A New Method for Statistical Multidimensional Unfolding

ABSTRACT

Consider the problem of estimating the positions of a set of targets in a multidimensional Euclidean space from distances reported by a number of observers when the observers do not know their own positions in the space. Each observer reports the distance from the observer to each target plus a random error. This statistical problem is the basic model for the various forms of what is called multidimensional unfolding in the psychometric literature. Multidimensional unfolding methodology as developed in the field of cognitive psychology is basically a statistical estimation problem where the data structure is a set of measures that are monotonic functions of Euclidean distances between a number of observers and targets in a multidimensional space. The new method presented in this article deals with estimating the target locations and the observer positions when the observations are functions of the squared distances between observers and targets observed with an additive random error in a two-dimensional space. The method provides robust estimates of the target locations in a multidimensional space for the parametric structure of the data generating model presented in the article. The method also yields estimates of the orientation of the coordinate system and the mean and variances of the observer locations. The mean and the variances are not estimated by standard unfolding methods which yield targets maps that are invariant to a rotation of the coordinate system. The data is transformed so that the nonlinearity due to the squared observer locations is removed. The sampling properties of the estimates are derived from the asymptotic variances of the additive errors of a maximum likelihood factor analysis of the sample covariance matrix of the transformed data augmented with bootstrapping. The robustness of the new method is tested using artificial data. The method is applied to a 2001 survey data set from Turkey to provide a real data example.