A Simulator for Twenty20 Cricket

This paper develops a Twenty20 cricket simulator for matches between sides belonging to the International Cricket Council. As input, the simulator requires the probabilities of batting outcomes which are dependent on the batsman, the bowler, the number of overs consumed and the number of wickets lost. The determination of batting probabilities is based on an amalgam of standard classical estimation techniques and a hierarchical empirical Bayes approach where the probabilities of batting outcomes borrow information from related scenarios. Initially, the probabilities of batting outcomes are obtained for the first innings. In the second innings, the target score obtained from the first innings affects the aggressiveness of batting during the second innings. We use the target score to modify batting probabilities in the second innings simulation. This gives rise to the suggestion that teams may not be adjusting their second innings batting aggressiveness in an optimal way. The adequacy of the simulator is addressed through various goodness‐of‐fit diagnostics.     

Optimal lineups in Twenty20 cricket

ABSTRACT

This paper considers the determination of optimal team lineups in Twenty20 cricket where a lineup consists of three components: team selection, batting order and bowling order. Via match simulation, we estimate the expected runs scored minus the expected runs allowed for a given lineup. The lineup is then optimized over a vast combinatorial space via simulated annealing. We observe that the composition of an optimal Twenty20 lineup sometimes results in non-traditional roles for players. As a by-product of the methodology, we obtain an ‘all-star’ lineup selected from international Twenty20 cricketers.     

Modelling and simulation for one‐day cricket

This article is concerned with the simulation of one‐day cricket matches. Given that only a finite number of outcomes can occur on each ball that is bowled, a discrete generator on a finite set is developed where the outcome probabilities are estimated from historical data involving one‐day international cricket matches. The probabilities depend on the batsman, the bowler, the number of wickets lost, the number of balls bowled and the innings. The proposed simulator appears to do a reasonable job at producing realistic results. The simulator allows investigators to address complex questions involving one‐day cricket matches. The Canadian Journal of Statistics © 2009 Statistical Society of Canada     

On generalized geometric distributions and improved estimation of batting average in cricket

Batting average is the most popular way of measuring a batsman's performance in cricket. However, in light of scores from not-out innings, the conventional way of computing the batting average is unsatisfactory from theoretical statistical perspective, as well as from intuitive and practitioner's point of view. We adopt alternative methods of calculating batting average, treating not-outs as right-censored data and using generalized class of geometric distributions (GGD) as models for the runs scored. In the proposed family of GGD, the generalization lies in the hazard of getting out possibly changing from one score to another. Each postulated structure of the hazards leads to a different member of the GGD family. Selection of appropriate member from the GGD family and maximum likelihood estimation of the hazard parameters in the model are discussed theoretically with illustrations. The proposed method subsumes the traditional average and product limit (Kaplan-Meier) estimate as the two extreme scenarios within this structure. We also discuss two alternative methods of estimating the true mean under the proposed framework and deliberate on issues while adopting these practices in practice.     

Predicting the outcomes of annual sporting contests

Summary.  Data from 20 sporting contests in which the same two teams compete regularly are studied. Strong and weak symmetry requirements for possible models are identified, and some simple models are proposed and fitted to the data. The need to compute the exact likelihood function and the presence of missing values make this non-trivial. Forecasting match outcomes by using the models can give a modest improvement over a naïve forecast. Significance tests for studying the effect of 'match covariates' such as playing at home or away or winning the toss are introduced, and the effect of these covariates is in general found to be quite large.     

Neutral umpires and leg before wicket decisions in test cricket

Summary.  The proportions of dismissals which were leg before wicket in test cricket matches during 1978–2004 are analysed by using generalized linear and mixed models to assess the effect of location, team and the presence or otherwise of neutral umpires. The location and the team batting are clearly significant. There is also clear evidence of an interaction showing that some teams' players are out leg before wicket less often at home but there is no further interaction with neutral umpires, suggesting that this is not caused simply by home umpires favouring the home team.     

Predictions and home advantage for Australian rules football

In a previous paper, it was demonstrated that distinctly different prediction methods when applied to 2435 American college and professional football games resulted in essentially the same fraction of correct selections of the winning team and essentially the same average absolute error for predicting the margin of victory. These results are now extended to 1446 Australian rules football games. Two distinctly different prediction methods are applied. A least-squares method provides a set of ratings. The predicted margin of victory in the next contest is less than the rating difference, corrected for home-ground advantage, while a 0.75 power method shrinks the ratings compared with those found by the least-squares technique and then performs predictions based on the rating difference and home-ground advantage. Both methods operate upon past margins of victory corrected for home advantage to obtain the ratings. It is shown that both methods perform similarly, based on the fraction of correct selections of the winning team and the average absolute error for predicting the margin of victory. That is, differing predictors using the same information tend to converge to a limiting level of accuracy. The least-squares approach also provides estimates of the accuracy of each prediction. The home advantage is evaluated for all teams collectively and also for individual teams. The data permit comparisons with other sports in other countries. The home team appears to have an advantage (the visiting team has a disadvantage) due to three factors:the visiting team suffers from travel fatigue; crowd intimidation by the home team fans; lack of familiarity with the playing conditions     

