Causal inference in outcome-dependent two-phase sampling designs

Summary.  We consider estimation of the causal effect of a treatment on an outcome from observational data collected in two phases. In the first phase, a simple random sample of individuals is drawn from a population. On these individuals, information is obtained on treatment, outcome and a few low dimensional covariates. These individuals are then stratified according to these factors. In the second phase, a random subsample of individuals is drawn from each stratum, with known stratum-specific selection probabilities. On these individuals, a rich set of covariates is collected. In this setting, we introduce five estimators: simple inverse weighted; simple doubly robust; enriched inverse weighted; enriched doubly robust; locally efficient. We evaluate the finite sample performance of these estimators in a simulation study. We also use our methodology to estimate the causal effect of trauma care on in-hospital mortality by using data from the National Study of Cost and Outcomes of Trauma.     

Optimal estimation for finite population mean in two-phase sampling

Using two-phase sampling scheme, we propose a general class of estimators for finite population mean. This class depends on the sample means and variances of two auxiliary variables. The minimum variance bound for any estimator in the class is provided (up to terms of ordern ⁻¹). It is also proved that there exists at least a chain regression type estimator which reaches this minimum. Finally, it is shown that other proposed estimators can reach the minimum variance bound, i.e. the optimal estimator is not unique.     

Efficient family of estimators of median using two-phase sampling design

ABSTRACT

For a trivariate distribution, an efficient family of estimators of median of study variable using the known information on the auxiliary variables has been proposed under two-phase sampling design. The expressions for bias and its mean square error have been obtained up to first order of approximation. It has been shown that the proposed estimator has smaller bias as compared to estimator defined by Singh et al. (2006 Singh, S., Singh, H.P., Upadhyaya, L.N. (2006). Chain ratio and regression type estimators for median estimation in survey sampling. Statist. Pap. 48:23–46.[Crossref], [Web of Science ®] , [Google Scholar]) with the same efficiency. The results have also been illustrated numerically by taking data from different populations considered in literature.     

On generalized exponential chain ratio estimators under stratified two-phase random sampling

Sanaullah et al. (2014 Sanaullah, A., Ali, H.M., Noor ul Amin, M., Hanif, M. (2014). Generalized exponential chain ratio estimators under stratified two-phase random sampling. Appl. Math. Comput. 226:541–547.[Crossref], [Web of Science ®] , [Google Scholar]) have suggested generalized exponential chain ratio estimators under stratified two-phase sampling scheme for estimating the finite population mean. However, the bias and mean square error (MSE) expressions presented in that work need some corrections, and consequently the study based on efficiency comparison also requires corrections. In this article, we revisit Sanaullah et al. (2014 Sanaullah, A., Ali, H.M., Noor ul Amin, M., Hanif, M. (2014). Generalized exponential chain ratio estimators under stratified two-phase random sampling. Appl. Math. Comput. 226:541–547.[Crossref], [Web of Science ®] , [Google Scholar]) estimator and provide the correct bias and MSE expressions of their estimator. We also propose an estimator which is more efficient than several competing estimators including the classes of estimators in Sanaullah et al. (2014 Sanaullah, A., Ali, H.M., Noor ul Amin, M., Hanif, M. (2014). Generalized exponential chain ratio estimators under stratified two-phase random sampling. Appl. Math. Comput. 226:541–547.[Crossref], [Web of Science ®] , [Google Scholar]). Three real datasets are used for efficiency comparisons.     

Calibration approach estimation of the mean in stratified sampling and stratified double sampling

Calibration estimation improves the precision of the estimates of population parameters by incorporating specified auxiliary information. A class of calibration estimators has been proposed for estimating the population mean by making use of a set of calibration constraints in stratified sampling. The estimator of variance of the proposed calibration estimator of the mean is derived using a lower level calibration approach. The idea is extended for stratified double sampling. A simulation study is used to evaluate the performances of the proposed estimators by comparing them with the similar estimators developed by Tracy, Singh and Arnab (2003 Tracy, D.S., Singh, S., Arnab, R. (2003). Note on calibration in stratified and double sampling. Surv. Methodol. 29(1): 99–104. [Google Scholar]) based on different sets of calibration constraints.     

A new method of imputation in survey sampling

In this paper, an alternative estimator of population mean in the presence of non-response has been suggested which comes in the form of Walsh's estimator. The estimator of mean obtained from the proposed technique remains better than the estimators obtained from ratio or mean methods of imputation. The mean-squared error (MSE) of the resultant estimator is less than that of the estimator obtained on the basis of ratio method of imputation for the optimum choice of parameters. An estimator for estimating a parameter involved in the process of new method of imputation has been discussed. A suggestion to form ‘warm deck’ method of imputation has been suggested. The MSE expressions for the proposed estimators have been derived analytically and compared empirically. The work has been extended to the case of multi-auxiliary information to be used for imputation. Numerical illustrations are also provided.     

