Exit, Voice and Quality in the English Education Sector

The use of choice as a mechanism to improve public service delivery is now well established in the UK. Current policy discourse additionally considers voice as a further, complementary, user-driven mechanism. In this article I scrutinize the assumption that choice (exit) and voice complement each other in creating user-driven incentives to increase quality for all consumers in the context of education. I do this by going back to Hirschman's thesis on 'Exit, Voice and Loyalty', focusing in particular on the definitions of quality put forward by him. I apply his analysis to the English education sector and show that, while the current policy discourse evokes the language of Hirschman, it doesn't follow through on the actual implications of his analysis. In particular, I argue that in the current system, choice and voice may complement each other for only a subset of consumers.     

娱乐圈里的“合伙人”

在娱乐圈这个名利场呈,每个明星都想要找寻充满友爱的生意伙伴、抱团取暖的人间至交.陈坤赵薇那样至交好友的真诚缘分;王菲林夕互相欣赏的音乐姻缘;小S蔡康永、何炅谢娜之间的惺惺相惜男女搭档,还有弥足珍贵的感人合拍在导演与演员之间重复上演……然而,诸如此类的暖暖的娱乐圈伙伴也许只是看上去很美,明星合伙人在这个纷繁复杂的娱乐圈上演了一幕幕现实与残酷,真诚与美好的剧目.