Neighbor product distinguishing total colorings

A total-[k]-coloring of a graph G is a mapping \(\phi : V (G) \cup E(G)\rightarrow \{1, 2, \ldots , k\}\) such that any two adjacent elements in \(V (G) \cup E(G)\) receive different colors. Let f(v) denote the product of the color of a vertex v and the colors of all edges incident to v. A total-[k]-neighbor product distinguishing-coloring of G is a total-[k]-coloring of G such that \(f(u)\ne f(v)\), where \(uv\in E(G)\). By \(\chi ^{\prime \prime }_{\prod }(G)\), we denote the smallest value k in such a coloring of G. We conjecture that \(\chi _{\prod }^{\prime \prime }(G)\le \Delta (G)+3\) for any simple graph with maximum degree \(\Delta (G)\). In this paper, we prove that the conjecture holds for complete graphs, cycles, trees, bipartite graphs and subcubic graphs. Furthermore, we show that if G is a \(K_4\)-minor free graph with \(\Delta (G)\ge 4\), then \(\chi _{\prod }^{\prime \prime }(G)\le \Delta (G)+2\).     

An approximation algorithm for maximum weight budgeted connected set cover

This paper studies approximation algorithm for the maximum weight budgeted connected set cover (MWBCSC) problem. Given an element set \(X\), a collection of sets \({\mathcal {S}}\subseteq 2^X\), a weight function \(w\) on \(X\), a cost function \(c\) on \({\mathcal {S}}\), a connected graph \(G_{\mathcal {S}}\) (called communication graph) on vertex set \({\mathcal {S}}\), and a budget \(L\), the MWBCSC problem is to select a subcollection \({\mathcal {S'}}\subseteq {\mathcal {S}}\) such that the cost \(c({\mathcal {S'}})=\sum _{S\in {\mathcal {S'}}}c(S)\le L\), the subgraph of \(G_{\mathcal {S}}\) induced by \({\mathcal {S'}}\) is connected, and the total weight of elements covered by \({\mathcal {S'}}\) (that is \(\sum _{x\in \bigcup _{S\in {\mathcal {S'}}}S}w(x)\)) is maximized. We present a polynomial time algorithm for this problem with a natural communication graph that has performance ratio \(O((\delta +1)\log n)\), where \(\delta \) is the maximum degree of graph \(G_{\mathcal {S}}\) and \(n\) is the number of sets in \({\mathcal {S}}\). In particular, if every set has cost at most \(L/2\), the performance ratio can be improved to \(O(\log n)\).     

The game chromatic index of some trees with maximum degree four and adjacent degree-four vertices

A (proper) total-k-coloring of a graph G is a mapping \(\phi : V (G) \cup E(G)\mapsto \{1, 2, \ldots , k\}\) such that any two adjacent or incident elements in \(V (G) \cup E(G)\) receive different colors. Let C(v) denote the set of the color of a vertex v and the colors of all incident edges of v. An adjacent vertex distinguishing total-k-coloring of G is a total-k-coloring of G such that for each edge \(uv\in E(G)\), \(C(u)\ne C(v)\). We denote the smallest value k in such a coloring of G by \(\chi ^{\prime \prime }_{a}(G)\). It is known that \(\chi _{a}^{\prime \prime }(G)\le \Delta (G)+3\) for any planar graph with \(\Delta (G)\ge 10\). In this paper, we consider the list version of this coloring and show that if G is a planar graph with \(\Delta (G)\ge 11\), then \({ ch}_{a}^{\prime \prime }(G)\le \Delta (G)+3\), where \({ ch}^{\prime \prime }_a(G)\) is the adjacent vertex distinguishing total choosability.     

Relation between the skew-rank of an oriented graph and the independence number of its underlying graph

An oriented graph \(G^\sigma \) is a digraph without loops or multiple arcs whose underlying graph is G. Let \(S\left( G^\sigma \right) \) be the skew-adjacency matrix of \(G^\sigma \) and \(\alpha (G)\) be the independence number of G. The rank of \(S(G^\sigma )\) is called the skew-rank of \(G^\sigma \), denoted by \(sr(G^\sigma )\). Wong et al. (Eur J Comb 54:76–86, 2016) studied the relationship between the skew-rank of an oriented graph and the rank of its underlying graph. In this paper, the correlation involving the skew-rank, the independence number, and some other parameters are considered. First we show that \(sr(G^\sigma )+2\alpha (G)\geqslant 2|V_G|-2d(G)\), where \(|V_G|\) is the order of G and d(G) is the dimension of cycle space of G. We also obtain sharp lower bounds for \(sr(G^\sigma )+\alpha (G),\, sr(G^\sigma )-\alpha (G)\), \(sr(G^\sigma )/\alpha (G)\) and characterize all corresponding extremal graphs.     

