农业科技论文学术水平的编辑把握

提出了农业科技期刊编辑可以从稿件的选题、试验设计及数据的客观性等方面入手把握稿件的学术水平。通过查阅文献、问询专家等途径了解选题是否有新意;通过分析试验设计中是否设置对照、对照设置是否正确、是否设有重复、取样有无代表性及是否考虑了供试条件的背景值等方面对试验设计的科学性进行把握;凭借专业知识、问询有关专家和(或)查阅国家(或行业)标准来判断数据的客观性。编辑可提高对论文的学术鉴别能力和审稿水平,进而提高期刊的学术质量。

Editorial Grasp of Academic Quality about Scientific Papers in Agriculture

Academic quality of scientific papers in agriculture may be grasped by editors through analyzing the selecting topics,experimental design and the data from the research.By looking up literature,consulting standard and asking the specialists,editors may judge whether the selecting topics are new and can check whether experimental design is correct and can analyze whether the research results are reliable.