The Loss Rank Criterion for Variable Selection in Linear Regression Analysis

Abstract. Lasso and other regularization procedures are attractive methods for variable selection, subject to a proper choice of shrinkage parameter. Given a set of potential subsets produced by a regularization algorithm, a consistent model selection criterion is proposed to select the best one among this preselected set. The approach leads to a fast and efficient procedure for variable selection, especially in high‐dimensional settings. Model selection consistency of the suggested criterion is proven when the number of covariates d is fixed. Simulation studies suggest that the criterion still enjoys model selection consistency when d is much larger than the sample size. The simulations also show that our approach for variable selection works surprisingly well in comparison with existing competitors. The method is also applied to a real data set.     

Rank-based multiple change-point detection

Abstract

A nonparametric procedure is proposed to estimate multiple change-points of location changes in a univariate data sequence by using ranks instead of the raw data. While existing rank-based multiple change-point detection methods are mostly based on sequential tests, we treat it as a model selection problem. We derive the corresponding Schwarz’s information criterion for rank-statistics, theoretically prove the consistency of the change-point estimator and use a pruned dynamic programing algorithm to achieve the change-point estimator. Simulation studies show our method’s robustness, effectiveness and efficiency in detecting mean-changes. We also apply the method to a gene dataset as an illustration.     

A new model selection procedure for finite mixture regression models

Abstract

In this article, we propose a new penalized-likelihood method to conduct model selection for finite mixture of regression models. The penalties are imposed on mixing proportions and regression coefficients, and hence order selection of the mixture and the variable selection in each component can be simultaneously conducted. The consistency of order selection and the consistency of variable selection are investigated. A modified EM algorithm is proposed to maximize the penalized log-likelihood function. Numerical simulations are conducted to demonstrate the finite sample performance of the estimation procedure. The proposed methodology is further illustrated via real data analysis.     

Variable selection for semiparametric varying coefficient partially linear model based on modal regression with missing data

Abstract

In this article, we focus on the variable selection for semiparametric varying coefficient partially linear model with response missing at random. Variable selection is proposed based on modal regression, where the non parametric functions are approximated by B-spline basis. The proposed procedure uses SCAD penalty to realize variable selection of parametric and nonparametric components simultaneously. Furthermore, we establish the consistency, the sparse property and asymptotic normality of the resulting estimators. The penalty estimation parameters value of the proposed method is calculated by EM algorithm. Simulation studies are carried out to assess the finite sample performance of the proposed variable selection procedure.     

High-dimensional posterior consistency of the Bayesian lasso

ABSTRACT

This paper considers posterior consistency in the context of high-dimensional variable selection using the Bayesian lasso algorithm. In a frequentist setting, consistency is perhaps the most basic property that we expect any reasonable estimator to achieve. However, in a Bayesian setting, consistency is often ignored or taken for granted, especially in more complex hierarchical Bayesian models. In this paper, we have derived sufficient conditions for posterior consistency in the Bayesian lasso model with the orthogonal design, where the number of parameters grows with the sample size.     

Robust variable selection and parametric component identification in varying coefficient models

ABSTRACT

In this paper, we study a novelly robust variable selection and parametric component identification simultaneously in varying coefficient models. The proposed estimator is based on spline approximation and two smoothly clipped absolute deviation (SCAD) penalties through rank regression, which is robust with respect to heavy-tailed errors or outliers in the response. Furthermore, when the tuning parameter is chosen by modified BIC criterion, we show that the proposed procedure is consistent both in variable selection and the separation of varying and constant coefficients. In addition, the estimators of varying coefficients possess the optimal convergence rate under some assumptions, and the estimators of constant coefficients have the same asymptotic distribution as their counterparts obtained when the true model is known. Simulation studies and a real data example are undertaken to assess the finite sample performance of the proposed variable selection procedure.     

The consistency of model selection for dynamic Semi-varying coefficient models with autocorrelated errors

The consistency of model selection criterion BIC has been well and widely studied for many nonlinear regression models. However, few of them had considered models with lag variables as regressors and auto-correlated errors in time series settings, which is common in both linear and nonlinear time series modeling. This paper studies a dynamic semi-varying coefficient model with ARMA errors, using an approach based on spectrum analysis of time series. The consistency property of the proposed model selection criteria is established and an implementation procedure of model selection is proposed for practitioners. Simulation studies have also been conducted to numerically show the consistency property.     

