Generalized mean squared error properties of regression estimators

Theobald (1974) compares Ordinary Least Squares and Ridge Regression estimators of regression parameters using a generalized mean squared error criterion. This paper presents the generalized mean squared error of a Principal Components Regression estimator and comparisons are made with each of the above estimators. In general the choice of which estimator to use depends on the magnitude and the orientation of the unknown parameter vector.     

A simulation study of least squares and ridge estimaors for normal and nonnormal autocorrelated disturbances

The purpose of this paper is to examine the small sample properties of various ridge estimators along with least squares, in some special settings.Specifically, we consider a first order autoregressive structuure for normal and nonnormal disturbances, and report on a Monte Carlo study the small sample behavior of these estimators according to the criteria of bias and dispersion.The results suggest that under all the examined settings and for all the criteria used the HKB estimator exhibited a superior performance compared to the other estimators, while the LS and LW estimators gave consistently poor results.Also if the error term is only moderately autocorrelated the performance of the ridge estimators that do not account for autocorrelation outperform their counterparts as well as least squares that account for autocorrelation.     

A note on the moments of stochastic shrinkage parameters in ridge regression

The purpose of this note is to gain insight on the performance of two well known operational Ridge Regression estimators by deriving the moments of their stochastic shrinkage parameters. We also show that, under certain conditions, one of them has bounded moments.     

THE DISTRIBUTION OF STOCHASTIC SHRINKAGE PARAMETERS IN RIDGE REGRESSION

ABSTRACT

In this article we derive the density and distribution functions of the stochastic shrinkage parameters of three well known operational Ridge Regression (RR) estimators by assuming normality. The stochastic behavior of these parameters is likely to affect the properties of the resulting RR estimator, therefore such knowledge can be useful in the selection of the shrinkage rule. Some numerical calculations are carried out to illustrate the behavior of these distributions, throwing light on the performance of the different RR estimators.     

ON SPLINE SMOOTHING WITH AUTOCORRELATED ERRORS

The generalised cross-validation criterion for choosing the degree of smoothing in spline regression is extended to accommodate an autocorrelated error sequence. It is demonstrated via simulation that the minimum generalised cross-validation smoothing spline is an inconsistent estimator in the presence of autocorrelated errors and that ignoring even moderate autocorrelation structure can seriously affect the performance of the cross-validated smoothing spline. The method of penalised maximum likelihood is used to develop an efficient algorithm for the case in which the autocorrelation decays exponentially. An application of the method to a published data-set is described. The method does not require the data to be equally spaced in time.     

On preliminary test ridge regression estimators for linear restrictions in a regression model with non-normal disturbances

In this paper, we study the properties of the preliminary test, restricted and unrestricted ridge regression estimators of the linear regression model with non-normal disturbances. We present the estimators of the regression coefficients combining the idea of preliminary test and ridge regression methodology, when it is suspected that the regression coefficients may be restricted to a subspace and the regression error is distributed as multivariate t. Accordingly we consider three estimators, namely the Unrestricted Ridge Regression Estimator (URRRE), the Restricted Ridge Regression Estimator (RRRE) and finally the Preliminary test Ridge Regression Estimator (PTRRE). The biases and the mean square error (MSE) of the estimators are derived under the null and alternative hypotheses and compared with the usual estimators. By studying the MSE criterion, the regions of optimahty of the estimators are determined.     

Monte Carlo Simulation Study of Biased Estimators in the Linear Regression Models with Correlated or Heteroscedastic Errors

In this study, the performance of the estimators proposed in the presence of multicollinearity in the linear regression model with heteroscedastic or correlated or both error terms is investigated under the matrix mean square error criterion. Structures of the autocorrelated error terms are given and a Monte Carlo simulation study is conducted to examine the relative efficiency of the estimators against each other.     

Ridge estimation in regression problems with autocorrelated errors: A monte carlo study

This paper presents the results of a Monte Carlo study of OLS and GLS based adaptive ridge estimators for regression problems in which the independent variables are collinear and the errors are autocorrelated. It studies the effects of degree of collinearity, magnitude of error variance, orientation of the parameter vector and serial correlation of the independent variables on the mean squared error performance of these estimators. Results suggest that such estimators produce greatly improved performance in favorable portions of the parameter space. The GLS based methods are best when the independent variables are also serially correlated.     

Some Asymptotic Properties of Ridge Regression in a System of Seemingly Unrelated Regression Equations

A discussion is made of asymptotic properties of an Operational Ordinary Ridge Regression estimator and comparison is made with the Operational Generalized Least Squares estimator. Also, some simulation experiments are carried showing efficiency gains can be made through the use of de Ridge estimator.     

The small sample performance of some limited information estimators of a dynamic structural equation with autocorrelated errors †

This paper examines the small sample properties of the following seven estimators of a dynamic structural equation with autocorrelated errors: (1) 2SLS; (2) Fair’s modification of Sargan’s 2SLS; (3) the Dhrymes, Berner and Cummins (1974) variant of 2SLS; (4) a modified Theil's (1958) generalized 2SLS; (5) three two-step estimators proposed by Hatanaka (1976). Our principal results are that for low degrees of autocorrelation 2SLS performs well whereas for high degrees of autocorrelation the Theil and Dhrymes estimators are best with two of Hatanaka’s estimators close behind. The Fair and the remaining Hatanaka estimator are always dominated by the others. This is of some practical interest because the Fair estimator is a standard option in some software packages.     

