On a class of nonparametric tests for the treatment vs control problem

The classical problem of testing treatment versus control is revisited by considering a class of test statistics based on a kernel that depends on a constant ‘a’. The proposed class includes the celebrated Wilcoxon-Mann-Whitnet statistics as a special case when ‘a’=1. It is shown that, with optimal choice of ‘a’ depending on the underlying distribution, the optimal member performs better (in terms of Pitman efficiency) than the Wilcoxon-Mann-Whitney and the Median tests for a wide range of underlying distributions. An extended Hodges-Lehmann type point estimator of the shift prameter corresponding to the proposed ‘optimal’ test statistic is also derived.     

A CLASS OF NONPARAMETRIC TESTS FOR THE ONE-SAMPLE LOCATION PROBLEM

A class of “optimal”U-statistics type nonparametric test statistics is proposed for the one-sample location problem by considering a kernel depending on a constant a and all possible (distinct) subsamples of size two from a sample of n independent and identically distributed observations. The “optimal” choice of a is determined by the underlying distribution. The proposed class includes the Sign and the modified Wilcoxon signed-rank statistics as special cases. It is shown that any “optimal” member of the class performs better in terms of Pitman efficiency relative to the Sign and Wilcoxon-signed rank statistics. The effect of deviation of chosen a from the “optimal” a on Pitman efficiency is also examined. A Hodges-Lehmann type point estimator of the location parameter corresponding to the proposed “optimal” test-statistics is also defined and studied in this paper.     

ASYMPTOTIC EFFICIENCY OF THE BLEST‐TYPE TESTS FOR INDEPENDENCE

Blest (2000, Aust. N. Z. J. Stat. 42 , 101–111) proposed a new measure of rank correlation that is sensitive to discrepancies in the small ranks. This paper investigates the efficiency properties of non‐parametric tests for independence based on Blest's correlation coefficient and its modifications. Pitman efficiency comparisons are made with analogous tests existing in the literature. Conditions for Pitman optimality of the Blest‐type tests are established.     

The chernoff efficiency of the wilcoxon rank test

Exact limiting Chernoff efficiencies of the Wilcoxon rank test are derived using Hoadley's results. Efficiency curves are derived for the two-sample Wilcoxon rank test relative to the two-sample t test for normal shift alternatives when the null hypothesis is that of common normality. The comparisons with Bahadur efficiency and small sample Hodges-Lehmann efficiency-are also made.     

On testing exponentiality against new better than used of specified age

R.M. Hollander, D.H. Park and F. Proschan [A class of life distributions for aging, J. Amer. Statist. Assoc. 81 (1986) 91–95] introduced the concept of the larger class of life distributions called new better than used of specified age. In practice, one might be interested in the new better than used behaviour at an unknown but estimable age t₀. Here, we investigate the testing of new better than used of specified age t₀ (NBU-t₀) alternatives. A class of test statistics for testing NBU-t₀ (t₀ is known) based on a U-statistic whose kernel depends on sub-sample minima is proposed. A member of the class of tests proposed by N. Ebrahimi and M. Habbibullah [Testing whether the survival distribution is new better than used of specified age, Biometrika 77 (1990) 212–215] for this problem belongs to the class of tests proposed here. The distributional properties of the class of test statistics are studied. The performances of a few members of the proposed class of tests are studied in terms of Pitman asymptotic relative efficiency. The Pitman ARE values show that the members of the class perform well in comparison with the N. Ebrahimi and M. Habbibullah [Testing whether the survival distribution is new better than used of specified age, Biometrika 77 (1990) 212–215] tests. The proposed class of tests is shown to be consistent for NBU-t₀ alternatives.     

Efficiency of tests based on weighted rankings for equality of treatment effects in a complete randomized blocks layout

Quade (1972,1979) proposed a family of nonparametric tests based on a method of weighted within-block rankings, for testing the hypothesis of no treatment effects in a complete randomized blocks layout.

