Discussion of ‘Modern Statistics for Spatial Point Processes’

Abstract. The paper ‘Modern statistics for spatial point processes’ by Jesper Møller and Rasmus P. Waagepetersen is based on a special invited lecture given by the authors at the 21st Nordic Conference on Mathematical Statistics, held at Rebild, Denmark, in June 2006. At the conference, Antti Penttinen and Eva B. Vedel Jensen were invited to discuss the paper. We here present the comments from the two invited discussants and from a number of other scholars, as well as the authors’ responses to these comments. Below Figure 1, Figure 2, etc., refer to figures in the paper under discussion, while Figure A , Figure B , etc., refer to figures in the current discussion. All numbered sections and formulas refer to the paper.

Figure A Open in figure viewer PowerPoint The estimate of A(k) (solid curve) and pointwise maximum and minimum envelopes (dotted curves) from 99 simulations under independent marking, conditional on the point locations. Zero boundary has been applied.     

Case studies in reliability and maintenance

edited by Wallace R. Blischke and D. N. Prabhakar Murthy, 2003, John Wiley & Sons, Inc., Hoboken, NJ, USA, 661 + xxvii pp., [ISBN: 0-471-41373-9]     

A Class of Multivariate Distributions

In this paper we introduce a class of multivariate distributions, known as the generalized Liouville distribution and defined by the functional form (0 ≤x_i < ∞, αi > 0, β_i > 0, q_i > 0). It is shown that such distributions can be used to derive both the Dirichlet distribution and the beta distribution of the second kind.     

Multivariate Kendall's tau for change‐point detection in copulas

Statistical procedures for the detection of a change in the dependence structure of a series of multivariate observations are studied in this work. The test statistics that are proposed are $L_1$ , $L_2$ , and $L_{\infty }$ distances computed from vectors of differences of Kendall's tau; two multivariate extensions of Kendall's measure of association are used. Since the distributions of these statistics under the null hypothesis of no change depend on the unknown underlying copula of the vectors, a procedure based on the multiplier central limit theorem is used for the computation of p‐values; the method is shown to be valid both asymptotically and for moderate sample sizes. Alternative versions of the tests that take into account possible breakpoints in the marginal distributions are also investigated. Monte Carlo simulations show that the tests are powerful under many scenarios of change‐point. In addition, two estimators of the time of change are proposed and their efficiency is carefully studied. The methodologies are illustrated on simulated series from the Canadian Regional Climate Model. The Canadian Journal of Statistics 41: 65–82; 2013 © 2012 Statistical Society of Canada     

Further Properties of Frequentist Confidence Intervals in Regression that Utilize Uncertain Prior Information

Consider a linear regression model with n‐dimensional response vector, regression parameter and independent and identically distributed errors. Suppose that the parameter of interest is where a is a specified vector. Define the parameter where c and t are specified. Also suppose that we have uncertain prior information that . Part of our evaluation of a frequentist confidence interval for is the ratio (expected length of this confidence interval)/(expected length of standard confidence interval), which we call the scaled expected length of this interval. We say that a confidence interval for utilizes this uncertain prior information if: (i) the scaled expected length of this interval is substantially less than 1 when ; (ii) the maximum value of the scaled expected length is not too much larger than 1; and (iii) this confidence interval reverts to the standard confidence interval when the data happen to strongly contradict the prior information. Kabaila and Giri (2009) present a new method for finding such a confidence interval. Let denote the least squares estimator of . Also let and . Using computations and new theoretical results, we show that the performance of this confidence interval improves as increases and decreases.     

ESTIMATING A PARAMETER WHEN IT IS KNOWN THAT THE PARAMETER EXCEEDS A GIVEN VALUE

In some statistical problems a degree of explicit, prior information is available about the value taken by the parameter of interest, θ say, although the information is much less than would be needed to place a prior density on the parameter's distribution. Often the prior information takes the form of a simple bound, ‘θ > θ₁ ’ or ‘θ < θ₁ ’, where θ₁ is determined by physical considerations or mathematical theory, such as positivity of a variance. A conventional approach to accommodating the requirement that θ > θ₁ is to replace an estimator, , of θ by the maximum of and θ₁. However, this technique is generally inadequate. For one thing, it does not respect the strictness of the inequality θ > θ₁ , which can be critical in interpreting results. For another, it produces an estimator that does not respond in a natural way to perturbations of the data. In this paper we suggest an alternative approach, in which bootstrap aggregation, or bagging, is used to overcome these difficulties. Bagging gives estimators that, when subjected to the constraint θ > θ₁ , strictly exceed θ₁ except in extreme settings in which the empirical evidence strongly contradicts the constraint. Bagging also reduces estimator variability in the important case for which is close to θ₁, and more generally produces estimators that respect the constraint in a smooth, realistic fashion.     

