Regression spline bivariate probit models: A practical approach to testing for exogeneity

Bivariate probit models can deal with a problem usually known as endogeneity. This issue is likely to arise in observational studies when confounders are unobserved. We are concerned with testing the hypothesis of exogeneity (or absence of endogeneity) when using regression spline recursive and sample selection bivariate probit models. Likelihood ratio and gradient tests are discussed in this context and their empirical properties investigated and compared with those of the Lagrange multiplier and Wald tests through a Monte Carlo study. The tests are illustrated using two datasets in which the hypothesis of exogeneity needs to be tested.     

Near exogeneity,weak identification and specification testing: Some asymptotic results

The paper studies the asymptotic size property of various specification tests in linear structural models where instrumental variables may locally violate the exclusion restrictions. Our results provide some new insights and extensions of earlier studies. In particular, we derive an explicit formula of the asymptotic size of the tests which shows clearly the factors that influence their size under instrument endogeneity. We show that all tests have correct asymptotic size when the usual orthogonality condition holds, but their asymptotic size can be arbitrary large even if only one instrument is slightly correlated with the error term. We present a Monte Carlo experiment that confirms our theoretical findings.     

Instrument endogeneity and identification-robust tests: Some analytical results

When some explanatory variables in a regression are correlated with the disturbance term, instrumental variable methods are typically employed to make reliable inferences. Furthermore, to avoid difficulties associated with weak instruments, identification-robust methods are often proposed. However, it is hard to assess whether an instrumental variable is valid in practice because instrument validity is based on the questionable assumption that some of them are exogenous. In this paper, we focus on structural models and analyze the effects of instrument endogeneity on two identification-robust procedures, the Anderson–Rubin (1949, AR) and the Kleibergen (2002, K) tests, with or without weak instruments. Two main setups are considered: (1) the level of “instrument” endogeneity is fixed (does not depend on the sample size) and (2) the instruments are locally exogenous, i.e. the parameter which controls instrument endogeneity approaches zero as the sample size increases. In the first setup, we show that both test procedures are in general consistent against the presence of invalid instruments (hence asymptotically invalid for the hypothesis of interest), whether the instruments are “strong” or “weak”. We also describe cases where test consistency may not hold, but the asymptotic distribution is modified in a way that would lead to size distortions in large samples. These include, in particular, cases where the 2SLS estimator remains consistent, but the AR and K tests are asymptotically invalid. In the second setup, we find (non-degenerate) asymptotic non-central chi-square distributions in all cases, and describe cases where the non-centrality parameter is zero and the asymptotic distribution remains the same as in the case of valid instruments (despite the presence of invalid instruments). Overall, our results underscore the importance of checking for the presence of possibly invalid instruments when applying “identification-robust” tests.     

Time-of-Day Electricity Consumption Response to Temperature and the Ownership of Air Conditioning Appliances

This article is concerned with the endogeneity of air conditioning appliance ownership in the consumption of electricity by time of day (TOD). Both TOD consumption and air conditioning appliance ownership depend on temperature level and on household responsiveness to temperature variation, as well as on other measured household characteristics. The article presents an appropriate econometric methodology and applies it to obtain estimates and perform tests based on data from Southern California Edison's Residential TOD Pricing Experiment. The authors emphasize the implications for estimated consumption price elasticities.     

Robust block bootstrap panel predictability tests*

This article develops two block bootstrap-based panel predictability test procedures that are valid under very general conditions. Some of the allowable features include cross-sectional dependence, heterogeneous predictive slopes, persistent predictors, and complex error dynamics, including cross-unit endogeneity. While the first test procedure tests if there is any predictability at all, the second procedure determines the units for which predictability holds in case of a rejection by the first. A weak unit root framework is adopted to allow persistent predictors, and a novel theory is developed to establish asymptotic validity of the proposed bootstrap. Simulations are used to evaluate the performance of our tests in small samples, and their implementation is illustrated through an empirical application to stock returns.     

Two-Stage Bayesian Model Averaging in Endogenous Variable Models

Economic modeling in the presence of endogeneity is subject to model uncertainty at both the instrument and covariate level. We propose a Two-Stage Bayesian Model Averaging (2SBMA) methodology that extends the Two-Stage Least Squares (2SLS) estimator. By constructing a Two-Stage Unit Information Prior in the endogenous variable model, we are able to efficiently combine established methods for addressing model uncertainty in regression models with the classic technique of 2SLS. To assess the validity of instruments in the 2SBMA context, we develop Bayesian tests of the identification restriction that are based on model averaged posterior predictive p-values. A simulation study showed that 2SBMA has the ability to recover structure in both the instrument and covariate set, and substantially improves the sharpness of resulting coefficient estimates in comparison to 2SLS using the full specification in an automatic fashion. Due to the increased parsimony of the 2SBMA estimate, the Bayesian Sargan test had a power of 50% in detecting a violation of the exogeneity assumption, while the method based on 2SLS using the full specification had negligible power. We apply our approach to the problem of development accounting, and find support not only for institutions, but also for geography and integration as development determinants, once both model uncertainty and endogeneity have been jointly addressed.     

