Properties of the beta regression model for small area estimation of proportions and application to estimation of poverty rates

Abstract

Linear mixed effects models have been popular in small area estimation problems for modeling survey data when the sample size in one or more areas is too small for reliable inference. However, when the data are restricted to a bounded interval, the linear model may be inappropriate, particularly if the data are near the boundary. Nonlinear sampling models are becoming increasingly popular for small area estimation problems when the normal model is inadequate. This paper studies the use of a beta distribution as an alternative to the normal distribution as a sampling model for survey estimates of proportions which take values in (0, 1). Inference for small area proportions based on the posterior distribution of a beta regression model ensures that point estimates and credible intervals take values in (0, 1). Properties of a hierarchical Bayesian small area model with a beta sampling distribution and logistic link function are presented and compared to those of the linear mixed effect model. Propriety of the posterior distribution using certain noninformative priors is shown, and behavior of the posterior mean as a function of the sampling variance and the model variance is described. An example using 2010 Small Area Income and Poverty Estimates (SAIPE) data is given, and a numerical example studying small sample properties of the model is presented.