论抵押权与质押权的竞合

动产抵押制度的产生适应了经济发展的需求,但同时也带来了法学理论和实践中抵押权与质押权竞合的问题。本文采用比较法分析、法律经济学分析及实证分析等方法对二者竞合条件下的效力进行了论述,认为不能简单地采用占有优先原则、登记优先原则或设定优先原则,而应在动产抵押采登记对抗主义公示原则的前提下,区分是否登记以及确定抵押与质押的设立顺序后,判断二者竞合条件下的效力

On Competition and Shut of Hypothec and Hypothecate

The production of chattel mortgage meets the demand of the competition and shut of hypothec and hypothecate in theory and practice at the same time. This article analyses this problem by the comparative law, legal economic analysis and real example analysis method. This article thinks that we should not only adopt one of the principles of occupy priority, register priority or set priority, should judge the effect at the prerequisite of adopting the register and oppose doctrine, distinguish the chattel weather be registered and confirm the order of the set time.