Robust location estimation with missing data

In a missing data setting, we have a sample in which a vector of explanatory variables ${\bf x}_i$ is observed for every subject i, while scalar responses $y_i$ are missing by happenstance on some individuals. In this work we propose robust estimators of the distribution of the responses assuming missing at random (MAR) data, under a semiparametric regression model. Our approach allows the consistent estimation of any weakly continuous functional of the response's distribution. In particular, strongly consistent estimators of any continuous location functional, such as the median, L‐functionals and M‐functionals, are proposed. A robust fit for the regression model combined with the robust properties of the location functional gives rise to a robust recipe for estimating the location parameter. Robustness is quantified through the breakdown point of the proposed procedure. The asymptotic distribution of the location estimators is also derived. The proofs of the theorems are presented in Supplementary Material available online. The Canadian Journal of Statistics 41: 111–132; 2013 © 2012 Statistical Society of Canada     

Some distributions arising from faulty inspection with multitype defectives,and an application to grading

Continuing their investigation of distributions arising from faulty and "incomplete" inspection from a finite popu-lation (Johnson et al. (1980), Comm. Statist.A9 917-922, Kotz and Johnson, ibid, All, 1997-2016) the authors investigate cases when inspection is not restricted to a single type of defect. Applications to grading problems, when grading is based on sets of defects found by sampling inspections, are indicated.     

Bayes sequential estimation in a life test and asymptotic properties

For a life test without replacement on M machines, assuming an exponential distribution for failure times, the Bayes sequential procedure for estimating the failure rate is studied. Estimation error is assumed to be measured by one of a family of loss functions, and the cost of sampling consists of a cost per machine failure c, >, 0 and a cost per unit time c > 0. Assuming a conjugate prior on 9, the Bayes sequential procedure and its asymptotic Bayesian and sampling theory properties are obtained as c1, z9 - 0 and M + jointly.     

RELATIONS BETWEEN ERGODICITY AND MEAN DRIFT FOR MARKOV CHAINS1

If {X_n} is an irreducible aperiodic Markov chain on a state apace denote the mean one step change of position, or “drift”, of {X_n} at j. The main result of this note is to show that, when |µ(j)| is bounded, {X_n} admits a stationary distribution {π_j}if and only if for some N > 0 and some state i, lim inf ∑when this holds, the limit infimum is in fact . Many of the known sufficient or necessary criteria for the existence of a stationary distribution can then be derived easily from this and related results.     

Second‐order bias‐corrected AIC in multivariate normal linear models under non‐normality

This paper deals with a bias correction of Akaike's information criterion (AIC) for selecting variables in multivariate normal linear regression models when the true distribution of observation is an unknown non‐normal distribution. It is well known that the bias of AIC is $O(1)$ , and there are a number of the first‐order bias‐corrected AICs which improve the bias to $O(n^{-1})$ , where $n$ is the sample size. A new information criterion is proposed by slightly adjusting the first‐order bias‐corrected AIC. Although the adjustment is achieved by merely using constant coefficients, the bias of the new criterion is reduced to $O(n^{-2})$ . Then, a variance of the new criterion is also improved. Through numerical experiments, we verify that our criterion is superior to others. The Canadian Journal of Statistics 39: 126–146; 2011 © 2011 Statistical Society of Canada     

Estimating prediction error in microarray classification: Modifications of the 0.632+ bootstrap when ${\bf n} < {\bf p}$

We are interested in estimating prediction error for a classification model built on high dimensional genomic data when the number of genes (p) greatly exceeds the number of subjects (n). We examine a distance argument supporting the conventional 0.632+ bootstrap proposed for the $n > p$ scenario, modify it for the $n < p$ situation and develop learning curves to describe how the true prediction error varies with the number of subjects in the training set. The curves are then applied to define adjusted resampling estimates for the prediction error in order to achieve a balance in terms of bias and variability. The adjusted resampling methods are proposed as counterparts of the 0.632+ bootstrap when $n < p$ , and are found to improve on the 0.632+ bootstrap and other existing methods in the microarray study scenario when the sample size is small and there is some level of differential expression. The Canadian Journal of Statistics 41: 133–150; 2013 © 2012 Statistical Society of Canada     

The World Fertility Survey: an appraisal of methodology

"In the first half of the article, a broad account of content and procedures is given. In conduct of individual surveys, the achievements of the World Fertility Survey were based on thoroughness rather than technical superiority. The later aspects of the program, including analysis, archiving, and data dissemination, were more innovative and represent models of excellence for similar future enquiries. In overall terms, the program is judged to be an expensive success. In the second half of the article, two methodological issues are discussed in more detail: the collection of retrospective birth histories and the translation of survey instruments into local languages." Comments by Anthony G. Turner (pp. 768-9), Kweku T. de Graft-Johnson (pp. 769-70), Burton Singer (pp. 771-2), and Joel E. Cohen (pp. 772-4) are appended.     

