Optimal block designs comparing treatments with a control when the errors are correlated

The efficient design of experiments for comparing a control with v new treatments when the data are dependent is investigated. We concentrate on generalized least-squares estimation for a known covariance structure. We consider block sizes k equal to 3 or 4 and approximate designs. This method may lead to exact optimal designs for some v, b, k, but usually will only indicate the structure of an efficient design for any particular v, b, k, and yield an efficiency bound, usually unattainable. The bound and the structure can then be used to investigate efficient finite designs.     

On the optimality of a class of minimal covering designs

It is shown that the minimal covering designs for v=6t+5 treatments in blocks of size 3 are optimal w.r.t. a large class of optimality criteria. This class of optimality criteria includes the well-known criteria of A-, D- and E-optimality. It is conjectured that these designs are also optimal w.r.t. other criteria suggested by Takeuchi (1961).     

Non-binary neighbor balance circular designs for v=2n and λ=2

Neighbor balance designs were first introduced by Rees (1967) in circular blocks for the use in serological research. Subsequently several researchers have defined the neighbor designs in different ways. In this paper, neighbor balance circular designs for (k≤v) block size are constructed for even number of treatments i.e. v=2n. No such series of designs is known in literature. Two theorems are developed for circular designs. Theorem 1 gives the non-binary circular blocks, whereas Theorem 2 generates binary circular blocks when n≤4 and non-binary blocks for n>4. In suggested designs no treatment is ever a neighbor of itself. Blocks are constructed in such a way that each treatment is a right and left neighbor of every other treatment for a fixed number of times say λ. Sizes of initial circular blocks are not same. One main guiding principle for such designs is to ensure economy in material use.     

Equineighboured balanced nested row-column designs

This paper presents equineighboured balanced nested row-column designs for v treatments arranged in b blocks each comprising pq units further grouped into p rows and q columns. These are two-dimensional designs with the property that all pairs of treatments are neighbours equally frequently at all levels in both rows and columns. Methods of construction are given both for designs based on Latin squares and those where pq≤v. Cyclic equineighboured designs are defined and tabulated for 5≤v≤10, p≤3, q≤5, where r=bpq/v is the number of replications of each treatment.     

Comparing more than one treatment to more than one control in incomplete blocks

The class of balanced treatment incomplete block designs is generalized to allow for comparison of v₁ test treatments and v₂ control treatments. The generalized class is equivalent to the class of balanced bipartite block designs considered by Jaggi, Gupta, and Parsad. Some results on design construction and A-optimality are given for small values of v₁ and v₂. Algorithms are developed for computing simultaneous confidence bounds for all test treatment versus control contrasts.     

Optimal regular graph designs

A typical problem in optimal design theory is finding an experimental design that is optimal with respect to some criteria in a class of designs. The most popular criteria include the A- and D-criteria. Regular graph designs occur in many optimality results, and if the number of blocks is large enough, an A-optimal (or D-optimal) design is among them (if any exist). To explore the landscape of designs with a large number of blocks, we introduce extensions of regular graph designs. These are constructed by adding the blocks of a balanced incomplete block design repeatedly to the original design. We present the results of an exact computer search for the best regular graph designs and the best extended regular graph designs with up to 20 treatments v, block size \(k \le 10\) and replication r \(\le 10\) and \(r(k-1)-(v-1)\lfloor r(k-1)/(v-1)\rfloor \le 9\).     

D-optimal block designs with at most six varieties

For given positive integers v, b, and k (all of them ≥2) a block design is a k × b array of the variety labels 1,…,v with blocks as columns. For the usual one-way heterogeneity model in standard form the problem is studied of finding a D-optimal block design for estimating the variety contrasts, when no balanced block design (BBD) exists. The paper presents solutions to this problem for v≤6. The results on D-optimality are derived from a graph-theoretic context. Block designs can be considered as multigraphs, and a block design is D-optimal iff its multigraph has greatest complexity (=number of spanning trees).     

Some further results on the MV-optimality of block designs for comparing test treatments to a standard treatment

In this paper we further consider the problem of determining optimal block designs which can be used to compare v test treatments to a standard treatment in experimental situations where the available experimental units are to be arranged in b blocks of size k. A design is said to be MV-optimal in such an experimental setting it is minimizes the maximal variance with which treatment differences involving the standard treatment are estimated. In this paper we derive some further sufficient conditions for a design to be MV-optimal in an experimental situation such as described above.     

E-optimal incomplete block designs with two distinct block sizes

Sufficient conditions are derived for the determination of E-optimal designs in the class D(v,b₁,b₂,k₁,k₂) of incomplete block designs for v treatments in b₁ blocks of size k₁ each and b₂ blocks of size k₂ each. Some constructions for E-optimal designs that satisfy the sufficient conditions obtained here are given. In particular, it is shown that E-optimal designs in D(v,b₁,b₂,k₁,k₂) can be constructed by augmenting b₂ blocks, with k₂ − k₁ extra plots each, of a BIBD(v,b = b₁ + b₂,k₁,λ) and GDD(v,b = b₁ + b₂,k₁,λ₁,λ₂). It is also shown that equireplicate E-optimal designs in D(v,b₁,b₂,k₁,k₂) can be constructed by combining disjoint blocks of BIBD(v,b,k₁,λ) and GDD(v,b,k₁,λ₁,λ₂) into larger blocks. As applications of the construction techniques, several infinite series of E-optimal designs with small block sizes differing by at most two are given. Lower bounds for the A-efficiency are derived and it is found that A-efficiency exceeds 99% for v ⩾ 10, and at least 97.5% for 5 ⩽v < 10.     

