Small sample power of multivariate nonparametric tests for monotone trend

Bhattacharyya and Kioiz (1966) propose two multivariate nonparametric tests for monotone trend, one involving coordinate-wise Mann statistics and the other, coordinate-wise Spearman statistics. Dietz and Killeen (1981) propose a different test statistic based on coordinate-wise Mann statistics. The Pitman asymptotic relative efficiency of all three tests with respect to a normal theory competitor equals the cube root of the efficiency of a multivariate signed rank test with respect to Hotelling's T2. In this article, the small sample power of the nonparametric tests, the normal theory test, and a Bonferroni approach involving coordinate-wise univariate Mann or Spearman tests is examined in a simulation study. The Mann statistic of Dietz and Killeen and the Spearman statistic of Bhattacharyya and Klotz are found to perform well under both null and alternative hypotheses     

On an asymptotic relative efficiency concept based on expected volumes of confidence regions

ABSTRACT

The paper deals with an asymptotic relative efficiency concept for confidence regions of multidimensional parameters that is based on the expected volumes of the confidence regions. Under standard conditions the asymptotic relative efficiencies of confidence regions are seen to be certain powers of the ratio of the limits of the expected volumes. These limits are explicitly derived for confidence regions associated with certain plugin estimators, likelihood ratio tests and Wald tests. Under regularity conditions, the asymptotic relative efficiency of each of these procedures with respect to each one of its competitors is equal to 1. The results are applied to multivariate normal distributions and multinomial distributions in a fairly general setting.     

An Affine-Invariant Generalization of the Wilcoxon Signed-Rank Test for the Bivariate Location Problem

This paper proposes an affine‐invariant test extending the univariate Wilcoxon signed‐rank test to the bivariate location problem. It gives two versions of the null distribution of the test statistic. The first version leads to a conditionally distribution‐free test which can be used with any sample size. The second version can be used for larger sample sizes and has a limiting χ₂² distribution under the null hypothesis. The paper investigates the relationship with a test proposed by Jan & Randles (1994). It shows that the Pitman efficiency of this test relative to the new test is equal to 1 for elliptical distributions but that the two tests are not necessarily equivalent for non‐elliptical distributions. These facts are also demonstrated empirically in a simulation study. The new test has the advantage of not requiring the assumption of elliptical symmetry which is needed to perform the asymptotic version of the Jan and Randles test.     

Asymptotic efficiencies of estiamtors of location a comutational study

Asymptotic efficiencies of four classes of estimators of location are evaluated for a family of distributions consisting of t, lambda and contaminated normal densities. For the class of estimators derived from signed rank tests, maximin efficiencies between pairs of distributions in the family are computed using a formula of Gastwirth ( 1966 ). Asymptotic efficiencies are also evaluated for the scale dependent estimators of the form proposed by Hubcr ( 1964 ) and the efficiencies of procedures utilizing interquantiie ranges.are evaluated. Efficiencies of linear estimators such as trimmed means, BLUE's for the lambda family are computed for each density considered. Efficiencies of linear, polynomial and trigonometric approximations to BLUE weight functions are determined. Using the method of Birnbaum and Laska ( 1967 ) maximin efficiencies are computed using four linear or polynomial terms. On the basis of comparisons of these numerical results, suggestions for robust estimators are given     

Linear Signed Rank Test for Model Selection

In this article, we consider a linear signed rank test for non-nested distributions in the context of the model selection. Introducing a new test, we show that, it is asymptotically more efficient than the Vuong test and the test statistic based on B statistic introduced by Clarke. However, here, we let the magnitude of the data give a better performance to the test statistic. We have shown that this test is an unbiased one. The results of simulations show that the rank test has the greater statistical power than the Vuong test where the underline distributions is symmetric.     

Wilcoxon's signed‐rank statistic: what null hypothesis and why it matters

In statistical literature, the term ‘signed‐rank test’ (or ‘Wilcoxon signed‐rank test’) has been used to refer to two distinct tests: a test for symmetry of distribution and a test for the median of a symmetric distribution, sharing a common test statistic. To avoid potential ambiguity, we propose to refer to those two tests by different names, as ‘test for symmetry based on signed‐rank statistic’ and ‘test for median based on signed‐rank statistic’, respectively. The utility of such terminological differentiation should become evident through our discussion of how those tests connect and contrast with sign test and one‐sample t‐test. Published 2014. This article is a U.S. Government work and is in the public domain in the USA.     