MODELLING THE 2004 SUPER 12 RUGBY UNION COMPETITION

This paper uses Bayesian methods via WinBUGS to model round robin play in the 2004 Super 12 Rugby Union competition in order to explore home advantage and how that impacts the outcome of the competition. The scores from the games are decomposed into counts of converted and unconverted tries, penalties and drop goals and are modelled as Poisson random variables with a log link. The dependent variables are the offensive and defensive capabilities of the teams along with terms for home advantage. The model is used to ascertain the effects of home advantage on the standings of the teams in the competition and, from that, how fairness in the competition could be improved.     

Paired comparison models applied to the design of the Major League baseball play-offs

This paper presents an analysis of the eff ect of various baseball play-off configurations on the probability of advancing to the World Series. Play-off games are assumed to be independent. Several paired comparisons models are considered for modeling the probability of a home team winning a single game as a function of the winning percentages of the contestants over the course of the season. The uniform and logistic regression models are both adequate, whereas the Bradley-Terry model (modified for within-pair order eff ects, i.e. the home field advantage) is not. The single-game probabilities are then used to compute the probability of winning the play-off s under various structures. The extra round of play-off s, instituted in 1994, significantly lowers the probability of the team with the best record advancing to the World Series, whereas home field advantage and the diff erent possible play-offdraws have a minimal eff ect.     

Modelling rugby league data viabivariate negative binomial regression

This paper uses a new bivariate negative binomial distribution to model scores in the 1996 Australian Rugby League competition. First, scores are modelled using the home ground advantage but ignoring the actual teams playing. Then a bivariate negative binomial regression model is introduced that takes into account the offensive and defensive capacities of each team. Finally, the 1996 season is simulated using the latter model to determine whether or not Manly did indeed deserve to win the competition.     

The effectiveness of coach turnover and the effect on home team advantage,team quality and team ranking

The effectiveness of coach turnover on team performance is widely discussed in the literature due to the indirect impact of a team's performance on a club's revenues. This study examines the effect of coach turnover within a competition season by focusing on the change in team quality and the change in home team advantage under the new coach. The change in team quality or home team advantage can vary according to the team (team specific) or might be an independent quantity (non-team specific). We estimated nine possible regression models, given no change, team-specific change and non-team-specific change in quality or home team advantage. The data are the match results of Belgian male soccer teams playing in the highest national division during seven seasons. Results point to a team-specific effect of a new coach on a team's quality. This article further contributes by evaluating the new coach's success with regard to whether his ability to improve team quality also results in a better position of the team in the final ranking. A new coach will be able to improve the ranking of the team if the improved team quality under the new coach renders a positive team quality.     

Are football referees really biased and inconsistent?: evidence on the incidence of disciplinary sanction in the English Premier League

Summary.  The paper presents a statistical analysis of patterns in the incidence of disciplinary sanction (yellow and red cards) that were taken against players in the English Premier League over the period 1996–2003. Several questions concerning sources of inconsistency and bias in refereeing standards are examined. Evidence is found to support a time consistency hypothesis, that the average incidence of disciplinary sanction is predominantly stable over time. However, a refereeing consistency hypothesis, that the incidence of disciplinary sanction does not vary between referees, is rejected. The tendency for away teams to incur more disciplinary points than home teams cannot be attributed to the home advantage effect on match results and appears to be due to a refereeing bias favouring the home team.     

Construction of a semi-Markov model for the performance of a football team in the presence of missing data

Using play-by-play data from the very beginning of the professional football league in Turkey, a semi-Markov model is presented for describing the performance of football teams. The official match results of the selected teams during 55 football seasons are used and winning, drawing and losing are considered as Markov states. The semi-Markov model is constructed with transition rates inferred from the official match results. The duration between the last match of a season and the very first match of the following season is much longer than any other duration during the season. Therefore these values are considered as missing values and estimated by using expectation–maximization algorithm. The effect of the sojourn time in a state to the performance of a team is discussed as well as mean sojourn times after losing/winning are estimated. The limiting probabilities of winning, drawing and losing are calculated. Some insights about the performance of the selected teams are presented.     

Patterns of NBA team performance from 1950 to 1998

This paper examines team performance in the NBA over the last five decades. It was motivated by two previous observational studies, one of which studied the winning percentages of professional baseball teams over time, while the other examined individual player performance in the NBA. These studies considered professional sports as evolving systems, a view proposed by evolutionary biologist Stephen Jay Gould, who wrote extensively on the disappearance of .400 hitters in baseball. Gould argued that the disappearance is actually a sign of improvement in the quality of play, reflected in the reduction of variability in hitting performance. The previous studies reached similar conclusions in terms of winning percentages of baseball teams, and performance of individual players in basketball. This paper uses multivariate measures of team performance in the NBA to see if similar characteristics of evolution can be observed. The conclusion does not appear to be clearly affirmative, as in previous studies, and possible reasons for this are discussed.     

