私人利益与表达自由著作权法立法价值之辩

由于权利客体的特殊性,著作权法的立法价值一直摇摆于激励经济收益与促进表达自由之间,针对信息产权化的弊端,著作权法被认为应该包含更高位阶的法律价值。然而,这种立法价值混搭,导致了著作权权利体系的混乱。因此,著作权法应回归到激励机制的模型下,而多元化的立法价值,应由针对不同调整对象,处于不同效力位阶的法律分别承担,只在著作权法追求的经济价值与主张表达自由的法律出现冲突时,再按照权利的位阶考虑对著作权的限制。

Private Interests and Expression Freedom:A Dispute over the Legislative Value of the Copyright Law

Due to the unique characteristic of the object of the right,the legislative value of the Copyright Law lies continuously between the incentive function on the economic interests and the promotion on the expression freedom.Because of the drawbacks of the information property rights,the Copyright Law is expected to include some higher legislative value.However,this legislative value is a messy mix,bringing disorder to the Copyright Law system.Therefore,the Copyright Law should return back to its incentive mec...