On a generalization of the test of endogeneity in a two stage least squares estimation

In situations that the predictors are correlated with the error term, we propose a bridge estimator in the two-stage least squares estimation. We apply this estimator to overcome the multicollinearity and sparsity of the explanatory variables, when the endogeneity problem is present.The proposed estimator was applied to modify the Durbin-Wu-Hausman (DWH) test of endogeneity in the presence of multicollinearity. To compare our modified test with the existing DWH for detection of an endogenous problem in multi-collinear data, some numerical assessments are carried out. The numerical results showed that the proposed estimators and the suggested test perform better for the multi-collinear data. Finally, a genetical data set is applied for illustration the our results by estimating the coefficients parameters in the presence of endogeneity and multicollinearity.     

现金-现金流敏感性能检验融资约束假说吗？

内容提要：章晓霞和吴冲锋（管理评论, 2006年第10期）以及李金等（管理评论,2007年第3期）从现金-现金流敏感性角度检验了融资约束假说,并未得出一致结论。本文从模型设定、衡量偏误、内生性偏误等角度重新审视了这个问题。研究结果表明：现金流和Tobin’s Q的内生性问题导致上述两篇文章的估计结果有偏。在采用广义矩估计方法（GMM）合理控制模型的内生性偏误后,融资约束公司表现出强烈的现金-现金流敏感性,而非融资约束公司则没有表现出这种特征。因此,本文结果支持融资约束假说,现金-现金流敏感性可以作为检验融资约束假说的依据。     

Identification and Inference With Many Invalid Instruments

We study estimation and inference in settings where the interest is in the effect of a potentially endogenous regressor on some outcome. To address the endogeneity, we exploit the presence of additional variables. Like conventional instrumental variables, these variables are correlated with the endogenous regressor. However, unlike conventional instrumental variables, they also have direct effects on the outcome, and thus are “invalid” instruments. Our novel identifying assumption is that the direct effects of these invalid instruments are uncorrelated with the effects of the instruments on the endogenous regressor. We show that in this case the limited-information-maximum-likelihood (liml) estimator is no longer consistent, but that a modification of the bias-corrected two-stage-least-square (tsls) estimator is consistent. We also show that conventional tests for over-identifying restrictions, adapted to the many instruments setting, can be used to test for the presence of these direct effects. We recommend that empirical researchers carry out such tests and compare estimates based on liml and the modified version of bias-corrected tsls. We illustrate in the context of two applications that such practice can be illuminating, and that our novel identifying assumption has substantive empirical content.     

居民对房价的预期如何影响房价变动

许多研究表明房价变动难以被经济基本面因素完全解释。市场参与者对房价的预期被认为是影响房价变动的重要因素;在土地供给缺乏弹性的情况下,居民的房价预期对房价的影响更加显著。文章利用2012-2013年中国7个重点城市开展的《中国城镇居民房价预期与购房行为专项调查》的季度调查数据对居民房价预期影响房价变动的内在经济机制进行了实证研究。研究发现,居民对房价的预期会显著影响其购房需求,从而影响未来房价的变化——本城市内居民对房价的预期水平每提高一个百分点,下一期房价增长率相应提高1.04%。文章利用微观数据和宏观数据的联合分析有效缓解了可能的内生性问题,研究结论对于理解房价波动和宏观调控工具的有效性具有较重要的意义。     

Bayesian model averaging for dynamic panels with an application to a trade gravity model

We extend the Bayesian Model Averaging (BMA) framework to dynamic panel data models with endogenous regressors using a Limited Information Bayesian Model Averaging (LIBMA) methodology. Monte Carlo simulations confirm the asymptotic performance of our methodology both in BMA and selection, with high posterior inclusion probabilities for all relevant regressors, and parameter estimates very close to their true values. In addition, we illustrate the use of LIBMA by estimating a dynamic gravity model for bilateral trade. Once model uncertainty, dynamics, and endogeneity are accounted for, we find several factors that are robustly correlated with bilateral trade. We also find that applying methodologies that do not account for either dynamics or endogeneity (or both) results in different sets of robust determinants.     

Testing parameter significance in instrumental variables probit estimators: some simulation

Binary choice models that contain endogenous regressors can now be estimated routinely using modern software. Each of the two packages, Stata 11 [Stata Statistical Software: Release 11, StataCorp LP, College Station, TX, 2009] and Limdep 9 [Econometric Software Inc., Plainview, NY, 2008], contains two estimators that can be used to estimate such a model. This paper compares the performance of maximum likelihood, Newey's Amemiya's generalized least-squares (AGLS) estimator, an instrumental variables plug-in estimator and others in samples of sizes 200 and 1000 using simulation. Specifically, this paper focuses on tests of parameter significance under various degrees of instrument strength and severity of endogeneity. Although the maximum-likelihood estimator performs well in large samples, there is some evidence that the more computationally robust AGLS estimator may perform better in smaller samples when instruments are weak. It also appears that instruments in endogenous probit estimation need to be even stronger than when used in linear instrumental variables (IV) estimation.     

