A note on a parametric extension of rank tests to the analysis of multifactor experiments within blocks

A general rank test procedure based on an underlying multinomial distribution is suggested for randomized block experiments with multifactor treatment combinations within each block. The Wald statistic for the multinomial is used to test hypotheses about the within–block rankings. This statistic is shown to be related to the one–sample Hotellingt's T² statistic, suggesting a method for computing the test statistic using the standard statistical computer packages.     

The X2-goodness-of-fit tests with moment type estimators

In the x²-goodness-of-fit test the underlying null hypothesis usually involves unknown parameters. In this article we study the asymptotic distribution of the Pearson statistic when the unknown parameters are estimated by a moment type estimator based on the ungrouped data. As is expected the usual Pearson statistic is no longer asymptotically x²-distributed in this situation. We propose a statistic [Qcirc] which under certain regularity conditions is asymptotically x²-distributed. We also propose a statistic Q? for the goodness-of-fit test when the class boundaries are random. The asymptotic powers of [Qcirc] and [Qcirc]? tests are discussed.     

The weighted compounding of probabilities from three independent hypothesis tests

Tail probabilities from three independent hypothesis tests can be combined to form a test statistic of the form P₁,P₂ ^θ2,P₃ ^θ3.The null distribution of the combined test statistic is presented and critical values for α=0.01 and 0.05 are provided.The power of this test is discussed for the special case ofthree independent F-tests.     

Small sample distribution for a nonparametric test for trend

The exact distribution of a nonparametric test statistic for ordered alternatives, the _rank ² statistic, is computed for small sample sizes. The exact distribution is compared to an approximation.     

A test for bivariate two sample location problem

A consistent test for difference in locations between two bivariate populations is proposed, The test is similar as the Mann-Whitney test and depends on the exceedances of slopes of the two samples where slope for each sample observation is computed by taking the ratios of the observed values. In terms of the slopes, it reduces to a univariate problem, The power of the test has been compared with those of various existing tests by simulation. The proposed test statistic is compared with Mardia's(1967) test statistics, Peters-Randies(1991) test statistic, Wilcoxon's rank sum test. statistic and Hotelling' T² test statistic using Monte Carlo technique. It performs better than other statistics compared for small differences in locations between two populations when underlying population is population 7(light tailed population) and sample size 15 and 18 respectively. When underlying population is population 6(heavy tailed population) and sample sizes are 15 and 18 it performas better than other statistic compared except Wilcoxon's rank sum test statistics for small differences in location between two populations. It performs better than Mardia's(1967) test statistic for large differences in location between two population when underlying population is bivariate normal mixture with probability p=0.5, population 6, Pearson type II population and Pearson type VII population for sample size 15 and 18 .Under bivariate normal population it performs as good as Mardia' (1967) test statistic for small differences in locations between two populations and sample sizes 15 and 18. For sample sizes 25 and 28 respectively it performs better than Mardia's (1967) test statistic when underlying population is population 6, Pearson type II population and Pearson type VII population     

Optimizing the wald-wolfowitz runs statistic using a linkage tolerance: guidelines based on computer simulation

When performing the Wald-Wolfowitz runs test, observations from two samples are combined and ordered, and the test statistic is the number of sequences of observations from the same sample. This test statistic is equivalent to the number of links between observations from different samples, if we consider each observation to be linked to the next higher and next lower observations. While it is known that the Wald-Wolfowitz runs test is not very powerful, what would be the effect on the power of the Wald-Wolfowitz runs test if all observations within a specified Euclidean distance or “tolerance” were linked instead? This question is motivated by the simulation results of Whaley and Quade (1985), who found that for normal data, the power of the multi-dimensional runs test using a linkage tolerance compared favorably to Hotelling's T² in some instances. The results of a similar simulation procedure show that the power of the Wald-Wolfowitz runs test does indeed improve when observations are linked using a tolerance. The results also suggest that a better large sample approximation to the distribution of the test statistic needs to be found.     

Analyzing multiple end points with a two-stage design in clinical trials

In many clinical trials, the assessment of the response to interventions can include a large variety of outcome variables which are generally correlated. The use of multiple significance tests is likely to increase the chance of detecting a difference in at least one of the outcomes between two treatments. Furthermore, univariate tests do not take into account the correlation structure. A new test is proposed that uses information from the interim analysis in a two-stage design to form the rejection region boundaries at the second stage. Initially, the test uses Hotelling’s T² at the end of the first stage allowing only, for early acceptance of the null hypothesis and an O’Brien ‘type’ procedure at the end of the second stage. This test allows one to ‘cheat’ and look at the data at the interim analysis to form rejection regions at the second stage, provided one uses the correct distribution of the final test statistic. This distribution is derived and the power of the new test is compared to the power of three common procedures for testing multiple outcomes: Bonferroni’s inequality, Hotelling’s T²and O’Brien’s test. O’Brien’s test has the best power to detect a difference when the outcomes are thought to be affected in exactly the same direction and the same magnitude or in exactly the same relative effects as those proposed prior to data collection. However, the statistic is not robust to deviations in the alternative parameters proposed a priori, especially for correlated outcomes. The proposed new statistic and the derivation of its distribution allows investigators to consider information from the first stage of a two-stage design and consequently base the final test on the direction observed at the first stage or modify the statistic if the direction differs significantly from what was expected a prior.     

