for multivariate data. The results follow years of development in robust diagnostic techniques. We discuss the issues of extending data monitoring to other models with complex structure, e.g. factor analysis, mixed linear models for which S and MM-estimators exist or deviating data cells. We emphasise the importance of robust testing that is often overlooked despite robust tests being readily available once S and MM-estimators have been defined. We mention open questions like out-of-sample inference or big data issues that would benefit from monitoring.     

Comment on “Issues Involved With the Seasonal Adjustment of Economic Time Series” by William R. Bell and Steven C. Hiilmer

This article investigates the existence of multiple regimes in the U.S. economy during the 1923—1991 period. A technique known as regression tree analysis is applied to search for splits in the data, if any exist, rather than choosing a splitting point a priori as has been done in previous work. Using this technique, strong evidence for the existence of nonlinear behavior of U.S. output is found over this period. Monte Carlo results are presented to assess the significance of the regime changes that are found.