On (s,t)-relaxed L(2,1)-labeling of graphs

We initiate the study of relaxed \(L(2,1)\)-labelings of graphs. Suppose \(G\) is a graph. Let \(u\) be a vertex of \(G\). A vertex \(v\) is called an \(i\)-neighbor of \(u\) if \(d_G(u,v)=i\). A \(1\)-neighbor of \(u\) is simply called a neighbor of \(u\). Let \(s\) and \(t\) be two nonnegative integers. Suppose \(f\) is an assignment of nonnegative integers to the vertices of \(G\). If the following three conditions are satisfied, then \(f\) is called an \((s,t)\)-relaxed \(L(2,1)\)-labeling of \(G\): (1) for any two adjacent vertices \(u\) and \(v\) of \(G, f(u)\not =f(v)\); (2) for any vertex \(u\) of \(G\), there are at most \(s\) neighbors of \(u\) receiving labels from \(\{f(u)-1,f(u)+1\}\); (3) for any vertex \(u\) of \(G\), the number of \(2\)-neighbors of \(u\) assigned the label \(f(u)\) is at most \(t\). The minimum span of \((s,t)\)-relaxed \(L(2,1)\)-labelings of \(G\) is called the \((s,t)\)-relaxed \(L(2,1)\)-labeling number of \(G\), denoted by \(\lambda ^{s,t}_{2,1}(G)\). It is clear that \(\lambda ^{0,0}_{2,1}(G)\) is the so called \(L(2,1)\)-labeling number of \(G\). \(\lambda ^{1,0}_{2,1}(G)\) is simply written as \(\widetilde{\lambda }(G)\). This paper discusses basic properties of \((s,t)\)-relaxed \(L(2,1)\)-labeling numbers of graphs. For any two nonnegative integers \(s\) and \(t\), the exact values of \((s,t)\)-relaxed \(L(2,1)\)-labeling numbers of paths, cycles and complete graphs are determined. Tight upper and lower bounds for \((s,t)\)-relaxed \(L(2,1)\)-labeling numbers of complete multipartite graphs and trees are given. The upper bounds for \((s,1)\)-relaxed \(L(2,1)\)-labeling number of general graphs are also investigated. We introduce a new graph parameter called the breaking path covering number of a graph. A breaking path \(P\) is a vertex sequence \(v_1,v_2,\ldots ,v_k\) in which each \(v_i\) is adjacent to at least one vertex of \(v_{i-1}\) and \(v_{i+1}\) for \(i=2,3,\ldots ,k-1\). A breaking path covering of \(G\) is a set of disjoint such vertex sequences that cover all vertices of \(G\). The breaking path covering number of \(G\), denoted by \(bpc(G)\), is the minimum number of breaking paths in a breaking path covering of \(G\). In this paper, it is proved that \(\widetilde{\lambda }(G)= n+bpc(G^{c})-2\) if \(bpc(G^{c})\ge 2\) and \(\widetilde{\lambda }(G)\le n-1\) if and only if \(bpc(G^{c})=1\). The breaking path covering number of a graph is proved to be computable in polynomial time. Thus, if a graph \(G\) is of diameter two, then \(\widetilde{\lambda }(G)\) can be determined in polynomial time. Several conjectures and problems on relaxed \(L(2,1)\)-labelings are also proposed.     

