一代人有一代人之学术——从《红学学案》到《金学学案》

"红学"若无"史"可鉴,它的发展也就没有方向;当然,"金学"若无"史"可鉴,它的发展也同样没有方向。"红学史"著述已见规模,"金学史"著述有待跟进。红学史常见的写法基本上是或"通史"写法,或"专题史"写法,尚未看到这种"以学人为主线,逐一立案考述"为旨趣的红学史著。于是,《红学学案》的撰述则立意出新,试图写出"似旧而新"的"学案体"或"学案性质"的红学史著述,以"学人"为主线建构红学史著述新体例、新格局。庶几可不拘格套,另辟蹊径,换一种眼光看红学。《金学学案》可谓《红学学案》写作模式的全方位地移植,即《红学学案》的学术理念、写作原则和写作方法以及整体构想等都对《金学学案》具有直接的借鉴意义。

The Academic of Different Generations From The Dream of Red Mansions Case Studies to The Golden Lotus Case Studies

The study of The Dream of Red Mansions will lose its direction without its history as references,the same case with the study of The Golden Lotus,the former made great achievements,while the latter needs further studies.In the past,General History writing or Specific Subject History writing is the widely used writing method in The Dream of Red Mansions Studies,now the book The Dream of Red Mansions Case Studies creates a different writing method,i.e.case body or case character writing style,it takes the researchers who study The Dream of Red Mansions as the core to construct a history of The Dream of Red Mansions Studies,which is an innovative way in this filed.The Golden Lotus Case Studies can be called as a complete transplant of The Dream of Red Mansions Case Studies because the latter provide direct references for the former in that the academic ideas,writing principle,writing method and the general thought of The Dream of Red Mansions Case Studies are adopted in The Golden Lotus Case Studies.