父母殴打子女致死案件的类型化处理

父母殴打子女致死的案件每每出现都引发了极大的社会反响,法院在审理过程中对该类案件如何认定存在争议,从对现有已收集到的案例进行整理发现,个案裁判结果差异极大.由于在该类案件中殴打与伤害难以区分、殴打的主观方面难以确定、殴打多出于一时激愤等特殊性,导致在具体案件认定上存在一定的难度.应当遵循从客观到主观的认识路径,在对行为进行全方位评价的基础上,通过“向前看”和“向后看”,对行为人的主观方面进行辅助分析,从殴打对象和部位选择、殴打行为的具体目的、是否存在长期虐待等方面加以考量.

Categorizing and Dealing with the Cases of Parents Beating the Children to Death

The public strongly backlasbes against the events that children are beaten to death by their parents. In respect of those cases, disputes arise during the trial and the decisions of courts vary vastly based on the analysis of the cases at hand. Those cases remain thorny because it is hard to distinguish the beating against the injury and define the mens rea of the actor. Therefore, the idea that objective facts first should be held on, and by looking backward and forward to analyze the mens rea of the actor, factors like the specified part of the children＇ s body being beaten, the purpose of parents beating up children etc should be considered in the full assessment of the acts of the parents.