Neighbor sum distinguishing total coloring of graphs with bounded treewidth

A proper total k-coloring \(\phi \) of a graph G is a mapping from \(V(G)\cup E(G)\) to \(\{1,2,\dots , k\}\) such that no adjacent or incident elements in \(V(G)\cup E(G)\) receive the same color. Let \(m_{\phi }(v)\) denote the sum of the colors on the edges incident with the vertex v and the color on v. A proper total k-coloring of G is called neighbor sum distinguishing if \(m_{\phi }(u)\not =m_{\phi }(v)\) for each edge \(uv\in E(G).\) Let \(\chi _{\Sigma }^t(G)\) be the neighbor sum distinguishing total chromatic number of a graph G. Pil?niak and Wo?niak conjectured that for any graph G, \(\chi _{\Sigma }^t(G)\le \Delta (G)+3\). In this paper, we show that if G is a graph with treewidth \(\ell \ge 3\) and \(\Delta (G)\ge 2\ell +3\), then \(\chi _{\Sigma }^t(G)\le \Delta (G)+\ell -1\). This upper bound confirms the conjecture for graphs with treewidth 3 and 4. Furthermore, when \(\ell =3\) and \(\Delta \ge 9\), we show that \(\Delta (G) + 1\le \chi _{\Sigma }^t(G)\le \Delta (G)+2\) and characterize graphs with equalities.     

Constant factor approximation for the weighted partial degree bounded edge packing problem

In the partial degree bounded edge packing problem (PDBEP), the input is an undirected graph \(G=(V,E)\) with capacity \(c_v\in {\mathbb {N}}\) on each vertex v. The objective is to find a feasible subgraph \(G'=(V,E')\) maximizing \(|E'|\), where \(G'\) is said to be feasible if for each \(e=\{u,v\}\in E'\), \(\deg _{G'}(u)\le c_u\) or \(\deg _{G'}(v)\le c_v\). In the weighted version of the problem, additionally each edge \(e\in E\) has a weight w(e) and we want to find a feasible subgraph \(G'=(V,E')\) maximizing \(\sum _{e\in E'} w(e)\). The problem is already NP-hard if \(c_v = 1\) for all \(v\in V\) (Zhang in: Proceedings of the joint international conference on frontiers in algorithmics and algorithmic aspects in information and management, FAW-AAIM 2012, Beijing, China, May 14–16, pp 359–367, 2012). In this paper, we introduce a generalization of the PDBEP problem. We let the edges have weights as well as demands, and we present the first constant-factor approximation algorithms for this problem. Our results imply the first constant-factor approximation algorithm for the weighted PDBEP problem, improving the result of Aurora et al. (FAW-AAIM 2013) who presented an \(O(\log n)\)-approximation for the weighted case. We also study the weighted PDBEP problem on hypergraphs and present a constant factor approximation if the maximum degree of the hypergraph is bounded above by a constant. We study a generalization of the weighted PDBEP problem with demands where each edge additionally specifies whether it requires at least one, or both its end-points to not exceed the capacity. The objective is to pick a maximum weight subset of edges. We give a constant factor approximation for this problem. We also present a PTAS for the weighted PDBEP problem with demands on H-minor free graphs, if the demands on the edges are bounded by polynomial. We show that the PDBEP problem is APX-hard even for bipartite graphs with \(c_v = 1, \; \forall v\in V\) and having degree at most 3.     

The 3-rainbow index and connected dominating sets

A tree in an edge-colored graph is said to be rainbow if no two edges on the tree share the same color. An edge-coloring of \(G\) is called a 3-rainbow coloring if for any three vertices in \(G\), there exists a rainbow tree connecting them. The 3-rainbow index \(rx_3(G)\) of \(G\) is defined as the minimum number of colors that are needed in a 3-rainbow coloring of \(G\). This concept, introduced by Chartrand et al., can be viewed as a generalization of the rainbow connection. In this paper, we study the 3-rainbow index by using connected 3-way dominating sets and 3-dominating sets. We show that for every connected graph \(G\) on \(n\) vertices with minimum degree at least \(\delta \, (3\le \delta \le 5)\), \(rx_{3}(G)\le \frac{3n}{\delta +1}+4\), and the bound is tight up to an additive constant; whereas for every connected graph \(G\) on \(n\) vertices with minimum degree at least \(\delta \, (\delta \ge 3)\), we get that \(rx_{3}(G)\le \frac{\ln (\delta +1)}{\delta +1}(1+o_{\delta }(1))n+5\). In addition, we obtain some tight upper bounds of the 3-rainbow index for some special graph classes, including threshold graphs, chain graphs and interval graphs.     

