Estimation for u-shaped beta distributions: minimum hellinger distance and related methods

We compare minimum Hellinger distance and minimum Heiiinger disparity estimates for U-shaped beta distributions. Given suitable density estimates, both methods are known to be asymptotically efficient when the data come from the assumed model family, and robust to small perturbations from the model family. Most implementations use kernel density estimates, which may not be appropriate for U-shaped distributions. We compare fixed binwidth histograms, percentile mesh histograms, and averaged shifted histograms. Minimum disparity estimates are less sensitive to the choice of density estimate than are minimum distance estimates, and the percentile mesh histogram gives the best results for both minimum distance and minimum disparity estimates. Minimum distance estimates are biased and a bias-corrected method is proposed. Minimum disparity estimates and bias-corrected minimum distance estimates are comparable to maximum likelihood estimates when the model holds, and give better results than either method of moments or maximum likelihood when the data are discretized or contaminated, Although our re¬sults are for the beta density, the implementations are easily modified for other U-shaped distributions such as the Dirkhlet or normal generated distribution.