In this paper we obtain an expression for the Pitman asymp-totic relative efficiency of these tests with respect to the Friedman test.     

A class of k-sample distribution-free tests for location against ordered alternatives

This paper introduces a new class of distribution-free tests for testing the homogeneity of several location parameters against ordered alternatives. The proposed class of test statistics is based on a linear combination of two-sample U-statistics based on subsample extremes. The mean and variance of the test statistic are obtained under the null hypothesis as well as under the sequence of local alternatives. The optimal weights are also determined. It is shown via Pitman ARE comparisons that the proposed class of test statistics performs better than its competitor tests in case of heavy-tailed and long-tailed distributions     

The efficiency of a test based on the asymptotic distribution of the mle for a linear functional relationship

A rigorous derivation is given of the asymptotic normality of the MLE of a linear functional relationship. Using these results, it is shown that the test proposed by VILLEGAS (1964) has Pitman efficiency zero w.r.t, a test based on the asymptotic distribution of the MLE.     

One-and two-sample sign tests for ranked set sample selective designs

Statistical inference based on a ranked set sample depends very much on the location of the quantified observations. A selective design which determines the location of the quantified observations in a ranked set sample is introduced. The paper investigates the effects of selective designs on one and two sample sign test statistics. The Pitman efficiencies of one- and two sample sign tests are calculated for selective designs and compared with ranked set samples of the same size. If the design quantifies observations at the center points, then the proposed procedure is superior to a ranked set sample of the same size in the sense of Pitman efficiency. Some practical problems are addressed for the two-sample sign test.     

Robust nonparametric tests for the two-sample location problem

We construct and investigate robust nonparametric tests for the two-sample location problem. A test based on a suitable scaling of the median of the set of differences between the two samples, which is the Hodges-Lehmann shift estimator corresponding to the Wilcoxon two-sample rank test, leads to higher robustness against outliers than the Wilcoxon test itself, while preserving its efficiency under a broad range of distributions. The good performance of the constructed test is investigated under different distributions and outlier configurations and compared to alternatives like the two-sample t-, the Wilcoxon and the median test, as well as to tests based on the difference of the sample medians or the one-sample Hodges-Lehmann estimators.     

Robust and nonparametric subset selection procedures

Subset selection procedures based on ranks have been investigated by a number of authors previously. Their methods are based on ranking the samples from all the populations jointly. However, as was pointed out by Rizvi and Woodworth (1970), the procedures they proposed cannot control the probability of a correct selection over the entire parameter space. In this paper, we propose a subset selection procedure based on pairwise rather than joint ranking of the samples. It is shown that this procedure controls the probability of a correct selection over the entire parameter space. It is also shown that the Pitman efficiency of this nonparametric procedure relative to the multivariate t procedure of Gupta (1956, 1965) is the same as the Pitman efficiency of the Mann-Whitney-Wilcoxon test relative to the t-test.     

Certain nonparametric classification rules and their asymptotic efficiencies

Two nonparametric classification rules for e-univariace populations are proposed, one in which the probability of correct classification is a specified number and the other in which one has to evaluate the probability of correct classification. In each case the classification is with respect to the Chernoff and Savage (1958) class of statistics, with possible specialization to populations having different location shifts and different changes of scale. An optimum property, namely the consistency of the classification procedure, is established for the second rule, when the distributions are either fixed or “near” in the Pitman sense and are tending to a common distribution at a specified rate. A measure of asymptotic efficiency is defined for the second rule and its asymptotic efficiency based on the Chernoff-Savage class of statistics relative to the parametric competitors ie the case of location shifts and scale changes is shown to be equal to the analogous Pitman efficiency.     

Linear rank tests for homogeneity against ordered alternatives in anova and anocova

A unified method of constructing rank tests for homogeneity against ordered alternatives in unbalanced analysis of variance and analysis of covariance is considered. The relationship between these tests with some of the existing methods are studied. The normal theory likelihood ratio tests are also derived and the asymptotic relative efficiency comparisons, in Pitman sense, of the rank tests with respect to the likelihood ratio tests are carried out.     

