论姚际恒《仪礼通论》

《仪礼通论》为清初学者姚际恒所著《九经通论》之一,原书久佚,近年被发现后,引起学界高度关注,被视为清初反传统的重要著作。本文认为,姚氏此书的学术趋向,以追随风行于清初的元儒敖继公、明儒郝敬之说为主,绝少创见,故不存在反传统的问题。姚氏轻诋郑玄而失之草率,暗用贾公彦疏而不注出处,勇于议论而流于肤浅,是为率尔操觚之作,学术价值不高。

A New Study on Yao Jiheng's Yi Li Tong Lun

Yi Li Tong Lun by YAO Jiheng, a scholar in early Qing Dynasty, was refound recently and considered as a major anti-traditional work of that time. This paper claims that YAO followed the popular academic character of AO Jigong and HAO Jing, and put forward little original idea, hence his book is not an anti-traditional masterpiece. YAO rebuked ZHENG Xuan's notes hastily, copied JIA Gongyan's notes on the sly. His arguments were crude, superficial and of low academic status.