Comparing three bootstrap methods for survey data

Various bootstrap methods for variance estimation and confidence intervals in complex survey data, where sampling is done without replacement, have been proposed in the literature. The oldest, and perhaps the most intuitively appealing, is the without-replacement bootstrap (BWO) method proposed by Gross (1980). Unfortunately, the BWO method is only applicable to very simple sampling situations. We first introduce extensions of the BWO method to more complex sampling designs. The performance of the BWO and two other bootstrap methods, the rescaling bootstrap (Rao and Wu 1988) and the mirror-match bootstrap (Sitter 1992), are then compared through a simulation study. Together these three methods encompass the various bootstrap proposals.     

Second-order approximations of finite population L-statistics

We construct Edgeworth and empirical Edgeworth approximations to distribution functions of finite population L-statistics and compare their accuracy with that of the normal approximation and the bootstrap approximation in a simulation study.     

Using jackknife in nonlinear models - confidence regions for a function of the structural parameter

A method of constructing jackknife confidence regions for a function of the structural parameter of a nonlinear model is investigated. The method is available for nonlinear regression models as well as for models with errors in the variables. Properties are discussed in comparison with traditional methods. This is supported by a simulation study.     

A comparison of alternative variance estimation strategies for estimating the slope of a linear regression in sample surveys

The balanced half-sample, jackknife and linearization methods are used to estimate the variance of the slope of a linear regression under a variety of computer generated situations. The basic sampling design is one in which two PSU's are selected from each of a number of strata . The variance estimation techniques are compared with a Monte Carlo experiment. Results show that variance estimates may be highly biased and variable unless sizeable numbers of observations are available from each stratum. The jackknife and linearization estimates appear superior to the balanced half sample method - particularly when the number of strata or the number of available observations from each stratum is small.     

Confidence intervals for the interrater agreement measure kappa

The asympotic normal approximation to the distribution of the estimated measure [kcirc] for evaluating agreement between two raters has been shown to perform poorly for small sample sizes when the true kappa is nonzero. This paper examines the use of skewness corrections and transformations of [kcirc] on the attained confidence levels. Small sample simulations demonstrate the improvement in the agreement between the desired and actual levels of confidence intervals and hypothesis tests that incorporate these corrections.     

Nonparametric standard errors and confidence intervals

We investigate several nonparametric methods; the bootstrap, the jackknife, the delta method, and other related techniques. The first and simplest goal is the assignment of nonparametric standard errors to a real-valued statistic. More ambitiously, we consider setting nonparametric confidence intervals for a real-valued parameter. Building on the well understood case of confidence intervals for the median, some hopeful evidence is presented that such a theory may be possible.     

A note on the two-sample mean problem based on jackknife empirical likelihood

In this article, we employ the jackknife empirical likelihood (JEL) method to construct the confidence regions for the difference of the means of two d-dimensional samples. Compared with traditional EL for the two-sample mean problem, JEL is extremely simpler to use in practice and is more effective in computing. Based on the JEL ratio test, a version of Wilks’ theorem is developed. Furthermore, to improve the coverage accuracy of confidence regions, a Bartlett correction is applied. The effectiveness of the proposed method is demonstrated by a simulation study and a real data analysis.     

Reduce computation in profile empirical likelihood method

Since its introduction by Owen (1988, 1990), the empirical likelihood method has been extensively investigated and widely used to construct confidence regions and to test hypotheses in the literature. For a large class of statistics that can be obtained via solving estimating equations, the empirical likelihood function can be formulated from these estimating equations as proposed by Qin and Lawless (1994). If only a small part of parameters is of interest, a profile empirical likelihood method has to be employed to construct confidence regions, which could be computationally costly. In this article the authors propose a jackknife empirical likelihood method to overcome this computational burden. This proposed method is easy to implement and works well in practice. The Canadian Journal of Statistics 39: 370–384; 2011 © 2011 Statistical Society of Canada