Experience Simpson's Paradox in the Classroom

Simpson's paradox is a challenging topic to teach in an introductory statistics course. To motivate students to understand this paradox both intuitively and statistically, this article introduces several new ways to teach Simpson's paradox. We design a paper toss activity between instructors and students in class to engage students in the learning process. We show that Simpson's paradox widely exists in basketball statistics, and thus instructors may consider looking for Simpson's paradox in their own school basketball teams as examples to motivate students’ interest. A new probabilistic explanation of Simpson's paradox is provided, which helps foster students’ statistical understanding. Supplementary materials for this article are available online.     

Do Baseball Players Regress toward the Mean?

Baseball performances are an imperfect measure of baseball abilities, and consequently exaggerate differences in abilities. Predictions of relative batting averages and earned run averages can be improved substantially by using correlation coefficients estimated from earlier seasons to shrink performances toward the mean.     

An individual measure of relative survival

Summary.  Relative survival techniques are used to compare survival experience in a study cohort with that expected if background population rates apply. The techniques are especially useful when cause-specific death information is not accurate or not available as they provide a measure of excess mortality in a group of patients with a certain disease. Whereas these methods are based on group comparisons, we present here a transformation approach which instead gives for each individual an outcome measure relative to the appropriate background population. The new outcome measure is easily interpreted and can be analysed by using standard survival analysis techniques. It provides additional information on relative survival and gives new options in regression analysis. For example, one can estimate the proportion of patients who survived longer than a given percentile of the respective general population or compare survival experience of individuals while accounting for the population differences. The regression models for the new outcome measure are different from existing models, thus providing new possibilities in analysing relative survival data. One distinctive feature of our approach is that we adjust for expected survival before modelling. The paper is motivated by a study into the survival of patients after acute myocardial infarction.     

Accuracy and fairness of rain rules for interrupted one-day cricket matches

In this paper, we investigate the relative merits of rain rules for one-day cricket matches. We suggest that interrupted one-day matches present a missing data problem: the outcome of the complete match cannot be observed, and instead the outcome of the interrupted match, as determined at least in part by the rain rule in question, is observed. Viewing the outcome of the interrupted match as an imputation of the missing outcome of the complete match, standard characteristics to assess the performance of classification tests can be used to assess the performance of a rain rule. In particular, we consider the overall and conditional accuracy and the predictive value of a rain rule. We propose two requirements for a ‘fair’ rain rule, and show that a fair rain rule must satisfy an identity involving its conditional accuracies. Estimating the performance characteristics of various rain rules from a sample of complete one-day matches our results suggest that the Duckworth–Lewis method, currently adopted by the International Cricket Council, is essentially as accurate as and somewhat more fair than its best competitors. A rain rule based on the iso-probability principle also performs well but might benefit from re-calibration using a more representative data base.     

Bayesian composite quantile regression

One advantage of quantile regression, relative to the ordinary least-square (OLS) regression, is that the quantile regression estimates are more robust against outliers and non-normal errors in the response measurements. However, the relative efficiency of the quantile regression estimator with respect to the OLS estimator can be arbitrarily small. To overcome this problem, composite quantile regression methods have been proposed in the literature which are resistant to heavy-tailed errors or outliers in the response and at the same time are more efficient than the traditional single quantile-based quantile regression method. This paper studies the composite quantile regression from a Bayesian perspective. The advantage of the Bayesian hierarchical framework is that the weight of each component in the composite model can be treated as open parameter and automatically estimated through Markov chain Monte Carlo sampling procedure. Moreover, the lasso regularization can be naturally incorporated into the model to perform variable selection. The performance of the proposed method over the single quantile-based method was demonstrated via extensive simulations and real data analysis.     

Relative Risk Regression for Binary Outcomes: Methods and Recommendations

Relative risks are often considered preferable to odds ratios for quantifying the association between a predictor and a binary outcome. Relative risk regression is an alternative to logistic regression where the parameters are relative risks rather than odds ratios. It uses a log link binomial generalised linear model, or log‐binomial model, which requires parameter constraints to prevent probabilities from exceeding 1. This leads to numerical problems with standard approaches for finding the maximum likelihood estimate (MLE), such as Fisher scoring, and has motivated various non‐MLE approaches. In this paper we discuss the roles of the MLE and its main competitors for relative risk regression. It is argued that reliable alternatives to Fisher scoring mean that numerical issues are no longer a motivation for non‐MLE methods. Nonetheless, non‐MLE methods may be worthwhile for other reasons and we evaluate this possibility for alternatives within a class of quasi‐likelihood methods. The MLE obtained using a reliable computational method is recommended, but this approach requires bootstrapping when estimates are on the parameter space boundary. If convenience is paramount, then quasi‐likelihood estimation can be a good alternative, although parameter constraints may be violated. Sensitivity to model misspecification and outliers is also discussed along with recommendations and priorities for future research.