A Combined Nonlinear Programming Model and Kibria Method for Choosing Ridge Parameter Regression

Ridge regression solves multicollinearity problems by introducing a biasing parameter that is called ridge parameter; it shrinks the estimates as well as their standard errors in order to reach acceptable results. Many methods are available for estimating a ridge parameter. This article has considered some of these methods and also proposed a combined nonlinear programming model and Kibria method. A simulation study has been made to evaluate the performance of the proposed estimators based on the minimum mean squared error criterion. The simulation study indicates that under certain conditions the proposed estimators outperform the least squares (LS) estimators and other popular existing estimators. Moreover, the new proposed model is applied on dataset that suffers also from the presence of heteroscedastic errors.     

A simulation study on SPSS ridge regression and ordinary least squares regression procedures for multicollinearity data

This study compares the SPSS ordinary least squares (OLS) regression and ridge regression procedures in dealing with multicollinearity data. The LS regression method is one of the most frequently applied statistical procedures in application. It is well documented that the LS method is extremely unreliable in parameter estimation while the independent variables are dependent (multicollinearity problem). The Ridge Regression procedure deals with the multicollinearity problem by introducing a small bias in the parameter estimation. The application of Ridge Regression involves the selection of a bias parameter and it is not clear if it works better in applications. This study uses a Monte Carlo method to compare the results of OLS procedure with the Ridge Regression procedure in SPSS.     

Study of partial least squares and ridge regression methods

This article considers both Partial Least Squares (PLS) and Ridge Regression (RR) methods to combat multicollinearity problem. A simulation study has been conducted to compare their performances with respect to Ordinary Least Squares (OLS). With varying degrees of multicollinearity, it is found that both, PLS and RR, estimators produce significant reductions in the Mean Square Error (MSE) and Prediction Mean Square Error (PMSE) over OLS. However, from the simulation study it is evident that the RR performs better when the error variance is large and the PLS estimator achieves its best results when the model includes more variables. However, the advantage of the ridge regression method over PLS is that it can provide the 95% confidence interval for the regression coefficients while PLS cannot.     

Ridge Regression and Generalized Maximum Entropy: An improved version of the Ridge–GME parameter estimator

In this article, the Ridge–GME parameter estimator, which combines Ridge Regression and Generalized Maximum Entropy, is improved in order to eliminate the subjectivity in the analysis of the ridge trace. A serious concern with the visual inspection of the ridge trace to define the supports for the parameters in the Ridge–GME parameter estimator is the misinterpretation of some ridge traces, in particular where some of them are very close to the axes. A simulation study and two empirical applications are used to illustrate the performance of the improved estimator. A MATLAB code is provided as supplementary material.     

Small sample properties of estimators in the autocorrelated error model: a review and some additional simulations

This paper provides a review of the literature concerning estimation in time series regression with first-order autocorrelated disturbances. Some additional simulation results confirm that the Cochrane-Orcutt estimator should not be used to correct for autocorrelation whether the explanatory variable is trended or not. Preferred estimators include a Bayesian estimator, full maximum likelihood and the iterative Prais-Winsten estimator. The authors would like to thank the referee for helpful comments which served to improve the paper.     

Weighted denoised minimum distance estimation in a regression model with autocorrelated measurement errors

This paper deals with the linear regression model with measurement errors in both response and covariates. The variables are observed with errors together with an auxiliary variable, such as time, and the errors in response are autocorrelated. We propose a weighted denoised minimum distance estimator (WDMDE) for the regression coefficients. The consistency, asymptotic normality, and strong convergence rate of the WDMDE are proved. Compared with the usual denoised least squares estimator (DLSE) in the previous literature, the WDMDE is asymptotically more efficient in the sense of having smaller variances. It also avoids undersmoothing the regressor functions over the auxiliary variable, so that data-driven optimal choice of the bandwidth can be used. Furthermore, we consider the fitting of the error structure, construct the estimators of the autocorrelation coefficients and the error variances, and derive their large-sample properties. Simulations are conducted to examine the finite sample performance of the proposed estimators, and an application of our methodology to analyze a set of real data is illustrated as well.     

Good ridge estimators based on prior information

Ridge regression is re-examined and ridge estimators based on prior information are introduced. A necessary and sufficient condition is given for such ridge estimators to yield estimators of every nonnull linear combination of the regression coefficients with smaller mean square error than that of the Gauss-Markov best linear unbiased estimator.     

Automated selection of post‐strata using a model‐assisted regression tree estimator

Despite having desirable properties, model‐assisted estimators are rarely used in anything but their simplest form to produce official statistics. This is due to the fact that the more complicated models are often ill suited to the available auxiliary data. Under a model‐assisted framework, we propose a regression tree estimator for a finite‐population total. Regression tree models are adept at handling the type of auxiliary data usually available in the sampling frame and provide a model that is easy to explain and justify. The estimator can be viewed as a post‐stratification estimator where the post‐strata are automatically selected by the recursive partitioning algorithm of the regression tree. We establish consistency of the regression tree estimator and a variance estimator, along with asymptotic normality of the regression tree estimator. We compare the performance of our estimator to other survey estimators using the United States Bureau of Labor Statistics Occupational Employment Statistics Survey data.     

A non stochastic ridge regression estimator and comparison with the James-Stein estimator

Abstract

This article presents a non-stochastic version of the Generalized Ridge Regression estimator that arises from a discussion of the properties of a Generalized Ridge Regression estimator whose shrinkage parameters are found to be close to their upper bounds. The resulting estimator takes the form of a shrinkage estimator that is superior to both the Ordinary Least Squares estimator and the James-Stein estimator under certain conditions. A numerical study is provided to investigate the range of signal to noise ratio under which the new estimator dominates the James-Stein estimator with respect to the prediction mean square error.     

The exact properties of the lawless and wang operational ridge regression estimator in a misspecified regression equation

The exact properties of the Lawless and Wang Operational Ridge Regression estimator are derived in the context of a misspecified regression equation.