A test for variance-covarianch parameters in normal linear models

This paper derives a test statistic for the variance-covariance parameters which is a quadratic function of their MINQUE (Minimum Norm Quadratic Unbiased Estimation) estimates. The test is a Wald-type test, and its development closely parallels the theory used to derive a similar test for the coefficients in linear models. In fact, the derivation proceeds by first setting up the estimation problem in a derived linear model in which the dispersion parameters are the coefficients. The test statistic is shown to be the sum of the squares of independent standardized x² variables.     

Asymptotic power comparison of T2-type test and likelihood ratio test for a mean vector based on two-step monotone missing data

Abstract

In a 2-step monotone missing dataset drawn from a multivariate normal population, T²-type test statistic (similar to Hotelling’s T² test statistic) and likelihood ratio (LR) are often used for the test for a mean vector. In complete data, Hotelling’s T² test and LR test are equivalent, however T²-type test and LR test are not equivalent in the 2-step monotone missing dataset. Then we interest which statistic is reasonable with relation to power. In this paper, we derive asymptotic power function of both statistics under a local alternative and obtain an explicit form for difference in asymptotic power function. Furthermore, under several parameter settings, we compare LR and T²-type test numerically by using difference in empirical power and in asymptotic power function. Summarizing obtained results, we recommend applying LR test for testing a mean vector.     

Computations of Bayesian t-values for multiple comparisons

Results from a simulation study of the power of eight statistics for testing that a sample is form a uniform distribution on the unit interval are reported. Power is given for each statistic against four classes if alternatives. The statistics studied include the discrete Pearson chi-square with ten and twenty cells, X² ₁₀ and X² ₂₀; Kolmogorov-smirov, D; Cramer-Von Mises, W²; Watson, U²; Anderson-Darling, A; Greenwood. G;and a new statistic called O A modified form of each of these statistic is also studied by first transforming the sample using a transformation given by Durbin. On the basis of the results observed in this study, the Watson U² statistic is recommended as a general test for uniformity.     

Multivariate analysis of variance with additional data from an unknown subset of the populations

In this paper we consider the problem of testing the means of k multivariate normal populations with additional data from an unknown subset of the k populations. The purpose of this research is to offer test procedures utilizing all the available data for the multivariate analysis of variance problem because the additional data may contain valuable information about the parameters of the k populations. The standard procedure uses only the data from identified populations. We provide a test using all available data based upon Hotelling' s generalized T²statistic. The power of this test is computed using Betz's approximation of Hotelling' s generalized T²statistic by an F-distribution. A comparison of the power of the test and the standard test procedure is also given.     

C326. Ergodicity for time series and spatial processes

A statistic is presented for testing a three state observed Markov chain for independence. The test procedure is compared with the traditional X ² test. Examples are given in which the proposed test has better power than the X ² test.     

Accuracy of Power-Divergence Statistics for Testing Independence and Homogeneity in Two-Way Contingency Tables

The small-sample accuracy of seven members of the family of power-divergence statistics for testing independence or homogeneity in contingency tables was studied via simulation. The likelihood ratio statistic G ² and Pearson's X ² statistic are among these seven members, whose behavior was studied at nominal test sizes of.01 and.05 with marginal distributions that could be uniform or skewed and with a set of sample sizes that included sparseness conditions as measured through table density (i.e., the ratio of sample size to number of cells). The likelihood ratio statistic G ² rejected the null hypothesis too often even with large table density, whereas Pearson's X ² was sufficiently accurate and only presented a minor misbehavior when table density was less than two observations/cell. None of the other five statistics outperformed Pearson's X ². A nonasymptotic variant of X ² solved the minor inaccuracies of Pearson's X ² and turned out to be the most accurate statistic for testing independence or homogeneity, even with table densities of one observation/cell. These results clearly advise against the use of the likelihood ratio statistic G ².     

Small-sample comparisons for powerdivergence goodness-of-fit statistics for symmetric and skewed simple null hypotheses

Power-divergence goodness-of-fit statistics have asymptotically a chi-squared distribution. Asymptotic results may not apply in small-sample situations, and the exact significance of a goodness-of-fit statistic may potentially be over- or under-stated by the asymptotic distribution. Several correction terms have been proposed to improve the accuracy of the asymptotic distribution, but their performance has only been studied for the equiprobable case. We extend that research to skewed hypotheses. Results are presented for one-way multinomials involving k = 2 to 6 cells with sample sizes N = 20, 40, 60, 80 and 100 and nominal test sizes f = 0.1, 0.05, 0.01 and 0.001. Six power-divergence goodness-of-fit statistics were investigated, and five correction terms were included in the study. Our results show that skewness itself does not affect the accuracy of the asymptotic approximation, which depends only on the magnitude of the smallest expected frequency (whether this comes from a small sample with the equiprobable hypothesis or a large sample with a skewed hypothesis). Throughout the conditions of the study, the accuracy of the asymptotic distribution seems to be optimal for Pearson's X² statistic (the power-divergence statistic of index u = 1) when k > 3 and the smallest expected frequency is as low as between 0.1 and 1.5 (depending on the particular k, N and nominal test size), but a computationally inexpensive improvement can be obtained in these cases by using a moment-corrected h² distribution. If the smallest expected frequency is even smaller, a normal correction yields accurate tests through the log-likelihood-ratio statistic G² (the power-divergence statistic of index u = 0).     