A diagnostic of influential cases based on the information complexity criteria in generalized linear mixed models

ABSTRACT

Modeling diagnostics assess models by means of a variety of criteria. Each criterion typically performs its evaluation upon a specific inferential objective. For instance, the well-known DFBETAS in linear regression models are a modeling diagnostic which is applied to discover the influential cases in fitting a model. To facilitate the evaluation of generalized linear mixed models (GLMM), we develop a diagnostic for detecting influential cases based on the information complexity (ICOMP) criteria for detecting influential cases which substantially affect the model selection criterion ICOMP. In a given model, the diagnostic compares the ICOMP criterion between the full data set and a case-deleted data set. The computational formula of the ICOMP criterion is evaluated using the Fisher information matrix. A simulation study is accomplished and a real data set of cancer cells is analyzed using the logistic linear mixed model for illustrating the effectiveness of the proposed diagnostic in detecting the influential cases.     

A MORE GENERAL CRITERION FOR SUBSET SELECTION IN MULTIPLE LINEAR REGRESSION

ABSTRACT

In this article, we propose a more general criterion called S_p -criterion, for subset selection in the multiple linear regression Model. Many subset selection methods are based on the Least Squares (LS) estimator of β, but whenever the data contain an influential observation or the distribution of the error variable deviates from normality, the LS estimator performs ‘poorly’ and hence a method based on this estimator (for example, Mallows’ C_p -criterion) tends to select a ‘wrong’ subset. The proposed method overcomes this drawback and its main feature is that it can be used with any type of estimator (either the LS estimator or any robust estimator) of β without any need for modification of the proposed criterion. Moreover, this technique is operationally simple to implement as compared to other existing criteria. The method is illustrated with examples.     

Linear model selection by cross-validation

We consider the problem of model (or variable) selection in the classical regression model based on cross-validation with an added penalty term for penalizing overfitting. Under some weak conditions, the new criterion is shown to be strongly consistent in the sense that with probability one, for all large n, the criterion chooses the smallest true model. The penalty function denoted by C_n depends on the sample size n and is chosen to ensure the consistency in the selection of true model. There are various choices of C_n suggested in the literature on model selection. In this paper we show that a particular choice of C_n based on observed data, which makes it random, preserves the consistency property and provides improved performance over a fixed choice of C_n.     

Consistency of information criteria for model selection with missing data

ABSTRACT

In this paper, we investigate the consistency of the Expectation Maximization (EM) algorithm-based information criteria for model selection with missing data. The criteria correspond to a penalization of the conditional expectation of the complete data log-likelihood given the observed data and with respect to the missing data conditional density. We present asymptotic properties related to maximum likelihood estimation in the presence of incomplete data and we provide sufficient conditions for the consistency of model selection by minimizing the information criteria. Their finite sample performance is illustrated through simulation and real data studies.     

A consistent model selection for orthogonal regression under component-wise shrinkage

Several authors developed a series of model selection criteria for determining the major frequency components in harmonic analysis. In this paper, we considered another direction of the extension. Specifically, we proposed a model selection criterion for an orthogonal regression estimated with a component-wise shrinkage method and proved the consistency of the proposed criterion. Through simple numerical examples, we verified the performance of the proposed criterion with the empirical component-wise shrinkage estimator. Our criterion is fully empirical and thus can be applied directly for practical uses.     

Robust estimation and variable selection for varying-coefficient single-index models based on modal regression

ABSTRACT

In this paper, we propose a new efficient and robust penalized estimating procedure for varying-coefficient single-index models based on modal regression and basis function approximations. The proposed procedure simultaneously solves two types of problems: separation of varying and constant effects and selection of variables with non zero coefficients for both non parametric and index components using three smoothly clipped absolute deviation (SCAD) penalties. With appropriate selection of the tuning parameters, the new method possesses the consistency in variable selection and the separation of varying and constant coefficients. In addition, the estimators of varying coefficients possess the optimal convergence rate and the estimators of constant coefficients and index parameters have the oracle property. Finally, we investigate the finite sample performance of the proposed method through a simulation study and real data analysis.     

Robust variable selection for the varying coefficient model based on composite L 1–L 2 regression

The varying coefficient model (VCM) is an important generalization of the linear regression model and many existing estimation procedures for VCM were built on L ₂ loss, which is popular for its mathematical beauty but is not robust to non-normal errors and outliers. In this paper, we address the problem of both robustness and efficiency of estimation and variable selection procedure based on the convex combined loss of L ₁ and L ₂ instead of only quadratic loss for VCM. By using local linear modeling method, the asymptotic normality of estimation is driven and a useful selection method is proposed for the weight of composite L ₁ and L ₂. Then the variable selection procedure is given by combining local kernel smoothing with adaptive group LASSO. With appropriate selection of tuning parameters by Bayesian information criterion (BIC) the theoretical properties of the new procedure, including consistency in variable selection and the oracle property in estimation, are established. The finite sample performance of the new method is investigated through simulation studies and the analysis of body fat data. Numerical studies show that the new method is better than or at least as well as the least square-based method in terms of both robustness and efficiency for variable selection.     

