版本传播与选诗态度——关于钱钟书《宋诗选注》中一个看法的考辨

著名学者钱钟书先生在《宋诗选注》中提出阅读前人诗歌选集时应有保留，因其选集大多比较草率，比如清代吴之振、吕留良合编的《宋诗钞》所选的刘克庄诗作，只选了刘氏前十六卷的作品，卷十七至卷四十八的作品一首也没有选录。本文考察了刘克庄集子在宋元明清之际的流传情况，结论是吴吕二人未选刘氏后期之作，并非态度草率所致，而是因为他们根本没有见过卷十七以后的诗。

Analysis of a View Posed in Qian Zhong-shu's Selected and Annotated Poems of the Song Dynasty

In his Selected and Annoated Poems of the Song Dynasty, Mr. Qian Zhong-shu proposes thatpeople should have reservation when they read selections of poeme compiled by careless predecessors. He givesan example of Selected Poeme of the Song Dynasty by Wu Zhi-zhen and Lu Liu-liang in the Qing Dynasty, inwhich the two editors only select Liu Ke-zhuang's earlier poems without mentioning his later ones. The authorinspects the spread of Liu's whole works during the Song, Yuan, Ming and Qing Dynashes and finds tha theonission is oot due to Wu ed hu's carelessness, for they de not see any liu's later pems at all.