On Barnette’s conjecture and the $$H^{+-}$$ property

Let \(\mathcal{B}\) denote the class of all 3-connected cubic bipartite plane graphs. A conjecture of Barnette states that every graph in \(\mathcal{B}\) has a Hamilton cycle. A cyclic sequence of big faces is a cyclic sequence of different faces, each bounded by at least six edges, such that two faces from the sequence are adjacent if and only if they are consecutive in the sequence. Suppose that \({F_1, F_2, F_3}\) is a proper 3-coloring of the faces of \(G^*\in \mathcal{B}\). We prove that if every cyclic sequence of big faces of \(G^*\) has a face belonging to \(F_1\) and a face belonging to \(F_2\), then \(G^*\) has the following properties: \(H^{+-}\): If any two edges are chosen on the same face, then there is a Hamilton cycle through one and avoiding the other, \(H^{--}\): If any two edges are chosen which are an even distance apart on the same face, then there is a Hamilton cycle that avoids both. Moreover, let \(X\) and \(Y\) partition the set of big faces of \(G^*\) such that all such faces of \(F_1\) are in \(X\) and all such faces of \(F_2\) are in \(Y\). We prove that if every cyclic sequence of big faces has a face belonging to \(X\) and a face belonging to \(Y\), then \(G^*\) has a Hamilton cycle.     

2-Edge connected dominating sets and 2-Connected dominating sets of a graph

A \(k\)-connected (resp. \(k\)-edge connected) dominating set \(D\) of a connected graph \(G\) is a subset of \(V(G)\) such that \(G[D]\) is \(k\)-connected (resp. \(k\)-edge connected) and each \(v\in V(G)\backslash D\) has at least one neighbor in \(D\). The \(k\) -connected domination number (resp. \(k\) -edge connected domination number) of a graph \(G\) is the minimum size of a \(k\)-connected (resp. \(k\)-edge connected) dominating set of \(G\), and denoted by \(\gamma _k(G)\) (resp. \(\gamma '_k(G)\)). In this paper, we investigate the relation of independence number and 2-connected (resp. 2-edge-connected) domination number, and prove that for a graph \(G\), if it is \(2\)-edge connected, then \(\gamma '_2(G)\le 4\alpha (G)-1\), and it is \(2\)-connected, then \(\gamma _2(G)\le 6\alpha (G)-3\), where \(\alpha (G)\) is the independent number of \(G\).     

Approximation for maximizing monotone non-decreasing set functions with a greedy method

We study the problem of maximizing a monotone non-decreasing function \(f\) subject to a matroid constraint. Fisher, Nemhauser and Wolsey have shown that, if \(f\) is submodular, the greedy algorithm will find a solution with value at least \(\frac{1}{2}\) of the optimal value under a general matroid constraint and at least \(1-\frac{1}{e}\) of the optimal value under a uniform matroid \((\mathcal {M} = (X,\mathcal {I})\), \(\mathcal {I} = \{ S \subseteq X: |S| \le k\}\)) constraint. In this paper, we show that the greedy algorithm can find a solution with value at least \(\frac{1}{1+\mu }\) of the optimum value for a general monotone non-decreasing function with a general matroid constraint, where \(\mu = \alpha \), if \(0 \le \alpha \le 1\); \(\mu = \frac{\alpha ^K(1-\alpha ^K)}{K(1-\alpha )}\) if \(\alpha > 1\); here \(\alpha \) is a constant representing the “elemental curvature” of \(f\), and \(K\) is the cardinality of the largest maximal independent sets. We also show that the greedy algorithm can achieve a \(1 - (\frac{\alpha + \cdots + \alpha ^{k-1}}{1+\alpha + \cdots + \alpha ^{k-1}})^k\) approximation under a uniform matroid constraint. Under this unified \(\alpha \)-classification, submodular functions arise as the special case \(0 \le \alpha \le 1\).     

Neighbor sum distinguishing total coloring of 2-degenerate graphs

A proper k-total coloring of a graph G is a mapping from \(V(G)\cup E(G)\) to \(\{1,2,\ldots ,k\}\) such that no two adjacent or incident elements in \(V(G)\cup E(G)\) receive the same color. Let f(v) denote the sum of the colors on the edges incident with v and the color on vertex v. A proper k-total coloring of G is called neighbor sum distinguishing if \(f(u)\ne f(v)\) for each edge \(uv\in E(G)\). Let \(\chi ''_{\Sigma }(G)\) denote the smallest integer k in such a coloring of G. Pil?niak and Wo?niak conjectured that for any graph G, \(\chi ''_{\Sigma }(G)\le \Delta (G)+3\). In this paper, we show that if G is a 2-degenerate graph, then \(\chi ''_{\Sigma }(G)\le \Delta (G)+3\); Moreover, if \(\Delta (G)\ge 5\) then \(\chi ''_{\Sigma }(G)\le \Delta (G)+2\).     

