Split-plot designs with mirror image pairs as sub-plots

In this article we investigate two-level split-plot designs where the sub-plots consist of only two mirror image trials. Assuming third and higher order interactions negligible, we show that these designs divide the estimated effects into two orthogonal sub-spaces, separating sub-plot main effects and sub-plot by whole-plot interactions from the rest. Further we show how to construct split-plot designs of projectivity P≥3. We also introduce a new class of split-plot designs with mirror image pairs constructed from non-geometric Plackett-Burman designs. The design properties of such designs are very appealing with effects of major interest free from full aliasing assuming that 3rd and higher order interactions are negligible.     

Model Discrimination Criteria on Model-Robust Designs

Recently, interest about model discrimination has been focused on methods based on model estimation. Due to the problem of model aliasing, several criteria have been proposed aimed at assessing the capacity of a design for model discrimination. Three of these measures, along with a new criterion that combines them and assesses the overall discrimination capacity of a design, are implemented to evaluate a class of 27-run orthogonal arrays in three levels.     

Comparisons of search designs using search probabilities

Search designs are considered for searching and estimating one nonzero interaction from the two and three factor interactions under the search linear model. We compare three 12-run search designs D1, D2, and D3, and three 11-run search designs D4, D5, and D6, for a 2⁴ factorial experiment. Designs D2 and D3 are orthogonal arrays of strength 2, D1 and D4 are balanced arrays of full strength, D5 is a balanced array of strength 2, and D6 is obtained from D3 by deleting the duplicate run. Designs D4 and D5 are also obtained by deleting a run from D1 and D2, respectively. Balanced arrays and orthogonal arrays are commonly used factorial designs in scientific experiments. “Search probabilities” are calculated for the comparison of search designs. Three criteria based on search probabilities are presented to determine the design which is most likely to identify the nonzero interaction. The calculation of these search probabilities depends on an unknown parameter ρ which has a signal-to-noise ratio form. For a given value of ρ, Criteria I and II are newly proposed in this paper and Criteria III is given in Shirakura et al. (Ann. Statist. 24 (6) (1996) 2560). We generalize Criteria I–III for all values of ρ so that the comparison of search designs can be made without requiring a specific value of ρ. We have developed simplified methods for comparing designs under these three criteria for all values of ρ. We demonstrate, under all three criteria, that the balanced array D1 is more likely to identify the nonzero interaction than the orthogonal arrays D2 and D3, and the design D4 is more likely to identify the nonzero interaction than the designs D5 and D6.The methods of comparing designs developed in this paper are applicable to other factorial experiments for searching one nonzero interaction of any order.     

Three-level main-effects designs exploiting prior information about model uncertainty

To explore the projection efficiency of a design, Tsai, et al [2000. Projective three-level main effects designs robust to model uncertainty. Biometrika 87, 467–475] introduced the Q criterion to compare three-level main-effects designs for quantitative factors that allow the consideration of interactions in addition to main effects. In this paper, we extend their method and focus on the case in which experimenters have some prior knowledge, in advance of running the experiment, about the probabilities of effects being non-negligible. A criterion which incorporates experimenters’ prior beliefs about the importance of each effect is introduced to compare orthogonal, or nearly orthogonal, main effects designs with robustness to interactions as a secondary consideration. We show that this criterion, exploiting prior information about model uncertainty, can lead to more appropriate designs reflecting experimenters’ prior beliefs.     

Incomplete block designs for symmetrical parallel line assays

New series of incomplete block designs for symmetrical parallel lines are proposed. From these designs important contrasts like L_p, L₁ and L′₁ are estimated free from block effects. In addition to these, other odd order contrasts are also estimated orthogonal to block effects. The designs are shown to have simple analysis.     

On the optimality of a class of minimal covering designs

It is shown that the minimal covering designs for v=6t+5 treatments in blocks of size 3 are optimal w.r.t. a large class of optimality criteria. This class of optimality criteria includes the well-known criteria of A-, D- and E-optimality. It is conjectured that these designs are also optimal w.r.t. other criteria suggested by Takeuchi (1961).     

On the equivalence of definitions for regular fractions of mixed-level factorial designs

The notion of regularity for fractional factorial designs was originally defined only for two-level factorial designs. Recently, rather different definitions for regular fractions of mixed-level factorial designs have been proposed by Collombier [1996. Plans d’Expérience Factoriels. Springer, Berlin], Wu and Hamada [2000. Experiments. Wiley, New York] and Pistone and Rogantin [2008. Indicator function and complex coding for mixed fractional factorial designs. J. Statist. Plann. Inference 138, 787–802]. In this paper we prove that, surprisingly, these definitions are equivalent. The proof of equivalence relies heavily on the character theory of finite Abelian groups. The group-theoretic framework provides a unified approach to deal with mixed-level factorial designs and treat symmetric factorial designs as a special case. We show how within this framework each regular fraction is uniquely characterized by a defining relation as for two-level factorial designs. The framework also allows us to extend the result that every regular fraction is an orthogonal array of a strength that is related to its resolution, as stated in Dey and Mukerjee [1999. Fractional Factorial Plans. Wiley, New York] to mixed-level factorial designs.     

