Testing for spurious and cointegrated regressions: A wavelet approach

This paper proposes a wavelet-based approach to analyze spurious and cointegrated regressions in time series. The approach is based on the properties of the wavelet covariance and correlation in Monte Carlo studies of spurious and cointegrated regression. In the case of the spurious regression, the null hypotheses of zero wavelet covariance and correlation for these series across the scales fail to be rejected. Conversely, these null hypotheses across the scales are rejected for the cointegrated bivariate time series. These nonresidual-based tests are then applied to analyze if any relationship exists between the extraterrestrial phenomenon of sunspots and the earthly economic time series of oil prices. Conventional residual-based tests appear sensitive to the specification in both the cointegrating regression and the lag order in the augmented Dickey–Fuller tests on the residuals. In contrast, the wavelet tests, with their bootstrap t-statistics and confidence intervals, detect the spuriousness of this relationship.     

结构突变趋势平稳过程与随机趋势过程的虚假回归研究

 内容提要：在已有研究的基础上,本文更为深入的研究含有结构突变的趋势平稳变量与随机趋势变量间的虚假回归问题。本文推导出OLS估计下DW统计量、F统计量以及R2的极限分布,并且将回归模型扩展到动态情形下,推导出用于Granger因果检验的F统计量的极限分布;采用Monte Carlo模拟方法分析了数据生成过程的各项参数对各统计量有限样本分布的影响;最后,本文分析了在有限样本下,数据生成过程的各项参数对虚假回归及虚假Granger因果关系发生概率的影响。     

Evidence of spurious regression driven by heavy-tailed observations with structural changes

This article extends the theoretical analysis of spurious relationship and considers the situation where the deterministic components of the processes generating individual series are independent heavy-tailed with structural changes. It shows when those sequences are used in ordinary least-square regression, the convenient t-statistic procedures wrongly indicate that (i) the spurious significance is established when regressing mean-stationary and trend-stationary series with structural changes, (ii) the spurious relationship occurs under broken mean-stationary and difference-stationary sequences, and (iii) the extent of spurious regression becomes stronger between difference-stationary and trend-stationary series in the presence of breaks. The spurious phenomenon is present regardless of the sample size and structural breaks taking place at the same points or not. Simulation experiments confirm our asymptotic results and reveal that the spurious effects are not only sensitive to the relative location of structural changes with the sample, but seriously depend on the stable indexes.     

Evidence of ARCH(1) Errors in the Context of Spurious Regressions

The spurious regression phenomenon is related to first-order serially correlated errors. This study, using a Monte Carlo analysis, finds that this phenomenon is also related to ARCH(1) type errors.     

Spurious Instrumental Variables

Spurious regression phenomenon has been recognized for a wide range of Data Generating Processes: driftless unit roots, unit roots with drift, long memory, trend and broken-trend stationarity, etc. The usual framework is Ordinary Least Squares. We show that the spurious phenomenon also occurs in Instrumental Variables estimation when using non stationary variables, whether the non stationarity component is stochastic or deterministic. Finite sample evidence supports the asymptotic results.     

Testing for spurious regression in a panel data model with the individual number and time length growing

This article shows a test for the spurious regression problem in a panel data model with a growing individual number and time series length. In the estimation, tapers are used and the integrated order for the remainder disturbance is extended to a real number; at the same time, the spurious regression problem can be detected without prior knowledge. Through Monte Carlo experiments, we examine the consistent estimators by various sizes of time length and individual number, in which the remainder disturbance is assumed to be either stationary or non-stationary. In addition, the asymptotic normality properties are discussed with a quasi log-likelihood function. From the power tests we can see that the estimators are quite successful and powerful.     

Bilinear modulation models for seasonal tables of counts

We propose generalized linear models for time or age-time tables of seasonal counts, with the goal of better understanding seasonal patterns in the data. The linear predictor contains a smooth component for the trend and the product of a smooth component (the modulation) and a periodic time series of arbitrary shape (the carrier wave). To model rates, a population offset is added. Two-dimensional trends and modulation are estimated using a tensor product B-spline basis of moderate dimension. Further smoothness is ensured using difference penalties on the rows and columns of the tensor product coefficients. The optimal penalty tuning parameters are chosen based on minimization of a quasi-information criterion. Computationally efficient estimation is achieved using array regression techniques, avoiding excessively large matrices. The model is applied to female death rate in the US due to cerebrovascular diseases and respiratory diseases.     