A proper total coloring distinguishing adjacent vertices by sums of planar graphs without intersecting triangles

Let \(G=(V,E)\) be a graph and \(\phi \) be a total \(k\)-coloring of \(G\) using the color set \(\{1,\ldots , k\}\). Let \(\sum _\phi (u)\) denote the sum of the color of the vertex \(u\) and the colors of all incident edges of \(u\). A \(k\)-neighbor sum distinguishing total coloring of \(G\) is a total \(k\)-coloring of \(G\) such that for each edge \(uv\in E(G)\), \(\sum _\phi (u)\ne \sum _\phi (v)\). By \(\chi ^{''}_{nsd}(G)\), we denote the smallest value \(k\) in such a coloring of \(G\). Pil?niak and Wo?niak first introduced this coloring and conjectured that \(\chi _{nsd}^{''}(G)\le \Delta (G)+3\) for any simple graph \(G\). In this paper, we prove that the conjecture holds for planar graphs without intersecting triangles with \(\Delta (G)\ge 7\). Moreover, we also show that \(\chi _{nsd}^{''}(G)\le \Delta (G)+2\) for planar graphs without intersecting triangles with \(\Delta (G) \ge 9\). Our approach is based on the Combinatorial Nullstellensatz and the discharging method.     

Neighbor sum distinguishing total coloring of graphs embedded in surfaces of nonnegative Euler characteristic

A total coloring of a graph \(G\) is a coloring of its vertices and edges such that adjacent or incident vertices and edges are not colored with the same color. A total \([k]\)-coloring of a graph \(G\) is a total coloring of \(G\) by using the color set \([k]=\{1,2,\ldots ,k\}\). Let \(f(v)\) denote the sum of the colors of a vertex \(v\) and the colors of all incident edges of \(v\). A total \([k]\)-neighbor sum distinguishing-coloring of \(G\) is a total \([k]\)-coloring of \(G\) such that for each edge \(uv\in E(G)\), \(f(u)\ne f(v)\). Let \(G\) be a graph which can be embedded in a surface of nonnegative Euler characteristic. In this paper, it is proved that the total neighbor sum distinguishing chromatic number of \(G\) is \(\Delta (G)+2\) if \(\Delta (G)\ge 14\), where \(\Delta (G)\) is the maximum degree of \(G\).     

Approximation algorithms for minimum weight partial connected set cover problem

In the Minimum Weight Partial Connected Set Cover problem, we are given a finite ground set \(U\), an integer \(q\le |U|\), a collection \(\mathcal {E}\) of subsets of \(U\), and a connected graph \(G_{\mathcal {E}}\) on vertex set \(\mathcal {E}\), the goal is to find a minimum weight subcollection of \(\mathcal {E}\) which covers at least \(q\) elements of \(U\) and induces a connected subgraph in \(G_{\mathcal {E}}\). In this paper, we derive a “partial cover property” for the greedy solution of the Minimum Weight Set Cover problem, based on which we present (a) for the weighted version under the assumption that any pair of sets in \(\mathcal {E}\) with nonempty intersection are adjacent in \(G_{\mathcal {E}}\) (the Minimum Weight Partial Connected Vertex Cover problem falls into this range), an approximation algorithm with performance ratio \(\rho (1+H(\gamma ))+o(1)\), and (b) for the cardinality version under the assumption that any pair of sets in \(\mathcal {E}\) with nonempty intersection are at most \(d\)-hops away from each other (the Minimum Partial Connected \(k\)-Hop Dominating Set problem falls into this range), an approximation algorithm with performance ratio \(2(1+dH(\gamma ))+o(1)\), where \(\gamma =\max \{|X|:X\in \mathcal {E}\}\), \(H(\cdot )\) is the Harmonic number, and \(\rho \) is the performance ratio for the Minimum Quota Node-Weighted Steiner Tree problem.     