Comparison of design for quadratic regression on cubes

Designs for quadratic regression are considered when the possible choices of the controllable variable are points x=(x₁,x₂,…,x_q) in the q-dimensional cube of side 2. The designs that are optimum with respect to such criteria as those of D-, A-, and E-optimality are compared in their performance relative to these and other criteria. Some of the results are developed algebraically; others, numerically. The possible supports of E-optimum designs are much more numerous than the D-optimum supports characterized earlier. The A-optimum design appears to be fairly robust in its efficiency, under variation of criterion.     

Efficient crossover designs in the presence of interactions between direct and carry-over treatment effects

Crossover designs, or repeated measurements designs, are used for experiments in which t treatments are applied to each of n experimental units successively over p time periods. Such experiments are widely used in areas such as clinical trials, experimental psychology and agricultural field trials. In addition to the direct effect on the response of the treatment in the period of application, there is also the possible presence of a residual, or carry-over, effect of a treatment from one or more previous periods. We use a model in which the residual effect from a treatment depends upon the treatment applied in the succeeding period; that is, a model which includes interactions between the treatment direct and residual effects. We assume that residual effects do not persist further than one succeeding period.A particular class of strongly balanced repeated measurements designs with n=t² units and which are uniform on the periods is examined. A lower bound for the A-efficiency of the designs for estimating the direct effects is derived and it is shown that such designs are highly efficient for any number of periods p=2,…,2t.     

Balanced and partially balanced incomplete block designs with autocorrelation errors

The paper aims to find variance balanced and variance partially balanced incomplete block designs when observations within blocks are autocorrelated and we call them BIBAC and PBIBAC designs. Orthogonal arrays of type I and type II when used as BIBAC designs have smaller average variance of elementary contrasts of treatment effects compared to the corresponding Balanced Incomplete Block (BIB) designs with homoscedastic, uncorrelated errors. The relative efficiency of BIB designs compared to BIBAC designs depends on the block size k and the autocorrelation ρ and is independent of the number of treatments. Further this relative efficiency increases with increasing k. Partially balanced incomplete block designs with autocorrelated errors are introduced using partially balanced incomplete block designs and orthogonal arrays of type I and type II.     

PARAMETER ESTIMATION FOR THE FIXED BLOCK EFFECTS MODEL USING A USUAL DESIGN

ABSTRACT

This paper is devoted to the fixed block effects model analysed with most of the classical designs. First, we find regularities conditions for such designs. Then, we obtain explicitly all the least squares estimators of the model. A particular attention is given to orthogonal blocked designs and their optimal properties.     

Orthogonal three-level parallel flats designs for user-specified resolution

Orthogonal factorial and fractional factorial designs are very popular in many experimental studies, particularly the two-level and three-level designs used in screening experiments. When an experimenter is able to specify the set of possibly nonnegligible factorial effects, it is sometimes possible to obtain an orthogonal design belonging to the class of parallel flats designs, that has a smaller run-size than a suitable design from the class of classical fractional factorial designs belonging to the class of single flat designs. Sri-vastava and Li (1996) proved a fundamental theorem of orthogonal s-level, s being a prime, designs of parallel flats type for the user-specified resolution. They also tabulated a series of orthogonal designs for the two-level case. No orthogonal designs for three-level case are available in their paper. In this paper, we present a simple proof for the theorem given in Srivastava and Li (1996) for the three-level case. We also give a dual form of the theorem, which is more useful for developing an algorithm for construction of orthogonal designs. Some classes of three-level orthogonal designs with practical run-size are given in the paper.     

Comparison of rotatable designs for regression on balls,I (quadratic)

Designs for quadratic and cubic regression are considered when the possible choices of the controlable variable are points x=( x₁,x₂,…,x_q) in the q-dimensional. Full of radius R, B_q(R) ={x:Σ⁴_ix²_i?R²}. The designs that are optimum among rotatable designs with respect to the D-, A-, and E-optimality criteria are compared in their performance relative to these and other criteria, including extrapolation. Additionally, the performance of a design optimum for one value of R, when it is implemented for a different value of R, is investigated. Some of the results are developed algebraically; others, numerically. For example, in quadratic regression the A-optimum design appears to be fairly robust in its efficiency, under variation of criterion.     

