Some determinant optimality aspects of main effect fold-over designs

Saha and Mohanty (1970) presented a main effect fold-over design consisting of 14 treatment combinations of the 24×33 factorial, which had the nice property of being even balanced. Calling this design DSM, this paper establishes the following specific results: (i) DSM is not d-optimal in the subclass Δe of all 14 point even balanced main effect fold-over designs of the 24×33 factorial; (ii) DSM is not d-optimal in the subclass $\text{Δ}{}^1\text{?Δ}{}^{\mathrm{e}}$ of all 14 point even and odd balanced main effect fold-over designs of the 24×33 factorial; (iii) DSM is even optimal in $\text{Δ}{}^1$ and Δe. In addition to these results two 14 point designs in $\text{Δ}{}^1$ are presented which are d-optimal and via a counter example it is shown that these designs are not odd optimal. Finally, several general matrix algebra results are given which should be useful in resolving d-optimality problems of fold-over designs of the kn11×kn22 factorial.