Simple nonparametric tests for a known standard survival based on censored data

It is often of interest in survival analysis to test whether the distribution of lifetimes from which the sample under study was derived is the same as a reference distribution. The latter can be specified on the basis of previous studies or on subject matter considerations. In this paper several tests are developed for the above hypothesis, suitable for right-censored observations. The tests are based on modifications of Moses' one-sample limits of some classical two-sample rank tests. The asymptotic distributions of the test statistics are derived, consistency is established for alternatives which are stochastically ordered with respect to the null, and Pitman asymptotic efficiencies are calculated relative to competing tests. Simulated power comparisons are reported. An example is given with data on the survival times of lung cancer patients.     

The two-sample problem with multivariate censored data: a new rank test family

A new rank test family is proposed to test the equality of two multivariate failure times distributions with censored observations. The tests are very simple: they are based on a transformation of the multivariate rank vectors to a univariate rank score and the resulting statistics belong to the familiar class of the weighted logrank test statistics. The new procedure is also applicable to multivariate observations in general, such as repeated measures, some of which may be missing. To investigate the performance of the proposed tests, a simulation study was conducted with bivariate exponential models for various censoring rates. The size and power of these tests against Lehmann alternatives were compared to the size and power of two other tests (Wei and Lachin, 1984 and Wei and Knuiman, 1987). In all simulations the new procedures provide a relatively good power and an accurate control over the size of the test. A real example from the National Cooperative Gallstone Study is given     

An extended class of permutation techniques for matched pairs

A class of matched-pairs permutation techniques based on distances between each pair of observed signed values is considered. Although many commonly-used inference techniques for matched pairs are members of this class, some of the more appealing inference techniques among this class have received very little attention. Two new simple rank tests of this class jointly possess both intuitive properties and location-alternative power characteristics which appear more appealing than the corresponding characteristics of either the sign test or the Wllcoxon signed-ranks test. In particular, power comparisons based on slmula-tions indicate that these new rank tests are jointly as good or even vastly superior to the sign test or the Wilcoxon signed-ranks test for location alternatives involving five symmetric distributions. The five distributions selected for these com-parisons include the Laplace, logistic, normal, uniform and a U-shaped distribution     

ON TESTS OF SYMMETRY FOR DISCRETE POPULATIONS

In this paper problems of tests of symmetry about the origin with discrete samples are considered. Recently Vorli?ková established the asymptotic normality of linear rank statistics and signed rank statistics in [5] and [6]. Here we propose statistics which are conditionally the sum of independent variables, including the locally most powerful tests for a one sided one parameter family. Their asymptotic distributions are derived under the null hypothesis and the contiguous rounding off location alternatives. We propose four types of signed rank tests and investigate their properties.     

On optimal testing for the equality of equicorrelation: An example of loss in power

Sen Gupta (1988) considered a locally most powerful (LMP) test for testing nonzero values of the equicorrelation coefficient of a standard symmetric multivariate normal distribution. This paper constructs analogous tests for the symmetric multivariate normal distribution. It shows that the new test is uniformly most powerful invariant even in the presence of a nuisance parameter, σ². Further applications of LMP invariant tests to several equicorrelated populations have been considered and an extension to panel data modeling has been suggested.     

Tests for the multivariate two-sample problem based on empirical probability measures

Nonparametric tests are proposed for the equality of two unknown p-variate distributions. Empirical probability measures are defined from samples from the two distributions and used to construct test statistics as the supremum of the absolute differences between empirical probabilities, the supremum being taken over all possible events. The test statistics are truly multivariate in not requiring the artificial ranking of multivariate observations, and they are distribution-free in the general p-variate case. Asymptotic null distributions are obtained. Powers of the proposed tests and a competitor are examined by Monte Carlo techniques.     

A note on the multivariate multisample rank sum and median tests

The muitivariate nonparametric tests analogous to the univar-iate rank sum test and median test are contained in Puri and Sen (1970). These tests provided a practical alternative for the analysis of multivariate data when the assumptions of parametric methods are not satisfied.

In this paper maximum values for L_Nthe asymptotic chi-Square test statistic for both the Multivariate Multisample Rank Sum Test (MMRST) and the Multivariate Multisample Median Test (MMMT) are developed.     

Saddlepoint p-values for a class of tests for comparing competing risks with censored data

One of the general problems in clinical trials and mortality rates is the comparison of competing risks. Most of the test statistics used for independent and dependent risks with censored data belong to the class of weighted linear rank tests in its multivariate version. In this paper, we introduce the saddlepoint approximations as accurate and fast approximations for the exact p-values of this class of tests instead of the asymptotic and permutation simulated calculations. Real data examples and extensive simulation studies showed the accuracy and stability performance of the saddlepoint approximations over different scenarios of lifetime distributions, sample sizes and censoring.     

