嫖宿幼女罪若干疑难问题研究

嫖宿幼女本身的犯罪事实是成立的,只是对于其某些成立要件的理解上存在若干疑难从而引发争议。该罪的司法认定中有两方面的疑难需要厘清,即,区分预备与未遂形态的标志在于双方是否达成了合意;行为人的承诺给付利益和幼女的承诺卖淫,并不以真实意思为必要条件。但在立法层面上,该罪名的独立却导致了刑法理论上和司法实践中的诸多矛盾,应当予以废止。

On Several Difficult Problems of the Offence of Whoring Girls Under 14 Years Old

The fact itself of whoring the girls under 14 years old is an offense,but there are several difficulties in the explanation of its certain established condition,thus some disputes appear.We should clear two difficult problems in the practice of justice,namely,the sign that distinguishes preparation and failed is whether both sides reach to suit;both the convict's promise of paying benefit and the girl's promise of prostitution,even if it is false,do not influence the establishment of this crime.But,in legislative layer,the independence of this crime has caused many contradictions in criminal theory and judicial practice,so we should abolish it.