On d- and e- minimax optimal designs for estimating the axial slopes of a second-order response surface over hypercubic regions

Design of experiments for estimating the slopes of a response surface is considered. Design criteria analogous to the traditional ones but based upon the variance-covariance matrix of the estimated slopes along factor axes are proposed. Optimal designs under the proposed criteria are derived for second-order polynomial regression over hypercubic regions. Best de¬signs within some commonly used classes of designs are also obtained and their efficiencies are investigated.     

Projection designs for mixture experiments in orthogonal blocks

Mixture experiments are often carried out in the presence of process variables, such as days of the week or different machines in a manufacturing process, or different ovens in bread and cake making. In such experiments it is particularly useful to be able to arrange the design in orthogonal blocks, so that the model in tue mixture vanauies may ue iitteu inucpenuentiy or tne UIOCK enects mtrouuceu to take account of the changes in the process variables. It is possible in some situations that some of the ingredients in the mixture, such as additives or flavourings, are present in soian quantities, pernaps as iuw a.s 5% ur even !%, resulting in the design space being restricted to only part of the mixture simplex. Hau and Box (1990) discussed the construction of experimental designs for situations where constraints are placed on the design variables. They considered projecting standard response surface designs, including factorial designs and central composite designs, into the restricted design space, and showed that the desirable property of block orthogonality is preserved by the projections considered. Here we present a number of examples of projection designs and illustrate their use when some of the ingredients are restricted to small values, such that the design space is restricted to a sub-region within the usual simplex in the mixture variables.     

Optimal designs based on exact confidence regions for parameter estimation of a nonlinear regression model

This paper is concerned with the proposal of optimality criteria, referred to as X  - and X^′$X^{\prime }$-optimality criteria, and the construction of X  - and X^′$X^{\prime }$-optimal designs, for nonlinear regression models. These optimal designs aim at improving the estimation of parameters of this class of models. The principle of these criteria is the minimization, with respect to the design, of the expected volume of a particular exact parametric confidence region. In this paper we give detailed definitions, properties, and computation methods of X  - and X^′$X^{\prime }$-optimal designs. We also compare these designs with the classic local D-optimal designs, with regard to robustness and efficiency, for two very well-known academic models (Box–Lucas and Michaelis–Menten models).     

Non-binary neighbor balance circular designs for v=2n and λ=2

Neighbor balance designs were first introduced by Rees (1967) in circular blocks for the use in serological research. Subsequently several researchers have defined the neighbor designs in different ways. In this paper, neighbor balance circular designs for (k≤v) block size are constructed for even number of treatments i.e. v=2n. No such series of designs is known in literature. Two theorems are developed for circular designs. Theorem 1 gives the non-binary circular blocks, whereas Theorem 2 generates binary circular blocks when n≤4 and non-binary blocks for n>4. In suggested designs no treatment is ever a neighbor of itself. Blocks are constructed in such a way that each treatment is a right and left neighbor of every other treatment for a fixed number of times say λ. Sizes of initial circular blocks are not same. One main guiding principle for such designs is to ensure economy in material use.     

Indicator function and complex coding for mixed fractional factorial designs

In a general fractional factorial design, the n levels of a factor are coded by the nth roots of the unity. This device allows a full generalization to mixed-level designs of the theory of the polynomial indicator function which has already been introduced for two-level designs in a joint paper with Fontana. The properties of orthogonal arrays and regular fractions are discussed.     

Optimal designs for the logit and probit models for binary data

We consider optimal designs for a class of symmetric models for binary data which includes the common probit and logit models. We show that for a large group of optimality criteria which includes the main ones in the literature (e.g. A-, D-, E-, F- and G-optimality) the optimal design for our class of models is a two-point design with support points symmetrically placed about the ED50 but with possibly unequal weighting. We demonstrate how one can further reduce the problem to a one-variable optimization by characterizing various of the common criteria. We also use the results to demonstrate major qualitative differences between the F - and c-optimal designs, two design criteria which have similar motivation.     

Taguchi methods: linear graphs of high resolution

An important reason behind the success of the Taguchi methodology in qual- ity assurance has been the use of statistical methods, presented in a way that is accessible to the nonexpert user. Among the tools used to simplify the sta- tistical design of experiments has been the linear graph, apparently introduced by Taguchi. However, he did not consider the resolution of the corresponding designs (the higher the resolution, the more accurate the conclusions). For example, it will be shown that half of the linear graphs given by Taguchi for the L₁₆(2¹⁵) orthogonal array correspond to designs of resolution III, when designs of resolution IV are available (with the same lines in the linear graphs but with different assignments to the columns of the orthogonal array). A nontraditional but very straightforward method is presented for obtaining the alias chains and the linear graphs corresponding to an orthogonal array. The procedure can be easily understood and employed by nonstatisticians to find an experimental design of the highest possible resolution. The design can be used to obtain products or processes that are robust to variation.