Predictive estimation of population mean in two-phase sampling

ABSTRACT

The present investigation deals with the problem of estimation of population mean in two-phase sampling. In the presence of two auxiliary variables, some classes of estimators have been proposed through predictive approach. Properties of the proposed classes of estimators have been studied, and the unbiased versions of these estimators along with their approximate variance expressions are obtained under simple random sampling without replacement scheme. The respective optimum strategies of the proposed estimators are discussed, and their empirical and graphical comparisons with some contemporary estimators of population mean have been made. Suitable recommendations to the survey practitioner are given.     

Some efficient classes of estimators of population mean in two-phase successive sampling under random non response

In this paper, an attempt has been made to present some efficient classes of estimators of population mean on current occasion in two-occasion successive sampling under random non response in two-phase setup. Effectiveness of the proposed classes of estimators has been studied under the assumptions that sampling units follow a distribution under the random non response. To check the performances, the proposed classes of estimators are compared with an estimator under the similar situation under the complete response. Results are demonstrated through empirical studies which show the reliable nature of the proposed classes of estimators. Suitable recommendations have been made to the survey practitioners.     

Estimation of finite population mean using two auxiliary variables in stratified two-phase sampling

We propose a new ratio type estimator for estimating the finite population mean using two auxiliary variables in stratified two-phase sampling. Expressions for bias and mean squared error of the proposed estimator are derived up to the first order of approximation. The proposed estimator is more efficient than the usual stratified sample mean estimator, traditional stratified ratio estimator and some other stratified estimators including Bahl and Tuteja (1991 Bahl, S., Tuteja, R. K. (1991). Ratio and product type exponential estimators. Information and Optimization Sciences 12:159–163. [Google Scholar]), Chami et al. (2012 Chami, P. S., Singh, B., Thomas, D. (2012). A two-prameter ratio-product-ratio estimator using auxiliary information. ISRN Probability and Statistics 2012:1–15, doi: 10.5402/2012/103860.[Crossref] , [Google Scholar]), Chand (1975 Chand, L. (1975) Some Ratio Type Estimator Based on two or more Auxiliary Variables, Ph.D. dissertation, Iowa State University, Ames, Iowa (unpublished). [Google Scholar]), Choudhury and Singh (2012 Choudhury, S., Singh, B. K. (2012). A class of chain ratio-product type estimators with two auxiliary variables under double sampling scheme. Journal of the Korean Statistical Society 41:247–256. [Google Scholar]), Hamad et al. (2013 Hamad, N., Hanif, M., Haider, N. (2013). A regression type estimator with two auxiliary variables for two-phase sampling. Open Journal of Statistics, 3:74–78. [Google Scholar]), Vishwakarma and Gangele (2014 Vishwakarma, G. K., Gangele, R. K. (2014). A class of chain ratio-type exponential estimators in double sampling using two auxiliary variates. Applied Mathematics and Computation 227:171–175. [Google Scholar]), Sanaullah et al. (2014 Sanaullah, A., Ali, H. M., Noor ul Amin, M., Hanif, M. (2014). Generalized exponential chain ratio estimators under stratified two-phase random sampling. Applied Mathematics and Computation 226:541–547. [Google Scholar]), and Chanu and Singh (2014 Chanu, W. K., Singh, B. K. (2014). Improved class of ratio-cum-product estimators of finite population mean in two phase sampling. Global Journal of Science Frontier Research: F Mathematics and Decision Sciences 14(2):1–14. [Google Scholar]).     

A two-phase sampling strategy for large-scale forest carbon budgets

The estimation of forest carbon sources and sinks is an important issue in forest inventories. For monitoring forest carbon budgets, a two-phase strategy is proposed. In the first phase, N points are thrown onto the study region by means of unaligned systematic sampling and then classified as forest or non-forest on the basis of aerial information. In the second phase, a sample of n points of those classified as forest is achieved by means of a sampling scheme with selection probabilities proportional to the sizes of an auxiliary variable. Subsequently, circular plots of adequate size are centred in the n selected points and visited in order to quantify the carbon amount within. Unbiased estimators of the forest area size as well as of the overall amount of carbon in that area and a conservative estimator of their variance–covariance matrix are derived. The strategy is applied to estimate carbon budgets in the forests of Trentino (North Italy).     

Optional randomized response technique in two-phase sampling

Two-phase optional randomized response (TORR) technique has been proposed. The proposed randomized response (RR) performs much better in general than the existing RR techniques. Theoretical and numerical illustrations identified conditions of superiority of the proposed TORR over the existing comparable optional randomized response (ORR) techniques.     

