评《回到马克思》的“历史现象学”

“历史现象学”是《回到马克思》一书“最重要的理论发现”。为了这个发现 ,作者质疑哲学的历史唯物主义在科学上的合法性 ,认为《德意志意识形态》在理论构建上不成功。但是 ,作者发现的“历史现象学” ,只不过是马克思透视本质的经济分析方法。这样 ,所谓“历史现象学”就难免在内容上以经济学遮蔽哲学 ,在名称上又以哲学遮蔽经济学。

A Review of "Historical Phenomenology" in Back to Marx

Historical Phenomenology" was one of the most important findings in Back to Marx. For his findings, the author doubted the legality of historical materialism in science and held that German Ideology was unsuccessful in its theoretical construction. But the "historical phenomenology" the author proposed was just a method of economic analysis that Marx had used to see through the essence. Therefore, the so called "historical phenomenology" inevitably resulted in shading philosophy with economics in the content, and conversely shading economics with philosophy in the name.