An asymptotic distribution-free selection procedure for a two-way layout problem

This paper deals with an asymptotic distribution-free subset selection procedure for a two-way layout problem. The treatment effect with the largest unknown value is of interest to us. The block effect is a nuisance parameter in this problem. The proposed procedure is based on the Hodges-Lehmann estimators of location parameters. The asymptotic relative efficiency of the proposed procedure with the normal means procedure is evaluated. It is shown that the proposed procedure has a high efficiency.     

Guarded Weights of Evidence and Acceptability Profiles Based on Signs: II. Asymptotic Results

The concepts of guarded weights of evidence and acceptability profiles have been extended to the distribution-free setting in Dollinger, Kulinskaya & Staudte (1999). In that first of two parts the advantages of these concepts relative to traditional ones such as p -values and confidence intervals derived from hypothesis tests are emphasized for small samples. Here in Part II asymptotic expressions are found for guarded weights of evidence for hypothesesregarding the median of a symmetric distribution and related acceptability profiles for the median. It is also seen that for local alternatives the efficacy and Pitman asymptotic relative efficiency of the sign statistic for testing hypotheses carries over to the more general setting of guarded weights of evidence.     

A decomposition of the Bradley–Blackwood paired-samples omnibus test

We show that the Bradley–Blackwood simultaneous test for equal means and equal variances in paired-samples additively decomposes into separate tests of these hypotheses. The test of equal variances in the decomposition is the standard Pitman–Morgan procedure. The test of equal means in the decomposition is based on a t-ratio with (n ? 2) degrees of freedom and has the additional restriction that the variances are equal.     

Two sample nonparametric tests based on subsamples

The paper introduces a general class of nonparametric tests for the two-sample location problem based on subsamples. Includ- ed in this class is the Mann-Whitney (or the Wilcoxon rank sum) test. General formulas for the Pitman efficacy for different methods of subsampling are derived. A small sample power simu- lation compares the performance of members of this class     

Combined sample scores versus two-sample scores under censoring

For testing the equality of K-populations against ordered alternatives a quadratic form based on two-sample scores of (K-l) pairs of adjacent samples has been suggested as an alternative to the statistic proposed by Beslow(1970). The Pitman asymptotic efficiency of the proposed statistic relative to the Breslow's statistic is found to be one or very close to one in all cases considered. The Bahadur asymptotic efficiency has also been studied and found to be at least one for the situations taken up in this paper.     

Negative exponential disparity based family of goodness-of-fit tests for multinomial models

This paper investigates a new family of goodness-of-fit tests based on the negative exponential disparities. This family includes the popular Pearson's chi-square as a member and is a subclass of the general class of disparity tests (Basu and Sarkar, 1994) which also contains the family of power divergence statistics. Pitman efficiency and finite sample power comparisons between different members of this new family are made. Three asymptotic approximations of the exact null distributions of the negative exponential disparity famiiy of tests are discussed. Some numerical results on the small sample perfomance of this family of tests are presented for the symmetric null hypothesis. It is shown that the negative exponential disparity famiiy, Like the power divergence family, produces a new goodness-of-fit test statistic that can be a very attractive alternative to the Pearson's chi-square. Some numerical results suggest that, application of this test statistic, as an alternative to Pearson's chi-square, could be preferable to the I ^2/3 statistic of Cressie and Read (1984) under the use of chi-square critical values.     

Non-parametric tests for several sample location problem based on subsample extrema

In this paper non-parametric tests for homogeneity of several populations against locationtype alternatives are proposed. For this all possible subsamples of fixed size are drawn from each sample and their maxima and minima are computed One class of tests is obtained using these subsample minima whereas other class of tests involves use of sub sample maxima. Tests belonging t o these two classes have been compared with many of the presently available tests in terms of their Pitman asymptotic relative efficiency . Some of the members of these proposed classes of tests prove to robust in terms of efficiency.