Properties of the Cox–Stuart Test for Trend in Application to Hydrological Series: The Simulation Study

The size and power properties of the Cox–Stuart test for detection of a monotonic deterministic trend in hydrological time series are analyzed using the Monte Carlo method. The influence of distribution properties, lengths of series, and trend slopes is studied. Results indicate good size in all cases. The power is high for: length over 60 and strong trend slope, low or medium variation, and medium slope. The power declines if slope and length decrease and if variability increases. The properties are better for skewed distributions than for symmetrical. The test is slightly weaker in comparison to the Mann–Kendall test.     

Comments on “Canonical Correlation in Multivariate Time Series Analysis With an Application to One-Year-Ahead and Multiyear- Ahead Macroeconomic Forecasting,” by P. W. Otter

We examine the orthogonality assumption of seasonal and nonseasonal components for official quarterly unemployment figures in Germany and the United States. Although nonperiodic correlations do not seem to reject the orthogonality assumption, a periodic analysis based on correlation functions that vary with the seasons indicates the violation of orthogonality. We find that the unadjusted data can be described by periodic autoregressive models with a unit root. In simulations we replicate the empirical findings for the German data, where we use these simple models to generate artificial samples. Multiplicative seasonal adjustment leads to large periodic correlations. Additive adjustment leads to smaller ones.