A new criterion of confidence set estimation: Improvement of the Neyman shortness

In past studies various criteria have been proposed for evaluating the performance of a confidence set. However, each of these criteria often causes some unsatisfactory results even for the standard models such as location model, scale model and multinormal model. In this article, we propose a new criterion so that the procedure of the confidence set estimation based on the criterion can lead to a desirable confidence set at least for the above models. The approach is on the basis of an improvement of the Neyman shortness according to two steps. The first step is some kind of theoretical improvement, referring to a proposal of Pratt. As a result, we get a solution to Pratt's paradox. In the second step, we adopt a kind of robust or minimax procedure without sticking to the uniform optimality. In conclusion, it is shown that the procedure based on our criterion produces a desirable and acceptable confidence set.