没有思想的学问和没有学问的思想——对当前文学研究界某些现象的批评

近几年的文学研究界 ,常见没有思想的学问和没有学问的思想。除了道德的层面、技术的层面 ,“学术规范”更重要的是应当指向学理的层面、思想的层面。如果一篇论文经过寻章摘句 ,旁求远绍 ,能求一义 ,征一理 ,也算是有思想有价值 ,但连考据的功夫的都没学到或不愿烦劳 ,嚼人剩饭 ,还要多谈“学术” ,那可真是奈何不得也么哥了。相反如果是冠之以“酷评” ,社会评论派的文章若能有理有据 ,又何以不能作为有价值的学术看待呢 ?

Knowledge without Thought and Thought without Knowledge

The literary circle in recent years has the phenomenon of pursuing knowledge without thought and thought without knowledge.Besides moral and technical commitment,academic norms should be orientated towards both knowledge and thought.A“serious”article without conscientious and careful investigation and first hand data is not of much worth.In contrast,a“cool” article with solid foundation is of academic value.