A new look at an old problem: Finding temporal patterns in homicide series—the Canadian case

It is believed by criminologists that the incidence of crimes committed against persons is highest in the summer. Knowledge about the annual patterns and other temporal behavior of such crimes can help authorities in prevention. The objective of this study is to reveal the temporal behavior of murders in Canada and assess if they are affected by trend-cyclical and/or seasonal influences. The series analyzed comprise the period 1961 to 1980 and are classified according to suspects and victims. Only the quarterly series display a significant seasonal pattern, with the peak occurring in the third quarter. We have also analyzed the relationship between the trend cycle of the murder series and two other variables, namely unemployment rate and rate of growth of the 15-to-44 age group.     

A Survey of Recent Developments in Seasonal Adjustment

In recent years there have been notable advances in the methodology for analyzing seasonal time series. This paper summarizes some recent research on seasonal adjustment problems and procedures. Included are signal-extraction methods based on autoregressive integrated moving average (ARIMA) models, improvements in X–11, revisions in preliminary seasonal factors, regression and other model-based methods, robust methods, seasonal model identification, aggregation, interrelating seasonally adjusted series, and causal approaches to seasonal adjustment.     

Critical values for unit root tests in seasonal time series

SUMMARY In this paper, we present tables with critical values for a variety of tests for seasonal and non-seasonal unit roots in seasonal time series. We consider (extensions of) the Hylleberg et al. and Osborn et al. test procedures. These extensions concern time series with increasing seasonal variation and time series with structural breaks in the seasonal means. For each case, we give the appropriate auxiliary test regression, the test statistics, and the corresponding critical values for a selected set of sample sizes. We also illustrate the practical use of the auxiliary regressions for quarterly new car sales in the Netherlands. Supplementary to this paper, we provide Gauss programs with which one can generate critical values for particular seasonal frequencies and sample sizes.     

Simple linear regression with multiple level shifts

The authors study the properties of the ordinary least squares trend estimator in a simple linear regression model with multiple known level shift times. The error component in the model is taken to be a general short‐memory stationary time series. The authors establish the consistency and asymptotic normality of the estimator. They also present a climatological application in which the multiple level shifts are prominent features.     

Trend and seasonal decomposition in discrete time

A time series is decomposed into a trend-cyclical plus seasonal component by minimizing the sum of a smoothness and a goodness of fit criterion. The smoothness criterion is such that polynomials (trend-cyclical component) and trigonometric functions (seasonal component) are rated with the ideal value zero. The residual sum of squares serves as goodness of fit criterion. The solution is then decomposed into the two components in a natural way.     

Forecasting Economic Time Series With Structural and Box-Jenkins Models: A Case Study

The basic structural model is a univariate time series model consisting of a slowly changing trend component, a slowly changing seasonal component, and a random irregular component. It is part of a class of models that have a number of advantages over the seasonal ARIMA models adopted by Box and Jenkins (1976). This article reports the results of an exercise in which the basic structural model was estimated for six U.K. macroeconomic time series and the forecasting performance compared with that of ARIMA models previously fitted by Prothero and Wallis (1976).     

Measures of Variability for Model-Based Seasonal Adjustment Procedures

An algorithm is derived that develops measures of variability for the estimates of the nonseasonal component computed from a model-based seasonal adjustment procedure. The measures of variability are developed from signal extraction theory. Properties of components of the variance are developed, and the behavior of the variance is investigated for one popular time series model. The results are illustrated by using real data.     

On trends and constants in periodic autoregressions

Periodic autoregressions are characterised by autoregressive structures that vary with the season. If a time series is periodically integrated, one needs a seasonally varying differencing filter to remove the stochastic trend. When the periodic regression model contains constants and trends with unrestricted parameters, the data can show diverging seasonal deterministic trends. In this paper we derive explicit expressions for parameter restrictions that result in common deterministic trends under periodic trend stationarity and periodic integration.     