The internal relocation premium: are migrants positively or negatively selected? Evidence from Italy

This paper analyzes the wage returns from internal migration for recent graduates in Italy. We employ a switching regression model that accounts for the endogeneity of the individual's choice to relocate to get a job after graduation: the omission of this selection decision can lead to biased estimates, as there is potential correlation between earnings and unobserved traits, exerting an influence on the decision to migrate. The empirical results sustain the appropriateness of the estimation technique and show that there is a significant pay gap between migrants and non-migrants; migrants seem to be positively selected and the migration premium is downward biased through OLS estimates. The endogeneity of migration shows up both as a negative intercept effect and as a positive slope effect, the second being larger than the first: bad knowledge of the local labor market and financial constraints lead migrants to accept a low basic wage but, due to relevant returns to their characteristics, they finally obtain a higher wage than the others.     

HT模型在健康人力资本对个人收入影响中的应用研究

由于在收入—健康模型中健康具有内生性,导致OLS估计结果有偏,但目前国内对此问题研究不足。采用HT模型,在有效控制健康等变量的内生性后,分析健康人力资本对个人收入的影响。通过比较发现：HT模型是比传统的FE模型更为有效的模型,能够更为精确地反映健康对个人收入的影响。     

动态广义最小二乘法在面板协整中的应用研究

在进行非平稳面板数据的协整分析时,使用动态最小二乘法（DOLS）可以有效消除内生性问题,从而得到具有渐进正态分布的统计量。但在小样本条件下,由于可使用解释变量差分项的阶数有限,导致模型中均衡误差项的序列相关,使得DOLS统计量出现严重的检验水平畸变。为此,本文将单一时间序列的动态广义最小二乘法（DGLS）应用于非平稳的同质面板数据模型。在序贯极限分布的条件下,DGLS统计量仍具有正态的条件极限分布。而仿真实验表明,对于非平稳的同质面板数据模型,即使在均衡误差项存在高序列相关的条件下,DGLS统计量仍具有较好的小样本性质。     

Semi‐parametric Estimation in a Single‐index Model with Endogenous Variables

We consider a semiparametric single‐index model and suppose that endogeneity is present in the explanatory variables. The presence of an instrument is assumed, that is, non‐correlated with the error term. We propose an estimator of the parametric component of the model, which is the solution of an ill‐posed inverse problem. The estimator is shown to be asymptotically normal under certain regularity conditions. A simulation study is conducted to illustrate the finite sample performance of the proposed estimator.     

On Baseline Conditions for Zero-Inflated Longitudinal Count Data

We describe a mixed-effect hurdle model for zero-inflated longitudinal count data, where a baseline variable is included in the model specification. Association between the count data process and the endogenous baseline variable is modeled through a latent structure, assumed to be dependent across equations. We show how model parameters can be estimated in a finite mixture context, allowing for overdispersion, multivariate association and endogeneity of the baseline variable. The model behavior is investigated through a large-scale simulation experiment. An empirical example on health care utilization data is provided.     

A comparative study on estimation methods to deal with the endogeneity in linear random-intercept models with an extension

In this paper, we investigate estimation methods to deal with situations where random intercepts are associated to time-varying covariates in the context of linear mixed models. First, a review of previous ways to deal with this so-called endogeneity issue is presented, then a new method based on shared random effects is proposed. Simulation studies and an empirical example are utilized to assess the performance of our proposed method. It is shown that our new approach is more efficient than most competitors and is robust to the misspecification of the random-effects distributions.     

The econometrics of female labor supply and children

This is a survey of applied econometric research on the effects of children on female labor supply. Reasons for interest in the topic, and a basic model and terminology, are reviewed. Concerns are raised about the possible endogeneity of child status variables, and about the instrumental variables approach for dealing with this problem. Alternative ways of conceptualizing and estimating child status effects are considered, together with selected empirical evidence. Relevant developments from the household demand literature are summarized. Basic issues of model choice are also discussed.     

Welfare gains of the poor: An endogenous Bayesian approach with spatial random effects

We introduce a Bayesian instrumental variable procedure with spatial random effects that handles endogeneity, and spatial dependence with unobserved heterogeneity. We find through a limited Monte Carlo experiment that our proposal works well in terms of point estimates and prediction. We apply our method to analyze the welfare effects generated by a process of electricity tariff unification on the poorest households. In particular, we deduce an Equivalent Variation measure where there is a budget constraint for a two-tiered pricing scheme, and find that 10% of the poorest municipalities attained welfare gains above 2% of their initial income.