Improved hypothesis testing in a general multivariate elliptical model

This paper investigates improved testing inferences under a general multivariate elliptical regression model. The model is very flexible in terms of the specification of the mean vector and the dispersion matrix, and of the choice of the error distribution. The error terms are allowed to follow a multivariate distribution in the class of the elliptical distributions, which has the multivariate normal and Student-t distributions as special cases. We obtain Skovgaard's adjusted likelihood ratio (LR) statistics and Barndorff-Nielsen's adjusted signed LR statistics and we compare the methods through simulations. The simulations suggest that the proposed tests display superior finite sample behaviour as compared to the standard tests. Two applications are presented in order to illustrate the methods.     

Testing linear inequality constraints in the standard linear model

In this paper we are concerned with the problem of testing whether the â-parameters of the standard linear model satisfy the linear equality constraints R = r when they are known to satisfy the corresponding linear inequality constraints Râ ? r. In particular we will show that the exact finite sample null distributions of the Likelihood Ratio, Wald and Kuhn-Tucker

statistics are known when R is of full row rank but not known when R has less than full row rank. The less than full row rank problem has not been discussed previously but it is of considerable potential importance.

This paper contains several simple numerical examples which illustrate the computational details of the tests     

A survey on multivariate chi-square distributions and their applications in testing multiple hypotheses

We are concerned with three different types of multivariate chi-square distributions. Their members play important roles as limiting distributions of vectors of test statistics in several applications of multiple hypotheses testing. We explain these applications and consider the computation of multiplicity-adjusted p-values under the respective global hypothesis. By means of numerical examples, we demonstrate how much gain in level exhaustion or, equivalently, power can be achieved with corresponding multivariate multiple tests compared with approaches which are only based on univariate marginal distributions and do not take the dependence structure among the test statistics into account. As a further contribution of independent value, we provide an overview of essentially all analytic formulas for computing multivariate chi-square probabilities of the considered types which are available up to present. These formulas were scattered in the previous literature and are presented here in a unified manner.     

A signed rank test for censored paired lifetimes

A locally most powerful signed rank test is proposed for the comparison of two independent lifetimes under the accelerated failure time model.

The test is based on N independent pairs(X_i, Y_i), i = 1, …, N: it is supposed that the shortest lifetime in each pair is observed and the experiment is stopped after r(r≤N and fixed) such lifetimes are available (type II censoring).

Actual scores of the test statistic are computed for some specific source distributions of the observations. The asymptotic distribution of the test statistic, as well as the asymptotic power and efficiency are given. The values of these efficiencies are computed for the case where the X_i follow and exponential, Weibull Gamma or Rayleigh distribution.     

Power of depth-based nonparametric tests for multivariate locations

Li and Liu [New nonparametric tests of multivariate locations and scales. Statist Sci. 2004;19(4):686–696] introduced two tests for a difference in locations of two multivariate distributions based on the concept of data depth. Using the simplicial depth [Liu RY. On a notion of data depth based on random simplices. Ann Stat. 1990;18(1):405–414], they studied the performance of these tests for symmetric distributions, namely, the normal and the Cauchy, in a simulation study. However, to the best of our knowledge, the performance of these tests for skewed distributions has not been studied in the current literature. This paper is a contribution in that direction and examines the performance of these depth-based tests in an extensive simulation study involving ten distributions belonging to five well-known families of multivariate skewed distributions. The study includes a comparison of the performance of these tests for four popular affine-invariant depth functions. Conclusions and recommendations are offered.     

A comparative study of tests for paired lifetime data

In this paper, we investigate different procedures for testing the equality of two mean survival times in paired lifetime studies. We consider Owen’s M-test and Q-test, a likelihood ratio test, the paired t-test, the Wilcoxon signed rank test and a permutation test based on log-transformed survival times in the comparative study. We also consider the paired t-test, the Wilcoxon signed rank test and a permutation test based on original survival times for the sake of comparison. The size and power characteristics of these tests are studied by means of Monte Carlo simulations under a frailty Weibull model. For less skewed marginal distributions, the Wilcoxon signed rank test based on original survival times is found to be desirable. Otherwise, the M-test and the likelihood ratio test are the best choices in terms of power. In general, one can choose a test procedure based on information about the correlation between the two survival times and the skewness of the marginal survival distributions.