On trends and constants in periodic autoregressions

Periodic autoregressions are characterised by autoregressive structures that vary with the season. If a time series is periodically integrated, one needs a seasonally varying differencing filter to remove the stochastic trend. When the periodic regression model contains constants and trends with unrestricted parameters, the data can show diverging seasonal deterministic trends. In this paper we derive explicit expressions for parameter restrictions that result in common deterministic trends under periodic trend stationarity and periodic integration.     

Modelling seasonally varying data: A case study for Sudden Infant Death Syndrome (SIDS)

Many time series are measured monthly, either as averages or totals, and such data often exhibit seasonal variability – the values of the series are consistently larger for some months of the year than for others. A typical series of this type is the number of deaths each month attributed to SIDS (Sudden Infant Death Syndrome). Seasonality can be modelled in a number of ways. This paper describes and discusses various methods for modelling seasonality in SIDS data, though much of the discussion is relevant to other seasonally varying data. There are two main approaches, either fitting a circular probability distribution to the data, or using regression-based techniques to model the mean seasonal behaviour. Both are discussed in this paper.     

A measure of output gap for Italy through structural time series models

The aim of this paper is to achieve a reliable estimate of the output gap for Italy through the development of several models within the class of the unobserved component time series models. These formulations imply the decomposition of output into a trend component (the 'potential output') and a cycle component (the 'output gap'). Both univariate and multivariate methods will be explored. In the former, only one measure of aggregate activity, such as GDP, is considered; in the latter, unemployment and industrial production are introduced. A comparison with alternative measures of output gap, mainly those published by international organisations, will conclude.     

A comparison of indicators for evaluating x-11-arima seasonal adjustment

Summary The evaluation of the performance of seasonal adjustment procedures is an issue of practical importance in view of the unobservable nature of the components. Looking at just one indicator when judging the overall quality of a procedure may be misleading, even though this is common practice when many series are involved. The main purpose of this paper is to compare the information content of different synthetic indicators with reference to the X-11-ARIMA procedure. Sixty-six different types of monthly seasonal series are generated and the seasonal component then extracted by carrying out X-11-ARIMA with standard options. The correlation between the pseudo-true error for each series and various synthetic indicators allows us to compare the latter's reliability, under both the hypotheses of minimum and maximum variance of the pseudo-true seasonal component. We show that the overall quality indexQ-the indicator most commonly adopted by users of the X-11-ARIMA-is always outperformed by the simpler diagnostics based on the stability of the estimates. In particular, the “sliding-spans” indicator, proposed by Findley et al. (1990) and included in the diagnostics of the new X-12 procedure, shows a much stronger correlation with the pseudo-true error in the seasonal adjustment. We also show that the total forecasting errors in the one-year-ahead extrapolation of the seasonal component have a good informative power and perform almost as well as the “sliding-spans” indicator.     

Parameter Estimation Robust to Low-Frequency Contamination

We provide methods to robustly estimate the parameters of stationary ergodic short-memory time series models in the potential presence of additive low-frequency contamination. The types of contamination covered include level shifts (changes in mean) and monotone or smooth time trends, both of which have been shown to bias parameter estimates toward regions of persistence in a variety of contexts. The estimators presented here minimize trimmed frequency domain quasi-maximum likelihood (FDQML) objective functions without requiring specification of the low-frequency contaminating component. When proper sample size-dependent trimmings are used, the FDQML estimators are consistent and asymptotically normal, asymptotically eliminating the presence of any spurious persistence. These asymptotic results also hold in the absence of additive low-frequency contamination, enabling the practitioner to robustly estimate model parameters without prior knowledge of whether contamination is present. Popular time series models that fit into the framework of this article include autoregressive moving average (ARMA), stochastic volatility, generalized autoregressive conditional heteroscedasticity (GARCH), and autoregressive conditional heteroscedasticity (ARCH) models. We explore the finite sample properties of the trimmed FDQML estimators of the parameters of some of these models, providing practical guidance on trimming choice. Empirical estimation results suggest that a large portion of the apparent persistence in certain volatility time series may indeed be spurious. Supplementary materials for this article are available online.