The uniform convergence of the nadaraya-watson regression function estimate

If (X₁,Y₁), …, (X_n,Y_n) is a sequence of independent identically distributed R_d × R-valued random vectors then Nadaraya (1964) and Watson (1964) proposed to estimate the regression function m(x) = ? {Y₁|X₁ = x{ by where K is a known density and {h_n} is a sequence of positive numbers satisfying certain properties. In this paper a variety of conditions are given for the strong convergence to 0 of ess_Xsup|m_n (X)-m(X)| (here X is independent of the data and distributed as X₁). The theorems are valid for all distributions of X₁ and for all sequences {h_n} satisfying h_n → 0 and nh/log n→0.     

Contaminated normal modeling with application to microarray data analysis

A contaminated beta model $(1-\gamma) B(1,1) + \gamma B(\alpha,\beta)$ is often used to describe the distribution of $P$ ‐values arising from a microarray experiment. The authors propose and examine a different approach: namely, using a contaminated normal model $(1-\gamma) N(0,\sigma^2) + \gamma N(\mu,\sigma^2)$ to describe the distribution of $Z$ statistics or suitably transformed $T$ statistics. The authors then address whether a researcher who has $Z$ statistics should analyze them using the contaminated normal model or whether the $Z$ statistics should be converted to $P$ ‐values to be analyzed using the contaminated beta model. The authors also provide a decision‐theoretic perspective on the analysis of $Z$ statistics. The Canadian Journal of Statistics 38: 315–332; 2010 © 2010 Statistical Society of Canada     

Estimation of population coverage in the 1990 United States census based on demographic analysis

"This article presents estimates of net coverage of the national population in the 1990 [U.S.] census, based on the method of demographic analysis. The general techniques of demographic analysis as an analytic tool for coverage measurement are discussed, including use of the demographic accounting equation, data components, and strengths and limitations of the method. Patterns of coverage displayed by the 1990 estimates are described, along with similarities or differences from comparable demographic estimates for previous censuses....A final section presents the results of the first statistical assessment of the uncertainty in the demographic coverage estimates for 1990." Comments by Clifford C. Clogg and Christine L. Himes (pp. 1,072-4) and Jeffrey S. Passel (pp. 1,074-7) and a rejoinder by the authors (pp. 1,077-9) are included.     

区域一体化、地区专业化与趋同分析 —基于珠江三角洲地区9城市的实证分析

 《珠江三角洲地区改革发展规划纲要（2008-2020）》提出促进区域经济一体化和加快发展先进制造业。本文以珠江三角洲地区9市的制造业为例,通过衡量行业空间集中度和地区专业化水平指标,发现随着区域一体化进程加快,珠江三角洲地区制造业的发展已进入聚集与扩散并存的新阶段,各城市间制造业结构的差异性增强,地区专业化水平提高,但珠江三角洲地区东岸、西岸内部各城市间仍存在不同程度的产业同构性。同时通过对珠江三角洲地区9城市1993－2007年面板数据的回归分析,珠江三角洲地区确实存在σ-趋同和条件β-趋同。     

An Estimator for the Survival Function on the Basis of Observable Censoring Times

Abstract

Chiu [Chiu, S. N. (1999 Chiu, S. N. 1999. An unbiased estimator for the survival function of censored data. Commun. Statist. - Theory Meth., 28(9): 2249–2260. [Taylor & Francis Online], [Web of Science ®] , [Google Scholar]). An unbiased estimator for the survival function of censored data. Commun. Statist. - Theory Meth. 28(9):2249–2260.] proposed a nonparametric estimator for the survival function which is based on observable censoring times in the general censoring model. His estimator is less efficient than the Product-Limit estimator. Considering an informative censoring model this drawback can partially be overcome. This is shown by a nonparametric, uniformly consistent estimator based on observable censoring times within the simple Koziol–Green model. Some asymptotic properties of the new estimator are investigated and it is compared with the well-known ACL-estimator.     

Wavelet Thresholding Estimation in a Poissonian Interactions Model with Application to Genomic Data

This paper deals with the study of dependencies between two given events modelled by point processes. In particular, we focus on the context of DNA to detect favoured or avoided distances between two given motifs along a genome suggesting possible interactions at a molecular level. For this, we naturally introduce a so‐called reproduction function h that allows to quantify the favoured positions of the motifs and that is considered as the intensity of a Poisson process. Our first interest is the estimation of this function h assumed to be well localized. The estimator based on random thresholds achieves an oracle inequality. Then, minimax properties of on Besov balls are established. Some simulations are provided, proving the good practical behaviour of our procedure. Finally, our method is applied to the analysis of the dependence between promoter sites and genes along the genome of the Escherichia coli bacterium.