Mean Estimation Under Successive Sampling with Calibration Estimators

The estimation of the finite population mean in successive occasions is investigated with calibration estimators in this article. We propose several estimators based on calibration techniques with arbitrary sampling design in each of the occasions. Asymptotic variance formulaes are derived for the proposed estimators. The properties of these estimators are studied via a simulation study and using natural populations.     

A EWMA control chart based on an auxiliary variable and repetitive sampling for monitoring process location

ABSTRACT

This article develops an exponentially weighted moving average (EWMA) control chart using an auxiliary variable and repetitive sampling for efficient detection of small to moderate shifts in location. A EWMA statistic of a product estimator of the average (which utilities the information of auxiliary variables as well as repetitive sampling) is plotted on the proposed chart. The control chart coefficients of the proposed EWMA chart are determined for two strategic limits known as outer and inner control limits for the target in-control average run length. The performance of the proposed EWMA chart is studied using average run length when a shift occurs in the process average. The efficiency of the developed chart is compared with the competitive existing control charts. The results of the study revealed that proposed EWMA chart is more efficient than others to detect small changes in process mean.     

Bayesian estimation methods for categorical data with misclassifications

This article considers Bayesian estimation methods for categorical data with misclassifications. To adjust for misclassification, double sampling schemes are utilized. Observations are represented in a contingency table categorized by error-free categorical variables and error-prone categorical variables. Posterior means of probabilities in cells are considered as estimates. In some cases, the posterior means can be calculated exactly. However,in some cases, the exact calculation may be too difficult to perform, but we can easily use the expectation-maximiza-tion(EM) algorithm to obtain approximate posterior means.     

Multi-phase sampling under cost constraints

Multi-phase sampling (M-PhS) scheme is useful when the interest is in the estimation of the population mean of an expensive variable strictly connected with other cheaper (auxiliary) variables. The MSE is an accuracy measure of an estimator. Usually it decreases as the sample size increases. In practice the sample size cannot become arbitrarily large for possible cost constraints. From a practical point of view it would be useful to know the sample sizes which guarantee the best accuracy of the estimates for fixed costs. These “optimum” sample sizes can be, in some cases, computable but not admissible. In other cases, they can be neither admissible nor computable. The main goal of this paper is to propose a solution for both these situations. It will be clear that in both situations the solution is to consider a M-PhS scheme with one or more phases less.     

Balanced k-nearest neighbour imputation

Random imputation is an interesting class of imputation methods to handle item nonresponse because it tends to preserve the distribution of the imputed variable. However, such methods amplify the total variance of the estimators because values are imputed at random. This increase in variance is called imputation variance. In this paper, we propose a new random hot-deck imputation method that is based on the k-nearest neighbour methodology. It replaces the missing value of a unit with the observed value of a similar unit. Calibration and balanced sampling are applied to minimize the imputation variance. Moreover, our proposed method provides triple protection against nonresponse bias. This means that if at least one out of three specified models holds, then the resulting total estimator is unbiased. Finally, our approach allows the user to perform consistency edits and to impute simultaneously.     

On estimation of conditional density models with two-phase sampling

Suppose that the conditional density of a response variable given a vector of explanatory variables is parametrically modelled, and that data are collected by a two-phase sampling design. First, a simple random sample is drawn from the population. The stratum membership in a finite number of strata of the response and explanatory variables is recorded for each unit. Second, a subsample is drawn from the phase-one sample such that the selection probability is determined by the stratum membership. The response and explanatory variables are fully measured at this phase. We synthesize existing results on nonparametric likelihood estimation and present a streamlined approach for the computation and the large sample theory of profile likelihood in four different situations. The amount of information in terms of data and assumptions varies depending on whether the phase-one data are retained, the selection probabilities are known, and/or the stratum probabilities are known. We establish and illustrate numerically the order of efficiency among the maximum likelihood estimators, according to the amount of information utilized, in the four situations.     

New calibration estimator in stratified sampling

This paper develops the theory of calibration estimation and proposes calibration approach alternative to existing calibration estimators for estimating population mean of the study variable using auxiliary variable in stratified sampling. The theory of new calibration estimation is given and optimum weights are derived. A simulation study is carried out to performance of the proposed calibration estimator with other existing calibration estimators. The results reveal that the proposed calibration estimators are more efficient than Tracy et al., Singh et al., Singh calibration estimators of the population mean.     

An improved estimation procedure of population mean in two-occasion successive sampling

ABSTRACT

In this paper an attempt to estimate the current population mean in two-occasion successive sampling has been made. A modified regression-type estimator has been proposed. Optimum replacement strategy of the proposed estimator has been formulated. The proposed estimator is compared with sample mean estimator when there is no matching from the previous occasion and the optimum natural successive sampling estimator. Empirical studies are carried out and suitable recommendations have been made.