Orthogonal sets of balanced incomplete block designs with nested rows and column

Known series of balanced incomplete block designs with nested rows and columns are used to find orthogonal sets of these designs, producing main effects plans in nested rows and columns. Two infinite series are so constructed and shown to be universally optimum for the analysis with recovery of row and column information, a benefit produced by the additional higher strata orthogonality they enjoy. One of these series achieves orthogonality with just v − 1 replicates of v treatments, fewer than required by Latin squares.     

Serial arrays and change-over designs

Consider change-over designs for the comparison of v treatments. Each application has a direct effect and up to n?1 residual and/or interaction effects. An array is defined to be a serial array if: (1) all treatments occur equally often in each row and (2) reading down columns, all possible permutations of n consecutive treatments occur equally often in the array. A method of constructing (λv+n?1) Xv^{n ?1}, λ integral, serial arrays is given. Use of these arrays as change-over designs is discussed with emphasis on the inclusion of interaction effects.     

On bounds for the efficiency of block designs for comparing test treatments with a control

In this paper we study the class of augmented balanced incomplete block designs, which are used for comparing a control treatment with a set of test treatments. Under the A- criterion we establish a condition that enables us to determine the most efficient augmented design and we suggest some methods to compute a lower bound for the efficiency of these designs. For 3≤k≤10, v≥k, we list the parameters of the most efficient designs with a lower bound for their efficiency or, if known, mention their optimality.     

Complete designs with blocks of maximal multiplicity

The set of distinct blocks of a block design is known as its support. We construct complete designs with parameters v(?7), k=3, λ=v ? 2 which contain a block of maximal multiplicity and with support size $\text{b}{}^1\text{= (}{}^{\mathrm{v}}{}_3\text{) ? 4(v ? 2)}$. Any complete design which contains such a block, and has parameters v, k, λ as above, must be supported on at most (^v₃) ? 4(v ? 2) blocks. Attention is given to complete designs because of their direct relationship to simple random sampling.     

A survey of nested designs

A nest with parameters (r,k,λ)→(r′,k′,λ′) is a BIBD on (b,v,r,k,λ) where each block has a distinguished sublock of cardinality k, the sublocks forming a (b,v,r,k,λ)-design.These designs are ‘nested’ in the sense of W.T. Federer (1972), who recommended the use of these designs for the sequential addition of periods in marketing experiments in order to retain Youden design properties as rows are added. Note that for a Youden design, the b columns and v treatments are in an SBIBD arrangement with parameters v=b, k=r, and λ.     

Model robust extrapolation designs

We seek designs which are optimal in some sense for extrapolation when the true regression function is in a certain class of regression functions. More precisely, the class is defined to be the collection of regression functions such that its (h + 1)-th derivative is bounded. The class can be viewed as representing possible departures from an ‘ideal’ model and thus describes a model robust setting. The estimates are restricted to be linear and the designs are restricted to be with minimal number of points. The design and estimate sought is minimax for mean square error. The optimal designs for cases X = [0, ∞] and X = [-1, 1], where X is the place where observations can be taken, are discussed.     

Orthogonal arrays and ordered designs

In the first part of this paper, we give a short and direct construction of signed orthogonal array SOA(λ,t,k,v), for any set of parameters λ,t,k,v,t ⩽ k. We also construct a specific basis of the Z-module generated by any SOA(0,t,k,v), for any t,k,v,t ⩽ k. We will then construct an inite family of large set of disjoint ordered designs by applying G.B. Khosrovshahi and S. Ajoodani-Namini's method to Luc. Teirlinck's construction.     

On optimality properties of simple block designs in the approximate design theory

Optimality properties of approximate block designs are studied under variations of (1) the class of competing designs, (2) the optimality criterion, (3) the parametric function of interest, and (4) the statistical model. The designs which are optimal turn out to be the product of their treatment and block marginals, and uniform designs when the support is specified in advance. Optimality here means uniform, universal, and simultaneous j_p-optimality. The classical balanced incomplete block designs are embedded into this approach, and shown to be simultaneously j_p-optimal for a maximal system of identifiable parameters. A geometric account of universal optimality is given which applies beyond the context of block designs.     

Designs for weighted least squares regression, with estimated weights

We study designs, optimal up to and including terms that are O(n ^?1), for weighted least squares regression, when the weights are intended to be inversely proportional to the variances but are estimated with random error. We take a finite, but arbitrarily large, design space from which the support points are to be chosen, and obtain the optimal proportions of observations to be assigned to each point. Specific examples of D- and I-optimal design for polynomial responses are studied. In some cases the same designs that are optimal under homoscedasticity remain so for a range of variance functions; in others there tend to be more support points than are required in the homoscedastic case. We also exhibit minimax designs, that minimize the maximum, over finite classes of variance functions, value of the loss. These also tend to have more support points, often resulting from the breaking down of replicates into clusters.     

On the determination and construction of E-optimal block designs in the presence of linear trends

In this paper we consider experimental situations in which v treatments are to be applied to experimental units arranged in b blocks of size k = 3 and where there may be unknown or uncontrollable linear trends (possibly different) within blocks. Methods are given here for determining and constructing E-optimal designs for such situations.     

Optimal blocking and foldover plans for nonregular two-level designs

This paper discusses the issue of choosing optimal designs when both blocking and foldover techniques are simultaneously employed to nonregular two-level fractional factorial designs. By using the indicator function, the treatment and block generalized wordlength patterns of the combined blocked design under a general foldover plan are defined. Some general properties of combined block designs are also obtained. Our results extend the findings of Ai et al. (2010) from regular designs to nonregular designs. Based on these theoretical results, a catalog of optimal blocking and foldover plans in terms of the generalized aberration criterion for nonregular initial design with 12, 16 and 20 runs is tabulated, respectively.