环境政策的道德含量评估:理路与框架

环境政策道德含量是指环境政策中所包含的道德量。由于环境政策具有相对独立性,社会道德具有相对静止性,因而环境政策道德含量能够被评估。环境政策道德含量评估的核心要素是政策和道德,二者共同决定了环境政策道德含量评估指标生成的逻辑,即政策过程、道德形态分别决定了环境政策道德含量评估一级指标和二级指标各自的生成逻辑。环境政策道德含量评估的一级指标由政策自身的道德基础、政策关系的道德原则、政策执行的道德后果共同构成,环境政策道德含量评估的二级指标由政治道德、经济道德、社会道德、生态道德共同构成。环境政策道德含量评估的二级指标决定环境政策道德含量评估的实测指标,即由政治道德、经济道德、社会道德、生态道德生成相应的实测指标。环境政策评估的框架主要包括环境政策评估的模型、主体和操作。评估模型即为对应实测指标的特定环境政策的道德因子得分测算方法。评估主体即由环境政策制定者、环境政策受用者、专业机构组成。评估操作分为四个步骤,分别是提取道德因子、汇总道德因子实际得分、测算环境政策的道德含量、评估环境政策的质量。

Evaluation of the Moral Content of Environmental Policy: Logic and Framework

The moral content of environmental policy refers to the moral quantity contained in environmental policy. Because environmental policy is relatively independent and social morality is relatively static,so the content of environmental policy morality can be evaluated. The core elements of environmental policy moral content assessment are policy and ethics,which together determine the logic of the generation of environmental policy ethical content evaluation indicators. Then the policy process and the moral form determine the generating logic of the primary index and the generating logic of the secondary index respectively. The primary index of the moral content of environmental policy consists of the moral foundation of the policy itself,the moral principles of the policy relations,and the moral consequences of the policy implementation. The secondary index of environmental policy moral content assessment is composed of political morality,economic morality,social morality and ecological morality. The secondary index of environmental policy moral content evaluation determines the measured index of environmental policy moral content evaluation,that is,the measured index produced by political morality,economic morality,social morality,and ecological morality.The framework of environmental policy assessment mainly includes the model,main body and operation of environmental policy evaluation. The assessment model is the ratio of the actual moral score of the specific environmental policy to the total social morality. The assessment body consists of environmental policy makers,recipients of environmental policies and professional structures. The evaluation operation is divided into four steps:extracting the moral elements,collecting the actual scores of the moral elements,measuring the moral content of environmental policies,and evaluating the quality of environmental policies.