Testing for linearity in Markov switching models: a bootstrap approach

Testing for linearity in the context of Markov switching models is complicated because standard regularity conditions for likelihood based inference are violated. In particular, under the null hypothesis of linearity, some parameters are not identified and scores are identically zero. Thus, the asymptotic distribution of the relevant test statistic does not possess the standard χ ²-distribution. A bootstrap resampling scheme to approximate the distribution of the relevant test statistic under the null of linearity is proposed. The procedure is relatively easy to program and computation requirements are reasonable. The performance of the bootstrap-based test is investigated by means of Monte Carlo simulations. Results show that this test works well and outperforms the Hansen test and the Carrasco et al. test.     

Comments on “a generalization of fisher's exact test in pxq contingency tables using more concordant relations”

The purpose of this note is to criticize Nguyen (1985) for his account of the literature on the generalization of Fisher's exact test and to point out parallels with existing algorithms of the algorithm proposed by Nguyen. Subsequently we will briefly raise some questions on the methodology proposed by Nguyen.

Nguyen (1985) suggests that all literature on exact testing prior to Nguyen & Sampson (1985) is based on the “more probable” relation or Exact Probability Test (EPT) as a test statistic. This is not correct. Yates (1934 - Pearson's X²), Lewontin & Felsenstein (1965 - X²), Agresti & Wackerly (1977 - X², Kendall's tau, Kruskal & Goodman's gamma), Klotz (1966 - Wilcoxon), Klotz & Teng (1977 - Kruskall & Wallis' H), Larntz (1978 - X², loglike-lihood-ratio statistic G², Freeman & Tukey statistic), and several others have investigated exact tests with other statistics than the EPT. In fact, Bennett & Nakamura (1963) are incorrectly cited as they investigated both X² and G², rather than EPT. Also, Freeman & Halton (1951) are incorrectly cited for they generalized Fisher's exact test to pxq tables and not 2xq tables as stated. And they are even predated by Yates (1934) who extended the test to 2×3 tables.     

A test statistic for weighted runs

A new test statistic based on runs of weighted deviations is introduced. Its use for observations sampled from independent normal distributions is worked out in detail. It supplements the classic χ² test which ignores the ordering of observations and provides additional sensitivity to local deviations from expectations. The exact distribution of the statistic in the non-parametric case is derived and an algorithm to compute p-values is presented. The computational complexity of the algorithm is derived employing a novel identity for integer partitions.     

Improved testing for the binomial distribution using chi-squared components with data-dependent cells

A power study suggests that a good test of fit analysis for the binomial distribution is provided by a data-dependent Chernoff–Lehmann X ² test with class expectations greater than unity, and its components. These data-dependent statistics involve arithmetically simple parameter estimation, convenient approximate distributions and provide a comprehensive assessment of how well the data agree with a binomial distribution. We suggest that a well-performed single test of fit statistic is the Anderson–Darling statistic.     

An Adjustment to the Bartlett's Test for Small Sample Size

The Bartlett's test (1937) for equality of variances is based on the χ² distribution approximation. This approximation deteriorates either when the sample size is small (particularly < 4) or when the population number is large. According to a simulation investigation, we find a similar varying trend for the mean differences between empirical distributions of Bartlett's statistics and their χ² approximations. By using the mean differences to represent the distribution departures, a simple adjustment approach on the Bartlett's statistic is proposed on the basis of equal mean principle. The performance before and after adjustment is extensively investigated under equal and unequal sample sizes, with number of populations varying from 3 to 100. Compared with the traditional Bartlett's statistic, the adjusted statistic is distributed more closely to χ² distribution, for homogeneity samples from normal populations. The type I error is well controlled and the power is a little higher after adjustment. In conclusion, the adjustment has good control on the type I error and higher power, and thus is recommended for small samples and large population number when underlying distribution is normal.     

Omnibus tests for the error distribution in the linear regression model

Test procedures are constructed for testing the goodness-of-fit of the error distribution in the regression context. The test statistic is based on an L ²-type distance between the characteristic function of the (assumed) error distribution and the empirical characteristic function of the residuals. The asymptotic null distribution as well as the behavior of the test statistic under contiguous alternatives is investigated, while the issue of the choice of suitable estimators has been particularly emphasized. Theoretical results are accompanied by a simulation study.