A greedy algorithm for the minimum 2-connected m-fold dominating set problem

To save energy and alleviate interference in a wireless sensor network, connected dominating set (CDS) has been proposed as the virtual backbone. Since nodes may fail due to accidental damage or energy depletion, it is desirable to construct a fault tolerant CDS, which can be modeled as a \(k\)-connected \(m\)-fold dominating set \(((k,m)\)-CDS for short): a subset of nodes \(C\subseteq V(G)\) is a \((k,m)\)-CDS of \(G\) if every node in \(V(G)\setminus C\) is adjacent with at least \(m\) nodes in \(C\) and the subgraph of \(G\) induced by \(C\) is \(k\)-connected.In this paper, we present an approximation algorithm for the minimum \((2,m)\)-CDS problem with \(m\ge 2\). Based on a \((1,m)\)-CDS, the algorithm greedily merges blocks until the connectivity is raised to two. The most difficult problem in the analysis is that the potential function used in the greedy algorithm is not submodular. By proving that an optimal solution has a specific decomposition, we managed to prove that the approximation ratio is \(\alpha +2(1+\ln \alpha )\), where \(\alpha \) is the approximation ratio for the minimum \((1,m)\)-CDS problem. This improves on previous approximation ratios for the minimum \((2,m)\)-CDS problem, both in general graphs and in unit disk graphs.     

Total coloring of planar graphs without short cycles

The total chromatic number of a graph \(G\), denoted by \(\chi ''(G)\), is the minimum number of colors needed to color the vertices and edges of \(G\) such that no two adjacent or incident elements get the same color. It is known that if a planar graph \(G\) has maximum degree \(\Delta (G)\ge 9\), then \(\chi ''(G)=\Delta (G)+1\). In this paper, it is proved that if \(G\) is a planar graph with \(\Delta (G)\ge 7\), and for each vertex \(v\), there is an integer \(k_v\in \{3,4,5,6,7,8\}\) such that there is no \(k_v\)-cycle which contains \(v\), then \(\chi ''(G)=\Delta (G)+1\).     

Neighbor sum distinguishing list total coloring of subcubic graphs

Let \(G=(V, E)\) be a simple graph and denote the set of edges incident to a vertex v by E(v). The neighbor sum distinguishing (NSD) total choice number of G, denoted by \(\mathrm{ch}_{\Sigma }^{t}(G)\), is the smallest integer k such that, after assigning each \(z\in V\cup E\) a set L(z) of k real numbers, G has a total coloring \(\phi \) satisfying \(\phi (z)\in L(z)\) for each \(z\in V\cup E\) and \(\sum _{z\in E(u)\cup \{u\}}\phi (z)\ne \sum _{z\in E(v)\cup \{v\}}\phi (z)\) for each \(uv\in E\). In this paper, we propose some reducible configurations of NSD list total coloring for general graphs by applying the Combinatorial Nullstellensatz. As an application, we present that \(\mathrm{ch}^{t}_{\Sigma }(G)\le \Delta (G)+3\) for every subcubic graph G.     

Maximum coverage problem with group budget constraints

We study the maximum coverage problem with group budget constraints (MCG). The input consists of a ground set X, a collection \(\psi \) of subsets of X each of which is associated with a combinatorial structure such that for every set \(S_j\in \psi \), a cost \(c(S_j)\) can be calculated based on the combinatorial structure associated with \(S_j\), a partition \(G_1,G_2,\ldots ,G_l\) of \(\psi \), and budgets \(B_1,B_2,\ldots ,B_l\), and B. A solution to the problem consists of a subset H of \(\psi \) such that \(\sum _{S_j\in H} c(S_j) \le B\) and for each \(i \in {1,2,\ldots ,l}\), \(\sum _{S_j \in H\cap G_i}c(S_j)\le B_i\). The objective is to maximize \(|\bigcup _{S_j\in H}S_j|\). In our work we use a new and improved analysis of the greedy algorithm to prove that it is a \((\frac{\alpha }{3+2\alpha })\)-approximation algorithm, where \(\alpha \) is the approximation ratio of a given oracle which takes as an input a subset \(X^{new}\subseteq X\) and a group \(G_i\) and returns a set \(S_j\in G_i\) which approximates the optimal solution for \(\max _{D\in G_i}\frac{|D\cap X^{new}|}{c(D)}\). This analysis that is shown here to be tight for the greedy algorithm, improves by a factor larger than 2 the analysis of the best known approximation algorithm for MCG.