Shrinkage inverse regression estimation for model-free variable selection

Summary.  The family of inverse regression estimators that was recently proposed by Cook and Ni has proven effective in dimension reduction by transforming the high dimensional predictor vector to its low dimensional projections. We propose a general shrinkage estimation strategy for the entire inverse regression estimation family that is capable of simultaneous dimension reduction and variable selection. We demonstrate that the new estimators achieve consistency in variable selection without requiring any traditional model, meanwhile retaining the root n estimation consistency of the dimension reduction basis. We also show the effectiveness of the new estimators through both simulation and real data analysis.     

Model selection criteria for dual-inflated data

ABSTRACT

Inflated data are prevalent in many situations and a variety of inflated models with extensions have been derived to fit data with excessive counts of some particular responses. The family of information criteria (IC) has been used to compare the fit of models for selection purposes. Yet despite the common use in statistical applications, there are not too many studies evaluating the performance of IC in inflated models. In this study, we studied the performance of IC for data with dual-inflated data. The new zero- and K-inflated Poisson (ZKIP) regression model and conventional inflated models including Poisson regression and zero-inflated Poisson (ZIP) regression were fitted for dual-inflated data and the performance of IC were compared. The effect of sample sizes and the proportions of inflated observations towards selection performance were also examined. The results suggest that the Bayesian information criterion (BIC) and consistent Akaike information criterion (CAIC) are more accurate than the Akaike information criterion (AIC) in terms of model selection when the true model is simple (i.e. Poisson regression (POI)). For more complex models, such as ZIP and ZKIP, the AIC was consistently better than the BIC and CAIC, although it did not reach high levels of accuracy when sample size and the proportion of zero observations were small. The AIC tended to over-fit the data for the POI, whereas the BIC and CAIC tended to under-parameterize the data for ZIP and ZKIP. Therefore, it is desirable to study other model selection criteria for dual-inflated data with small sample size.     

Model selection with data-oriented penalty

We consider the problem of model (or variable) selection in the classical regression model using the GIC (general information criterion). In this method the maximum likelihood is used with a penalty function denoted by C_n, depending on the sample size n and chosen to ensure consistency in the selection of the true model. There are various choices of C_n suggested in the literature on model selection. In this paper we show that a particular choice of C_n based on observed data, which makes it random, preserves the consistency property and provides improved performance over a fixed choice of C_n.     

Two-Step Estimation of Incomplete Information Social Interaction Models With Sample Selection

ABSTRACT

This article considers linear social interaction models under incomplete information that allow for missing outcome data due to sample selection. For model estimation, assuming that each individual forms his/her belief about the other members’ outcomes based on rational expectations, we propose a two-step series nonlinear least squares estimator. Both the consistency and asymptotic normality of the estimator are established. As an empirical illustration, we apply the proposed model and method to National Longitudinal Study of Adolescent Health (Add Health) data to examine the impacts of friendship interactions on adolescents’ academic achievements. We provide empirical evidence that the interaction effects are important determinants of grade point average and that controlling for sample selection bias has certain impacts on the estimation results. Supplementary materials for this article are available online.     

Variable selection of the quantile varying coefficient regression models

As a useful supplement to mean regression, quantile regression is a completely distribution-free approach and is more robust to heavy-tailed random errors. In this paper, a variable selection procedure for quantile varying coefficient models is proposed by combining local polynomial smoothing with adaptive group LASSO. With an appropriate selection of tuning parameters by the BIC criterion, the theoretical properties of the new procedure, including consistency in variable selection and the oracle property in estimation, are established. The finite sample performance of the newly proposed method is investigated through simulation studies and the analysis of Boston house price data. Numerical studies confirm that the newly proposed procedure (QKLASSO) has both robustness and efficiency for varying coefficient models irrespective of error distribution, which is a good alternative and necessary supplement to the KLASSO method.     

New improvements in the use of dependence measures for sensitivity analysis and screening

ABSTRACT

Physical phenomena are commonly modelled by time consuming numerical simulators, function of many uncertain parameters whose influences can be measured via a global sensitivity analysis. The usual variance-based indices require too many simulations, especially as the inputs are numerous. To address this limitation, we consider recent advances in dependence measures, focusing on the distance correlation and the Hilbert–Schmidt independence criterion. We study and use these indices for a screening purpose. Numerical tests reveal differences between variance-based indices and dependence measures. Then, two approaches are proposed to use the latter for a screening purpose. The first approach uses independence tests, with existing asymptotic versions and spectral extensions; bootstrap versions are also proposed. The second considers a linear model with dependence measures, coupled to a bootstrap selection method or a Lasso penalization. Numerical experiments show their potential in the presence of many non-influential inputs and give successful results for a nuclear reliability application.