卡利克勒斯论自然正义

苏格拉底与卡利克勒斯的争论被视为<高尔吉亚>的高潮,卡利克勒斯的这一长篇讲辞被视为西方政治哲学史上最精彩的非道德主义讲辞.细致绎读卡利克勒斯的讲辞,认为他并非一个简单的非道德主义者,而是企图建立一套不同于苏格拉底式的自然正义理论,即强者正义观;苏格拉底与卡利克勒斯的争论是两种不同的自然正义观之争,是政治与哲学之争.

Callicles on Natural Justice

The dispute between Socrates and Callicles is generally considered the climax of Gorgias,and Callicles' long speech the most eloquent statement of the immoralist's case in European literature.Through a close reading of his speech,the essay attempts to indicate that Callicles,rather than a simple immoralist,is a moral lawgiver,by a different means,of natural justice doctrine contrary to Socrates',and the quarrel between Socrates and Callicles is one between two opposing natural justice doctrines and between ...