Abstract: | The mid-p-value is the standard p-value for a test minus half the difference between it and the nearest lower possible value. Its smaller size lends it an obvious appeal to users — it provides a more significant-looking summary of the evidence against the null hypothesis. This paper examines the possibility that the user might overstate the significance of the evidence by using the smaller mid-p in place of the standard p-value. Routine use of the mid-p is shown to control a quantity related to the Type I error rate. This related quantity is appropriate to consider when the decision to accept or reject the null hypothesis is not always firm. The natural, subjective interpretation of a p-value as the probability that the null hypothesis is true is also examined. The usual asymptotic correspondence between these two probabilities for one-sided hypotheses is shown to be strengthened when the standard p-value is replaced by the mid-p. |